|
'Doomjobbing' This can't be good!
Editorial by Christian Saint Cyr
National Director / Canadian Job Development Network
.
When the term 'Doomjobbing' started crossing my news feeds in the last few months, my immediate reaction was, "this can't be good!" I didn't immediately know what it was but it couldn't be any more ominous than if the term was 'Career Catastrophe' or 'Application Apocalypse'.
It turns out, the term was coined this past March by Ilya Bagrak, a product manager based in Los Gatos, California. He first shared the term in a Threads post, explaining that his 8-year-old daughter came up with the name after watching him endlessly scroll through job listings on LinkedIn.
The term quickly went viral, being adopted by career experts and publications to describe the act of endlessly and passively scrolling through job boards without much intention.
And while this might seem like the latest trending term in the career development sector, up there with 'the great resignation' or 'job hugging', it's actually something far more concerning that strikes at the very heart of our poor economy and a universal truth about job seekers.
The term doomjobbing is carried forward from doomscrolling on social media, a habit which can become a way of engaging with a problem that feels outside your control. Getting hired, by its very nature, feels outside of our control and so there is a natural tendency to try to apply for as many jobs as possible.
Unfortunately, the very nature of our 'slow to hire, slow to fire' economy is that employers are increasingly getting higher numbers of applications. Mismatched or unqualified applications just start building up but never reach the top of the pile, in terms of who the employer will interview.
I've always felt that mass applications are like the lottery of job search. If I get a ticket for a Lotto 649, my odds are 1 in 14 million, but if I have 2 tickets my odds are 1 in 7 million. If I have 10 tickets my odds go down to 1 in 1.4 million and if I have a hundred tickets my odds are now 1 in 140,000.
Unfortunately, aside from the fact that 140,000-to-one is still pretty poor odds, this approach doesn't apply to job search for a number of reasons.
First of all, you can't or shouldn't apply more than once for the same job.
Second, unlike a lottery ticket which gives you an equal, albeit microscopic, chance of winning, not all job applications are created equal.
Employers will screen for the applications with the best education, experience and skills to determine who to interview, so simply submitting more applications doesn't change that equation.
Unfortunately, this volume of applications is prompting people to apply for jobs without a clear understanding of what the employer is looking for.
According to a recent survey conducted by Monster, 48% of candidates admit they apply without reading the entire job posting, and 32% spend one minute or less reviewing a posting before applying:
- 16% spend less than 30 seconds
- 16% spend between 30 seconds and 1 minute
- 26% spend 1–3 minutes
- 20% spend 3–5 minutes
- 22% spend more than 5 minutes
Dimitri Boylan, CEO of the recruitment platform Avature, says there’s an escalating technical arms race between applicants and hiring systems. Job seekers are using AI to create multiple polished résumés and cover letters while employers are implementing automation to screen candidates. It leads some to wonder why they should bother going through the process at all.
And if there is an 'arms race' between the technology job seekers are using and the technology employers are using to block, screen and reject candidates, we now have an atomic bomb in the form of AI Apply.
AI Apply is an AI-powered job search platform designed to automate and streamline the hiring process. It features an auto-apply bot, custom resume and cover letter generation, and interview coaching to help job seekers bypass manual job hunting.
It's not the only tool out there. Others include Loopcv, LazyApply, JobCopilot, Sonara, and Autojob.
Can you imagine sitting in an interview with an employer and having them say, "ah, I see your resume was forwarded by 'LazyApply'." So much for having our 'job search' demonstrate the skills and abilities an employer might like to see in a job candidate.
“We call it the ‘AI Recruiting Doom Loop,’" explains Lili Foggle, director at the Interview Institute of the Professional Association of Resume Writers and Career Coaches. She says the process creates a counter-productive loop in which:
- Job candidates use AI to enhance their resume and tailor it to the job description.
- Companies become flooded with a sea of sameness – all the resumes look qualified, and it becomes difficult to identify truly qualified candidates.
- Companies apply more or tighter AI filtering, making it harder for candidates to get an interview.
- To get an edge, candidates apply to even more jobs – often using AI to do so at scale – flooding companies with yet more often unqualified applications to filter through.
The sad thing about nuclear solutions, like having apps inundate employers with thousands of applications, is that eventually, like the computer in the 1984 movie 'War Games' discovers, the best way to win this war is to not play at all.
