"Gentlemen, you shall not be dismissed till we have a verdict that the court will accept; and you shall be locked up, without meat, drink, fire, and tobacco; you shall not think thus to abuse the court; we will have a verdict, by the help of God, or you shall starve for it.” 1
Dear Colleagues,
I will circle back and explain why I go to the year 1670 with Judge Howell's admonition to the jurors in the trial of William Penn and William Mead at the Old Bailey, which set the stage for Bushell's case.
"Who is deciding has replaced what is being decided as the central focus of these news stories. This is why we at the Project must redouble our efforts in supporting jury trials, the judges who preside over them and the attorneys who try them."
Last January I was addressing the growing number of stories about politics and appointments to the Supreme Court. With the Supreme Court overturning the nearly 50 year precedent of Roe v. Wade, commentators are again writing about politics and the Court. Confidence in the Court is at an all time low according to opinion polls.
This highlights, once again, how essential jury trials, both civil and criminal, are for the public to be involved with, and have confidence in, our system of justice.
I offer two cases tried a month apart to make my point. Both had a connection to a polarizing political figure, the former president. Both had stories written about the effort to keep political biases out of the courtroom. Both ended differently.
In November, a 75-year-old billionaire, Thomas J. Barrack, Jr. was on trial in Brooklyn. He is a friend of Donald Trump and chaired the Republican's inaugural committee.
After deliberating for three days, the jury found Barrack and an assistant not guilty of acting as an unregistered agent of a foreign government, obstruction of justice and making false statements.
A month later, two Trump organizations were on trial in Manhattan for tax fraud. After about 10 hours of deliberation the jury returned guilty verdicts on all 17 counts.
What is of note with these two cases are the number of news stories about the lengths that the attorneys and the judges took to keep political biases out of the courtroom and the jury box.
Now this may be a stretch to find a connection between Bushell's case and the reaction to the Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade. As you know, the jurors in Bushell's case refused to bend to the will of the judge, thus setting the groundwork for juror independence.
However, can a parallel be drawn between the jurors in 1670 with the voters in the midterm elections in 2022? Voters in five states, including two traditionally "red states" (Kentucky and Montana), voted for abortion rights or rejected measures to curtail those rights.
The decision in Dobbs stated, "...the authority to regulate abortion is returned to the people and their elected representatives." It appears that at least as far as those five states in the midterms elections of 2022 are concerned, that the jurors...excuse me...the voters have spoken.
In this Issue
We begin with a piece by one of our Judicial Advisors Emeritus, Hon. Mark W. Bennett (ret.), with his report from the witness box during two state court jury trials in Iowa. His insights as a witness, former judge and jury innovation pioneer are invaluable.
Since the end of the year is the time many people catch up on their charitable donations, I wanted to make a pitch for a pro bono platform that I use in New York to help people in Illinois, where I am still licensed.
This ABA platform offers an easy way to help those in need of legal help.
Steve Susman lamented the lack of real trial lawyers and real trial judges as a factor in the decline of civil jury trials that was relatively easy to change. I outline our efforts to train the next generation of trial lawyers in our last piece for this issue.
"...a very resourceful and informative repository of information." was compliment we recently received from a court administrator asking for our help with a juror questionnaire. In closing, we want to continue to be of assistance to court systems and individual judges. If your court system would like our assistance, we are ready, willing and able to work with you.
If you wish to contribute any article or resource to the Project, we welcome any effort that will help restore and improve the civil jury trial system.
Diversity Matters
Are you a diverse trial lawyer, or know of a diverse trial lawyer, who is an excellent advocate with jury trial experience and has the talent to pass those skills along to others? If so, please write to me at markd56.md@gmail.com or call me at (217) 430-7459. I would love to discuss the possibilities available for teaching through The National Institute for Trial Advocacy (NITA).
- The Trial of William Penn and William Mead, at the Old Bailey, for a Tumultuous Assembly’ (1670) 6 Cobbett’s State Trials (1661-78: Charles II), col.951, at col.963
|
Sincerely,
Hon. Mark A. Drummond (ret.),
Executive/Judicial Director
|
|
March 31, 2023
South Carolina Bar
From File to Trial Program
For registration information click here.
