Job Development

Pulse

Mon. Aug. 24, 2026

www.JobDevelopment.org

Click here to learn more about 'Developing a Comprehensive Approach to Effective

Job Development'

Click here to join the Monday Aug. 24th #MotivatingMondays Session

'OR' Click here to view a YouTube video of today's session

Helping employers see the benefit of screening interviews

Editorial by Christian Saint Cyr

National Director / Canadian Job Development Network

.

While screening interviews are a strong technique for finding individuals who will be a good fit for an organization, they're extremely valuable in job development as it expands the pool of candidates an employer will consider.

.

If you've ever taken my job development training workshop, I will typically share a story about a large chain of restaurants hiring for cooks. They placed a series of ads and ultimately received more than 168 applications. Out of these applicants they choose 16 people to interview.

.

The outcome of that story is that nearly every scheduled candidate didn't show up for their interview. Certainly, this story is a product of the time in which it happened but it does illuminate a fundamental frustration among both job seekers and employers.

.

Employers don't like to be ghosted or having to deal with non-committal individuals and job seekers struggle to get noticed when their chances of getting interviewed, at least in this example, are less one in ten.

.

Screening interviews allow an employer to try out a lot more candidates but it also improves the chances of the job seeker to get more face-time.

.

In the example of the restaurant chain, they chose to interview 16 people but how many people were actually qualified to do the job? Perhaps 150, maybe 155? How did they narrow down this list to just 16 applicants?

.

They likely chose the candidates with the:

  • Greatest number of years of experience
  • Most relevant education
  • Most consistent experience
  • Canadian experience
  • Easiest commute
  • Least gaps in their work experience

.

We are now 20 years into an ongoing skills shortage. These candidates are in high-demand everywhere and so they can pick and choose their job opportunities.

.

Who does this system of sorting job applicants exclude? Let's match up the criteria:

  • People who just completed their training
  • People who's education is dated or limited
  • People who've had gaps in their work history
  • People who are new to the country
  • People without transportation or mobility issues
  • People who are trying to pursue a career in a new sector

.

Simply put, this is excluding 'people' and 'people who typically work with job developers, those in co-op education and other employer engagement professionals'.

.

Recently I was speaking with one job developer who said, "my clients typically come from a substance use background and will often have 15 or more years of a gap in their work history." They asked, "what can I do to help them make connections with employers?"

.

I get asked this question a lot and I'm at a loss for a good answer. I tell people to attend job fairs, cold call employers, ask for information interviews. I encourage them to try to personalize their job search but frankly that is a tough path with many employers.

.

Employers want to hire for fit. It's often noted as the primary driver and yet who they chose to interview is often representative of who gets to the top of the resume stack.

.

According to a Robert Half Canada survey released just last month, "nearly four in 10 employers (37%) prioritize hiring high-potential candidates and investing in their development when unable to find fully qualified talent who are ready to contribute immediately." That's a third of employers.

.

So, yes, job seekers would benefit from screening interviews but how do we get employers onboard?

..

This utilizes one of the most important skills a job developer can utilize and that's getting inside the head of employers.

.

What frustrates an employer about recruitment? By the way, this should be one of the most common questions you should ask an employer. I would suggest the responses might include:

  • Getting ghosted
  • Not being available
  • Having a poor attitude
  • Contributing to workplace gossip
  • Entitlement
  • Lack of enthusiasm
  • An inability to take initiative
  • Failing to follow instructions

.

All of these attributes contribute to a 'good fit'. They are also things that are difficult to discover through traditional resume screening.

.

If we can empathize with employers and say, "even when you hire the best candidates on paper, are they going to be your best employees?"

.

Put another way: "If you always do what you've always done, you'll always get what you've always gotten."

.

Doing screening interviews is going to take more time, but if employers can buy into them, they'll be able to balance how good candidates look on paper vs. the impression they give off on the phone or in a Teams interview.

.

One of the key areas we can support employers is with helping craft the questions.

.

In a perfect world, an employer should interview EVERYONE who is technically qualified; everyone who is capable of doing the job. This said, we don't want to overwhelm the employer with screening calls.

.

I believe just two or three questions can tell an employer a lot about an employee. Based on this ratio an employer can do 15-20 screening calls an hour.

Indeed published an article where they suggested questions such as:

  • Why don't you tell me a little about yourself?
  • What do you know about our company?
  • What is your plan for the next three years?

