|
Lessons learned from 62 construction project managers
Editorial by Christian Saint Cyr
National Director / Canadian Job Development Network
.
Developing a stronger understanding of employer challenges, attitudes and processes is the cornerstone of good job development. We call it 'discovery' and it allows us to be able to recommend candidates, programs and employer supports that will address the very challenges employers face everyday.
Canada is seemingly at a crossroads economically and the construction industry is an important sector to consider. Economic uncertainty and cooling immigration have slowed the residential construction sector and major new projects funded under the tariff response have yet to literally and figuratively break ground.
The sector is also facing a major demographic imbalance. An aging workforce is creating many new job opportunities and yet employers are reluctant to take on new workers without a clearer sense of what the future involves.
One occupation worth taking a closer look at is 'construction project manager' -- both as an occupation and as a major decision maker in the sector. To help illuminate this profession, and the sector itself, we're aided by a recent article by Pascal Patrice, a construction project director in Quebec and the founder of TCC (Total Cost Control), a daily field reporting and cost tracking platform for contractors.
Recently, Pascal shared the feedback he received from 62 separate construction project managers (27 in English and 35 in French) which was published in Ontario Construction News.
According to Pascal, all 62 respondents say finding competent, experienced people has become harder. Seventy-seven percent say “a lot harder.” That held through every wave of responses and in both languages, without a single dissent.
Several respondents made the point that it isn’t only their own hiring. They see the decline at every link in the chain: owners, consultants, subcontractors and trades.
In our job development work, it's important for us to understand that employers are being overwhelmed by non-construction activities.
Ninety-seven percent say paperwork and compliance have increased. Ninety percent say reporting has increased. Eighty-nine percent feel more schedule pressure, and 84 percent more margin pressure.
For many, administration is taking over. Fifty-eight percent now spend more than half their week on administration, and nearly one in four says admin has simply “taken over.” Sixty percent describe themselves as more firefighter than manager. Just over half say they no longer spend their time on what they’re actually good at.
The written answers were sharper than the checkboxes. One PM said: “Too many different platforms and places to store, move, and retrieve data… duplication of effort and wasting time doing things three different places.”
Another named a problem no software fixes: “decision makers who actually provide answers instead of avoiding making decisions so they can’t get blamed later.”
What can we take from this initial feedback? Construction employers are not going to be favourably disposed to wage subsidy, skills training and other administrative burdens that make their lives more difficult.
When we are pitching clients, we should be highlighting their self-reliance, ability to pick up skills quickly and that they are ready to go on day one.
This may underscore the importance of providing pre-employment in critical skills areas and to help our job seekers understand that if they can present themselves as problem solvers, hard workers and willing to learn as they go, employers will be more interested in them.
This isn't to say all job seekers will be in this position and many will need supports, but if we're starting from the position of needing to provide ongoing support, construction employers just aren't going to listen.
Pascal's research also demonstrated that employers aren't afraid of AI.
Eighty-seven percent of respondents expect AI to help them or to fundamentally change the job and only one person in 62 called it a threat to their role.
This industry hears constantly that it’s about to be disrupted, and its project managers seem remarkably unbothered.
Pascal believes they know exactly where their hours go. The re-entry, the chasing and the reports nobody reads aren’t the job they signed up for. They’d happily hand that part to a machine.
And while this article isn't about AI, I think this is a great example of how professionals will be using AI to make their lives better but won't be replaced by it. Professionals have jobs that are far more complex and interpersonal than what can be accomplished by AI.
As to our desire to better understand the needs of employers, we want to have questions we can regularly ask employers to gain clarity on what is important to them.
In my job development training, I suggest nine questions you might use with an employer over coffee or through an informational interview to get a better sense of what they are struggling with. These nine questions include:
- What sort of roles do you typically hire for?
- How do you promote roles?
- What does your recruitment process look like?
- What distinguishes your business?
- Who is your major competition?
- What do your customers most like about your business?
- What are you most proud of in your organization?
- What motivates your staff?
- Where do you see your organization in the years to come?
There is a logic to how these questions are presented. Employers are likely to be hesitant to answer questions right off the bat so the first few questions are easy left-brain questions with tangible answers.
As the conversation goes on, the we ask more intangible questions about values, goals and ideas, right-brain areas, where the employer will be more open to answer.
While these are the questions I prefer, they're really just a starting place. They provide a framework but the ultimate goal of getting to know employers is three-fold: 1. understand their challenges, so that we can speak to them in what we suggest; 2. be able to speak to their higher values and goals; and 3. build credibility and trust.
Our job might be job development but at the end of the day, we're just another networking contact for most employers. The more we build our subject matter expertise and trust with local employers, the more likely they are to reach out to us, rather than they other way around, when they need to fill jobs.
.
We’ll be discussing the value of engaging employers at this week's #MotivatingMondays meeting of the Canadian Job Development Network, Monday November 2nd at 8:30am in British Columbia; 9:30am: Alberta and Saskatchewan; 10:30am: Manitoba, Ontario and Quebec; 11:30am New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and PEI; and at 12pm in Newfoundland.
.
On the morning of Monday November 2nd 'Click this Link' to join the session.
.* * *
Looking for a workshop covering all of the major LMI from the past year, tailored to your province or region?
2026 Labour Market
Year-in-Review Workshops
20% Discount
for registrations received by
NEXT WEEK
November 12, 2026
.
BC LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
IN-PERSON: Fri. Dec. 4th
ONLINE: Mon. Dec. 7th
www.labourmarketonline.com/lmiworkshop
.
Alberta LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
ONLINE: Tues. Dec. 8th
www.jobdevelopment.org/albertalmiworkshop
.
Prairie LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
ONLINE: Wed. Dec. 9th
www.jobdevelopment.org/prairielmiworkshop
.
Ontario LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
ONLINE: Thurs. Dec. 10th
www.ontariolabourmarketonline.org/lmiworkshop
.
Atlantic LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
ONLINE: Fri. Dec. 11th
www.jobdevelopment.org/atlanticlmiworkshop
..
To learn more, send me an email at:
csaintcyr@labourmarketsolutions.ca
|