Dear ROGER,

Welcome to the October 2024 issue of Key Notes - Marketing Keys' monthly newsletter! We hope you are enjoying the beautiful Fall season! Key Notes is an informative, quick-read newsletter to get you caught up on all things media and marketing. Our goal is for you to be informed and entertained with the latest media and marketing happenings quickly and efficiently. 

In the digital age, it’s becoming harder to tell the difference between paid political ads and organic political messaging, especially on social media. Research shows that even people who are politically aware and well-educated often struggle to grasp the complexities behind online political ads. This confusion is linked to a lack of understanding about how these ads are targeted, funded, and regulated compared to commercial ads.

Political advertisements have more protection under the First Amendment than commercial ads, as they are considered crucial for a functioning democracy. While the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) oversees commercial ads to prevent misleading consumers, it does not regulate political messaging. The Federal Election Commission (FEC) is responsible for political ads, but its regulations mainly cover traditional media formats, such as TV and radio, leaving social media platforms with inconsistent rules and guidelines.

Some social media platforms provide transparency tools, such as ad libraries, to help users identify who is funding ads. However, these tools often require a lot of effort and investigation from users, making it difficult for the average person to determine the true sources of political messages. With regulations not fully adapted to the online environment, the clarity of information is not guaranteed.

To navigate this, citizens need to boost their understanding of political advertising, especially as the election approaches. Using educational resources like fact-checking sites and online quizzes can help voters become more discerning. By improving their political ad literacy, voters can better evaluate the messages they receive and make informed decisions when casting their ballots.

Google has decided to continue supporting third-party cookies in Chrome browsers beyond next year, marking a shift from its earlier plan to phase them out. The tech company initially aimed to replace cookies with a new technology called "Privacy Sandbox," designed to enhance user privacy while maintaining ad functionality. However, due to industry and regulatory pressure, Google has chosen to keep cookies for now while allowing users to control their preferences. The new approach will offer people the ability to make informed choices about cookies and adjust their settings as needed.

This reversal marks a significant change for Google, which has been signaling the end of third-party cookies since 2019. The delay reflects concerns from advertisers and publishers about how removing cookies could impact their business models. While the Privacy Sandbox technology shows potential, especially in maintaining ad spend and conversions, it still struggles with targeted advertising efforts. Google plans to continue developing the system and is in discussions with industry stakeholders and regulators to ensure it aligns with current standards.

Early tests of the Privacy Sandbox have produced varied outcomes. Google's advertising team reported that while ad spend and conversion rates showed high recovery percentages, the technology did not perform as well in retargeting campaigns, which are a vital aspect of digital advertising. Some industry players have been slow to adopt the new platform, partly due to fears of reduced revenue. As a result, Google faces challenges in gaining widespread support for its new system among ad tech vendors and publishers.

Additionally, Google announced an update aimed at boosting privacy for users in Chrome’s Incognito mode. This feature, called "IP Protection," will conceal users' IP addresses, making it harder to track their online activity. Google’s ongoing efforts to balance user privacy with advertising needs are under regulatory scrutiny, particularly in the U.K., as authorities evaluate the impact these changes may have on the advertising ecosystem.

The landscape of television advertising is shifting dramatically, with streaming ad revenues struggling to keep pace with declining linear TV revenue. A recent forecast predicts a 1.7% decrease in total TV ad revenue in the U.S. for 2024, excluding major events like presidential elections and the Olympics. In contrast, streaming ad revenue is set to grow by 19.3% this year, while linear TV experiences a notable decline of 6.8%. This disparity underscores the pressing need for industry stakeholders to adapt their strategies in response to evolving viewer habits.

With the number of households subscribing to cable expected to drop below 50% by the end of the year, advertisers are under increasing pressure to deliver results across a fragmented media landscape. According to a source, there’s a widespread sentiment that sales teams across various platforms, from linear to digital, are feeling the strain. Although overall marketing budgets remain steady, they are now being divided among a multitude of platforms, complicating the task of meeting advertising objectives.

The complexity and cost of advertising inventory are also rising, as advertisers focus on reaching more specific audiences and utilizing new technologies. Despite an increase in available streaming ad inventory—thanks in part to platforms like Amazon’s Prime Video and Netflix introducing ad-supported tiers—advertisers face challenges such as inconsistent pricing and a lack of standardized metrics. Media professionals stress the importance of addressing these issues to better leverage the available ad spend.

Recent insights indicate that even though streaming ad inventory is on the rise, it is not being fully utilized. The gap between supply and demand is widening, with streaming ad fill rates dropping 18% in the first quarter and nearly 20% in the second quarter compared to last year. This trend highlights a crucial need for the industry to refine its inventory management practices and develop innovative strategies that enable advertisers to maximize their investments in the growing streaming arena. As the television advertising landscape continues to evolve, finding effective solutions will be essential for major players facing these challenges.

