|
Pay transparency rewriting the rules of hiring
Editorial by Christian Saint Cyr
National Director / Canadian Job Development Network
.
Last week, HRFest Canada 2026 wrapped up in Toronto and obviously there are a lot of important issues taking place in human resources, but one central to this conference was wage transparency.
It's now been a year since Ontario enacted the Working for Workers Four Act 2024, which requires employers with 25 or more employees to include the expected salary range in every publicly advertised external job posting. The range may not exceed $50,000, and employers are exempt from disclosing compensation above $200,000.
The legislation also requires disclosure of AI use in hiring, while a companion provision under the act established a 45-day candidate notification rule, requiring employers to inform every interviewed applicant of a hiring decision within 45 days of their most recent interview.
When it comes to wage transparency, all the cool provinces are doing it. Ontario joins five other Canadian provinces that have enacted (British Columbia, Prince Edward Island, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia) or proposed (Newfoundland and Labrador) some form of pay transparency legislation, according to Employment Hero.
As publisher of the Canadian Labour Market Reports, each we share new career development job postings and as I sift through these each day, the number of job postings which don't have salaries stand out more than the postings with salary ranges.
In the past year, Ontario job postings disclosing salary information have jumped from 49 per cent to 71 per cent, according to Indeed’s Pay Transparency Tracker.
At the HRFest Canada conference, Aleksandra Pressey, Partner at Williams HR Law in the Greater Toronto Area spoke about the legal implications of the wage transparency legislation.
“Pay transparency was definitely loud and out there, and something that a lot of organizations had heard about,” says Pressey. “But I think there was a lot of misunderstanding in terms of what it meant – a lot of confusion between pay transparency obligations, pay equity obligations, and equal pay for equal work obligations.”
While Pressey acknowledges that failing to disclose wages, as well as whether AI is being used in the hiring process, looks exclusively at the penalties and requirements but fails to appreciate the benefits.
“Pay transparency is actually an opportunity, first of all, to look internally and see what exactly your expected pay ranges are for any type of role,” Pressey says. “And then hopefully be aligned with that before you have to make any sort of communication outside, in terms of candidates – and it helps to somewhat set candidates' expectations… to ensure that the employer and the potential future employee are on the same page.”
Many leaders in HR are seeing the benefits. According to research from Indeed, 92.5 percent of HR leaders say pay transparency has been 'definitely' or 'mostly' worthwhile.
Among hiring decision makers, more than 80 percent say the benefits of pay transparency outweigh the challenges.
"The top four benefits that hiring decision makers cited were: being better able to achieve or increase pay equity, helping build a more transparent company culture, helping employee satisfaction, and creating a culture of trust," according to Indeed.
That internal alignment can expose uncomfortable realities. Some employers are finding that publicly posted pay ranges sit well above what long-tenured employees currently earn – a dynamic that creates retention risk alongside compliance risk.
“You’re posting for a job, you’re saying here’s the potential salary range, and then you have incumbents who might be a lot closer to that lower end than the high end, despite sometimes many years of service,” says Pressey.
When this relates to the use of AI, it creates an uncomfortable reality that isn't being addressed in many organizations. Many employees and managers are using AI and not telling anyone about it.
“You say you’re not using AI in your recruitment processes, or you’re only using it to this limited amount – and you might not necessarily know that your frontline manager who’s on your hiring panel is actually using AI heavily in some way, shape, or form,” says Pressey. “Because you haven’t inquired, you haven’t properly set expectations, or you don’t have appropriate policies in place.”
In wrapping up her presentation, Pressey stressed the importance of establishing sound practices around AI and wages.
“Taking some of that time to really consider what the future is going to look like is going to be very, very helpful, but I also recognize it’s easier said than done – HR has a lot on the go right now,” she says. “Sometimes it’s really difficult to find that time and actually take a step back when you need to fill certain seats now or yesterday.”
In our communication with employers, I believe there is an obligation and an opportunity.
As subject matter experts in recruitment and retention, I believe we should be sharing information and resources with employers whether it's a violation of employment standards or human rights. Obviously, this is sensitive communication, but we don't want employers who simply don't understand the rules, to face penalties when they violate them.
The opportunity is at the heart of Aleksandra Pressey's presentation. It's easy to focus on the administrative burden and invasive requirement to share information, but in the majority of provinces, this is now legislation or about to be legislation.
Sharing wages creates a reasonable expectation of what someone might hope to earn in a role. It ensures greater equity between what men and women should earn, but this would also extend to recent immigrants, racialized Canadians as well as mature and youth workers.
As they say, "sunlight is the best disinfectant." Employers who are striving to have impartial, integrity-based recruitment processes will be open to this.
British Columbia has had this legislation in place for several years and each year we are seeing greater parity in the salaries earned by men and women in the same role.
An additional opportunity is in the area of friction. Every time you add a layer or bureaucracy, cost or delay to the practice of posting jobs, you create friction that makes posting jobs a less attractive alterative.
This friction has always existed and it's a major contributor to growth in the hidden job market, which has very little friction.
With increased requirements to discloses wages, employers may choose to review resumes of candidates you represent rather than officially posting it.
I don't believe this should be a way for employers to circumvent their responsibility to share wages, but it does provide an easy access point to potential candidates without having to broadly publicize their wages.
Disclosure of wages is just the latest in a series of new employment laws designed to support workers. It goes hand-in-hand with the annual increases in the minimum wages over the past few years.
Each time the government puts a new requirement on an employer; or the economy is challenged by something like tariffs; or there is a national emergency such as COVID; opportunities and challenges emerge for job seekers and career professionals. The key for us as job developers is to mitigate the challenges and find opportunities for hiring managers to grow as more inclusive employers when these things occur.
We’ll be discussing the benefits of wage transparency at this week's #MotivatingMondays meeting of the Canadian Job Development Network, Monday November 16th at 8:30am in British Columbia; 9:30am: Alberta and Saskatchewan; 10:30am: Manitoba, Ontario and Quebec; 11:30am New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and PEI; and at 12pm in Newfoundland.
.
On the morning of Monday November 16th 'Click this Link' to join the session.
.* * *
Looking for a workshop covering all of the major LMI from the past year, tailored to your province or region?
2026 Labour Market
Year-in-Review Workshops
Registration is Closing Soon
LEARN MORE BELOW FOR EACH WORKSHOP
.
BC LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
IN-PERSON: Fri. Dec. 4th
ONLINE: Mon. Dec. 7th
www.labourmarketonline.com/lmiworkshop
.
Alberta LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
ONLINE: Tues. Dec. 8th
www.jobdevelopment.org/albertalmiworkshop
.
Prairie LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
ONLINE: Wed. Dec. 9th
www.jobdevelopment.org/prairielmiworkshop
.
Ontario LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
ONLINE: Thurs. Dec. 10th
www.ontariolabourmarketonline.org/lmiworkshop
.
Atlantic LMI Year-in-Review Workshop
ONLINE: Fri. Dec. 11th
www.jobdevelopment.org/atlanticlmiworkshop
..
To learn more, send me an email at:
csaintcyr@labourmarketsolutions.ca
|