|
|
|
|
Lessons Learned from the Witness Box –
By Hon. Mark W. Bennett (Ret. U.S. district judge, N.D. Iowa)
|
|
|
|
Since I retired in 2019, I have testified twice in legal malpractice cases in state court in Iowa. Once for the defendant and once for the plaintiff. Both won, with the plaintiff receiving a verdict of 12 million dollars in
September. Two excellent and extremely bright and thoughtful trial judges presided. Surprisingly, neither judge used any of the plethora of trial court innovations that I used as a trial judge and have written about.1
The two exceptions were allowing jurors to take notes which they did in abundance and one judge gave frequent stretch-in-place breaks. Here are a few observations about their use or lack of use of trial court
innovations and a few comments on the lawyers:
- In one case I was the first witness in the case (obviously for the plaintiff) about the negligence of his state court public defender. Before I testified, the parties had agreed that the defense could read the entire trial transcript from the underlying jury trial to the eight-person jury. Boring, boring, boring, especially because an individual copy wasn’t available to each juror. They had to try and remember the trial transcript from memory – an utterly impossible task. It was not an exhibit in the trial. The judge should have given each juror a copy to follow along to help with their comprehension while the transcript was read. The transcripts then could have been collected, or better yet, allow each juror the use of their transcript during the evidence presentation. I and the opposing expert frequently referred to matters in the transcript as did other witnesses.
- After I was sworn in and about 30 minutes into my testimony I was asked about several exhibits. Unfortunately, there was no final pre-trial conference to admit the exhibits and the lawyers were quibbling about them right in front of me and in the presence of the jury. The exhibits were admitted but that should have obviously been done earlier.
- There were no preliminary instructions so the jurors had no idea what they would need to find. I always put the verdict form in every civil and criminal case up on a large screen and told the potential jurors that if they were selected at the end of the case this is what they would be asked to find. The purpose was to see if any of the potential jurors would have unusual difficulty in making the findings.
- One of the judges gave all of us quick stretch breaks about every hour, which I did as a judge, and it was much appreciated by all in the courtroom. The 30-second to a minute stretch break in place adds little to the length of trial and makes absorbing the testimony much easier for the jurors. They were attentive during my full day of direct and cross.
- Neither judge used time limits negotiated with the lawyers at a final pre-trial conference, so the jurors had no idea when the trial evidence was going to end. We were all there voluntarily – the jurors were not. Reasonable time limits negotiated with the lawyers, in addition to many other benefits, are a huge courtesy to jurors.
- Both judges generally treated the jurors with respect, except one was not in the courtroom when the jurors were brought in after breaks. So, the judge was not standing for the jurors when they entered, which I always thought was important as a sign of respect. As a judge, I never wanted to make a grand entrance. One judge was seldom on time so the jurors and counsel usually waited beyond the time the judge told everyone court would resume.
- Both courtrooms had lawyer podiums on wheels but were not set up so witnesses could see both the lawyers asking questions and the jurors - so my head spun like a top.
-
Both trials would have benefited from final instructions prior to opening statements, or at least preliminary instructions including the elements of legal malpractice which were not in dispute under Iowa law. Moreover, for the last 20 years of my judging I gave the jurors a final set of instructions before opening statements. In only one out of every fifty or so trials would I have to delete an instruction or give a supplement instruction and they were told at the beginning that might happen. It was never, ever a problem. 2 Also, each juror would have benefited from having an individual set of final or preliminary instructions with them during the trial. They also would have benefited from time limits, especially on opening and closing arguments, if not the entire trial; allowing jurors to ask questions of witnesses; judges just saying no to side bars; starting and ending on time for each break and for each trial day; and more creature comforts for jurors. Juror feedback on the trial would help each lawyer and the trial judges improve on their craft. The trial judges had not yet developed a jury-centered approach to jury trials. The central feature of this outlook is WWJW, What Would Jurors Want. While it’s not always possible to give jurors what they want, it usually is!!!!
- One lawyer did a great job of dribbling out my qualifications during my direct to not bore the jurors with the usual lengthy qualifications first, but highlighted them as they related to my opinions.
- Neither lawyer did a good job of “previewing” my testimony. I always encouraged lawyers at the final pre-trial conference to preview their witnesses, especially their experts, by asking very early in the examination why they were being called to testify. It is much easier for jurors to be interested in the expert’s opinion if they know early on why they are being called. Often an expert spends a ton of time on their qualifications and the jurors have little understanding of why they are testifying until they get to their opinions. For example, a preview of my testimony might look like this: “Is it your understanding you have been called to testify today why, in your expert opinion, the defendant lawyer was negligent and committed legal malpractice?” If you think that is too leading (even though it is foundational) you can always ask: “Please tell the jury why you have been called to testify?”
1 Mark W. Bennett, Reinvigorating and Enhancing Jury Trials Through an
(2016).
2 Any reader of this article who wants to learn how I gave a complete set of final
instructions to each juror prior to opening statements in hundreds of federal criminal
either a Zoom session or a telephone call to explain how it is done.
3 Each of these suggestions are discussed in my article cited in fn 1.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Hon. Mark W. Bennett (Ret. U.S. district judge, N.D. Iowa) is a Judicial Advisor Emeritus for the Civil Jury Project. Judge Bennett retired on March 2, 2019, to become the first Director of the Drake University Law School’s Institute for Justice Reform & Innovation and to start a mediation, arbitration and legal consulting practice.
|
|
|
|
A Plea for Pro Bono
and the Road Ahead
By Hon. Mark A. Drummond (ret.)