.

Those questions are fine but do not tell the employer much about the candidate. If these interviews are for getting a good feel for how the person would fit with the organization, why not ask questions about workplace values? These might include:

  • What does team work mean to you?
  • Can you share examples of times you've taken initiative in the workplace?
  • Can you describe 'quality service'?

.

If an employer really wants to get an unscripted answer, they might want to try one of these questions from left field:

  • If you won $50,000, what would you do with the money?
  • If you could work in a completely different field, what job would you pursue? 
  • What is the best piece of career advice you would give your child or a young relative?

.

While the answers are important, screening interviews are less about the information and more about the personal connection. It's kind of like 'speed dating'.

.

Even scheduling an interview gives a candidate an opportunity to demonstrate enthusiasm, follow-through and flexibility.

.

If an employer emails someone to set up a phone-interview and they don't call back for three days, what does that say about their work ethic?

.

We want more employers to participate in screening interviews. This allows them to broaden their net and look at the complete population of people interested in the job.

.

This brings us to the second half of our challenge.

.

Our clients or students have to be ready for this. This means constantly scanning their email and being ready to take a call when it comes up as an 'unknown number'. They need to practice, come up with personal stories to demonstrate skills and really impress an employer with their willingness to go that extra mile.

.

And if you're thinking right now, my client won't go that extra mile, my student isn't prepared to be on top of all of this, that's not something we can solve here.

.

In many cases, the people who get to the top of the stack or resumes are also going to good at screening interviews.

.

Employers don't want to be tricked into hiring our clients or students. But, it's perfectly legitimate to help them understand there is a better way of hiring.

.

The benefit of screening interviews for us is that it gives our clients an opportunity to make a sincere case for themselves while otherwise all they would be getting from an employer is silence.

.

We’ll be discussing the benefits of screening interviews at this week's #MotivatingMondays meeting of the Canadian Job Development Network, Monday August 24th at 8:30am Pacific; 9:30am Mountain; 10:30am Central; 11:30am Eastern; 12:30pm Atlantic and at 1pm in Newfoundland.

.

On the morning of Monday August 24th 'Click this Link' to join the session.


.* * *

Staying on top of labour market information...


Canadian Labour Market Reports

The Canadian Labour Market Reports provide a weekly round-up of the major labour market information that most impacts those in

career transition. Click on the relevant

labour market report below.

.

BC Labour Market Report

www.labourmarketonline.com

.

Alberta Labour Market Report

www.jobdevelopment.org/albertalmr

.

Prairie Labour Market Report

www.jobdevelopment.org/prairielmr

.

Ontario Labour Market Online

www.ontariolabourmarketonline.org

.

Atlantic Labour Market Report

www.jobdevelopment.org/atlanticlmr

..

To learn more, send me an email at:

csaintcyr@labourmarketsolutions.ca


TIP OF THE WEEK


Greetings!

.

Give your clients a checklist for success with screening interviews. This checklist can include: (1) respond quickly: (2) be flexible; (3) stay positive; (4) ask questions; and (5) follow-up.

.

All my best!

.

Christian Saint Cyr

National Director, CJDN


IMPORTANT LINKS

Canadian Job Development Network

Vancouver:

604-288-2424

Toronto:

647-660-3665

Email:

csaintcyr@

labourmarket

solutions.ca


Next #Motivating

Mondays

Mon. Aug. 24th

8:30am Pacific

9:30am Mountain

10:30am Central

11:30am Eastern

12:30pm Atlantic

1:00pm Newfoundland

Copyright 2026

Research Deep Dive

The following is a breakdown of research from the past week to help you better understand the goals, objectives and strategies of local employers.

.

July 2026 Labour Force Survey: The Turn Comes Into View

Indeed Hiring Lab -- Aug. 21, 2026

.

Employment Insurance, June 2026

Statistics Canada -- Aug. 21, 2026

.

Who’s really missing from the US workforce?

CIBC Economics -- Aug. 21, 2026


Resource of the Week

.

To help job seekers better prepare for screening interviews, Charity Village has published this article: 'Interview tips: How to prepare for a pre-screening phone call', helping people better organize their materials, do research, prepare questions, find the right environment, how to act and what to do to follow-up.

.

Click here to read:.

Interview tips: How to prepare for a pre-screening phone call