Employers will eventually get tired of this endless slog of applications and seek out better ways to only sort through the applicants with the best skills, experience and qualifications. This will push employers into further tapping the hidden job market and using recruitment companies.
Job seekers, particularly those with multiple barriers to employment, need less competition, not more. Unfortunately, they are 'doomjobbing' out of a sense of hopelessness and not because it's a good strategy.
Like so many fruitless behaviours in job search, the best thing we can do in our career development roles is to call it out. When an exasperated clients says, "I've applied for a hundred jobs and not heard anything," our best response is to say in a kind and supportive way, "well, we clearly need to look at a more personalized solution because that is not working."
Our coaching around job search shouldn't be organized around giving them a more comprehensive list of job search engines or instruction on how to use AI to max-out there job search, but instead to take it back to fundamentals.
If you said to your clients, "if you could only apply to 10 employers and 10 employers only, what would you do differently in your job search?" How would you approach the job posting? How much more time or effort would you put into the resume or cover letter? How much more likely would you be to follow-up after applying? What little things could you do to improve your chances?
Job seekers are fast and loose with job applications because job postings are limitless.
While we're never limited to just 10 jobs or 10 employers, job seekers need to adopt the attitude of scarcity. We need to put everything we can into each application.
Encourage clients to create a list of their preferred 15 - 30 employers. Find out who the decision makers are, where they post jobs, follow their social media and try to find in-person opportunities to connect with them.
There are four points clients or students might want to adopt in undertaking this approach.
-
Identify a Niche: While they may be looking for a couple of different types of jobs, specificity in cover letters, resumes, interview responses, and even the type of role can be extremely helpful. This might be how a graphic design role would look different within a marketing company vs. a non-profit society.
-
Target Specific Companies: A job is not a job and a company is not a company. The best way to develop a curated list of companies your clients would like to work for is to read about them in the news, on their websites and in social media to identify companies most aligned with your client's goals, values and personality.
-
Customize Every Application: Not only is it essential to completely read every job posting but ensure the cover letter addresses the major points in the job posting. It's not to say that an applicant needs to meet every point, but at the very least the cover letter should address ways of learning and acquiring the missing pieces.
-
Tap the Hidden Job Market: Job fairs, networking events, information interviews and mentorship programs are all excellent ways of networking and developing the hidden job market for the individual. Cold calling employers in-person and connecting on social media are also valuable pathways. Job seekers should ensure they are doing a certain portion of networking for each posted job they apply to.
While the term Doomjobbing may be new, this compulsive pattern of putting as many irons in the fire is not; clearly illustrated by the relevance of my blacksmith analogy.
At my recent labour market conference, I interviewed an old friend and mentor Tina Strehlke, CEO of Minerva, and she noted that everyone longs to be part of the team but also wants to be seen as special.
Applying for hundreds of jobs without a response not only subjectively tells people they are not special but they have no team.
In working with your clients, reinforce you and they are a team, working towards a common goal. They are each special and their words, actions and interactions should convey the special contribution they can make to each employer.
This sort of mentorship with our own clients creates a culture of excellence that will be far more effective in achieving the very best employment outcomes.
We’ll be discussing the impact of disability employment at our #MotivatingMondays meeting of the Canadian Job Development Network, Monday June 22nd at 8:30am Pacific; 9:30am Mountain; 10:30am Central; 11:30am Eastern; 12:30pm Atlantic and at 1pm in Newfoundland.
.
On the morning of Monday June 22nd 'Click this Link' to join the session.
.
'Developing a Comprehensive Approach to Effective Job Development'
September 2026
.
We've officially opened registration for this year's job development training: 'Developing a Comprehensive Approach to Effective Job Development' which is taking place online on five (5) separate days, for five separate time zones:
Mon. Sep. 21st (Pacific)
Tues. Sep. 22nd (Mountain)
Wed. Sep. 23rd (Central)
Thurs. Sep. 24th (Eastern)
Fri. Sep. 25th (Atlantic)
.
Up until July 16th, 2026, everyone who registers will benefit from a 35% discount on registration.
.
To learn more, please visit:
www.JobDevelopment.org/pro-d
or send me an email at:
csaintcyr@labourmarketsolutions.ca
|