A common refrain has surfaced among CMOs: many believe that a $5 million marketing budget for mid-sized companies is insufficient in the current fast-paced digital landscape. This perception often stems from observing the spending patterns of top-tier advertisers, leading to the misconception that larger budgets are necessary. However, for numerous businesses in the middle market and startups, a $5 million budget is quite standard and can serve as a strong platform for effective marketing strategies. The real issue lies in how many marketers end up treating this budget as if it were only worth $2 million.

It's crucial to align creative production with the realities of the budget. While a high-end $1 million shoot might not be justifiable for a $5 million budget, a more reasonable production range of $100,000 to $200,000 can yield substantial content. Brands should consider flexible staffing models and ensure they have ample content for ongoing testing and optimization, which can significantly boost marketing effectiveness without needing larger financial commitments. Additionally, when it comes to technology, brands can benefit from more tailored solutions; instead of shelling out for pricey platforms, creating their own systems can be both cost-effective and customized to meet their specific needs.

Ultimately, effective marketing is not solely about managing a budget—it's about optimizing every dollar spent. This includes conducting market tests to focus on generating new sales rather than just retaining existing customers, as well as exploring various media strategies. Numerous success stories exist of brands that have outsmarted their rivals without overspending. By being innovative and strategic with their resources, middle-market brands can thrive and establish practices that pave the way for future growth. Adopting the belief that “my budget is enough” can help transform marketing strategies for lasting success.

TikTok users are progressing in a class-action lawsuit claiming that the app tracked their keystrokes when they used its in-app browser to visit external websites. A recent ruling permits these users to potentially hold TikTok accountable for alleged violations of federal and California state wiretap laws. This lawsuit asserts that TikTok collected sensitive personal data by monitoring users' activities outside its platform.

The plaintiffs argue that TikTok's in-app browser tracks every detail of their online activity, particularly during transactions. They contend that this tracking could capture vital information like names, addresses, phone numbers, and credit card data. Additionally, the lawsuit points out that the app's browser monitors visits to health-related websites, including those like Planned Parenthood, which raises serious privacy concerns. The allegations are backed by a security researcher, who reported that TikTok's in-app browser includes Javascript capable of logging keystrokes, further intensifying the privacy debate surrounding the app.

In response, TikTok has sought to have the lawsuit dismissed, arguing that the research merely suggests the possibility of data collection without proving that user information was actually logged or transmitted. However, the court rejected this defense, stating that the research does not completely exonerate TikTok from potential liability. The court noted that the plaintiffs' requests for further information demonstrate legitimate concerns regarding how TikTok manages sensitive data collected through its in-app browser.

While TikTok aims to downplay the allegations by asserting they lack specificity and adequate evidence, the court found the users' claims compelling enough to warrant further examination. The court referenced TikTok's own data, which indicates that a significant portion of Gen Z users frequently make purchases while using the app, lending credibility to the plaintiffs' assertions that they entered personal information while navigating through the in-app browser. This case may set an important precedent for privacy issues on social media platforms as users become increasingly aware of how their personal information is handled online.

Here is a recent highlight from Marketing Keys' blog page. Please start following our blogs and let us know what you think.

Are your holiday campaigns ready to go?

Get the latest insight here!

Whether you've been at your marketing position for 1 year or for 20 years, the pressure to produce and come up with the right strategies to reach your target audience is always there.

You no longer need to go about this on your own with 100% of the pressure. Now, you can collaborate with a media expert to help you with the latest, most effective and most efficient media strategies.

We can help by placing your campaigns in the right places, at the right times with the right frequencies. We'll make sure your campaign succeeds by examining the cost effectiveness, engagement potential and audience suitability of different media channels.

It is also critical to reach your customer on multiple platforms. This is how they are spending their media day. Therefore, it is critical that your messaging gets targeted and delivered in multiple online and offline ways.

As a 12 year former Disney executive with 30+ years in the business, I have discovered the best ways on how brands can cut through the clutter to reach their target.

By teaming up with us, we make the process enjoyable with minimal stress.

Furthermore, we will listen to you and always be committed to you. We strive to run our business with passion and humility all with the utmost integrity.

We look forward to empowering you to do your best work.

Until next month,

Roger Keys

Founder and CEO

Marketing Keys

P.S. Thank you for your loyalty in reading our newsletters!

If you feel this information is useful to

someone you know, we would appreciate you sharing

it with them. See share buttons below for social.