Executive/Judicial Director of the Civil Jury Project
|
|
|
|
“Long distance is the next best thing to being there.”
-Bell Systems’ Advertisement, circa 1965
Want to do something that will help others, perhaps help you fulfill a pro bono requirement and make you feel good all at the same time? The ABA has made it easy. ABA Free Legal Answers is a project of the American Bar Association's Standing Committee on Pro Bono and Public Service. From virtually anywhere you can help someone in need.
When one of my fellow judges retired, I always thought it was such a waste of talent if their only destination was the golf course. All that knowledge, all that experience put on the shelf? What if they could devote just an hour or two here or there to help?
How easy is it to get started?
Very. Just click on the name of the state or states where you are licensed to practice from the list at the end of this article. On the home page click the tab at the top labeled “Attorney Registration." This leads to a short “Attorney Agreement” along with an overview of frequently asked questions. Click on “I agree” at the bottom, fill out the short form with your information and you are good to go.
Will I have to appear for the client in court if I participate?
No, your representation is limited to giving your best legal advice over the platform. Your representation is limited to answering their questions to the best of your ability.
Do I need to get malpractice insurance?
No, as stated on the website, “Malpractice insurance is provided by the ABA for the legal guidance that you provide through the ABA Free Legal Answers website.”
How much time does it take?
Let me address this by example. I just logged in. There are 67 pending questions to be answered. Across the top are these categories:
Legal Deadline Kind of Problem Parties Subject Submitted (Date)
Next to each question is a red flag. If the flag is filled in that means the question has been pending for more than 25 days or has a legal deadline. If the flag is not filled in that means the question has been pending for more than 10 days and no flag at all means that the question has been pending for less than 10 days and that there is no legal deadline. Finally, there may be a symbol telling you that the person asking the question is over 65 or a veteran.
Assuming I feel competent to answer a question, the first person I would want to help would be a veteran, over the age of 65 who has a legal deadline. Fortunately, today there is no one with that profile with a question. Here is my decision tree:
1. Is there a legal deadline?
2. Is the person over 65 or a veteran?
3. Is this in my area of expertise? If not, can I help by directing them to another resource?
4. After reading the issue do I have the time to adequately address it, including responding to follow up questions?
5. After reading the issue do I need other information from the person? (This happens often)
6. Has the person attached documents that will help me decide the issue?
7. Am I clear on what they need, or will I need to ask substantially more questions?
8. Is this issue in the county where I used to preside? (I do not take questions from here)
Today, I picked a question that had a legal deadline three days away. The questions were fairly narrow, and the client attached documents, which were very helpful. I answered the questions, but my guess is that I will receive some follow-up questions. On average, about only 20% of the questions I answer result in follow-up questions.
I try to answer the questions to the best of my ability but most of the time I am also including links to in-state legal service agencies that could perhaps help the person by going to court. The website also allows me to attach documents and I have drafted some documents for clients.
Once I answer a question the website has a great feature that allows you to record your hours. This helps if your state requires you to document pro bono hours. Today, I spent an hour reviewing the question, the documents attached and crafting a response. I will get an email notification if the client responds and my practice is to respond that day, if possible. Today is Saturday and I am going to wait until Monday to see if I get a response. Postscript: It is Monday and I have not received any follow-up questions.
What types of questions am I likely to handle?
The cases are all civil matters. The Illinois site lists 15 separate categories of cases. You can subscribe to as few or as many different categories as you feel confident in handling. My experience has been that most of the questions involve family issues.
If there is a question that I see is urgent and I feel uncomfortable giving advice based upon my experience, I can usually find a resource in the state and can at least send the client a link for further help.
I’m interested. Are there any training resources?
Click on the state where you are licensed and register. Once I registered, my Illinois home page had a tab for “Training Resources” with links to three helpful videos for those starting out.
In closing, I try to set aside some time each week to log on. Sometimes I answer a question and hear nothing back from the client. However, from time to time, a client will take the time to write a “thank you” and let you know how everything came out. It is always rewarding to be able to help someone who is half a continent away.
Here are links to the states with Free Legal Answers websites:
Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, USVI, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, West Virginia and Wisconsin.
I hope you will join me.
Future Events
At the end of this week I will travel to South Africa to teach in The General Council of the Bar of South Africa's (GCB) Advanced Advocacy Training Course and Advanced Teacher Training Course.
March 8 to 12 I will be in Chicago teaching at NITA's Midwest Regional Program. Registration information can be found here.
On March 31st, I will be in South Carolina to present a full-day seminar on remote and in-person advocacy. I will address Trial by Agreement and many of the jury innovations promoted by Steve Susman and the CJP. A full description of the program can be found here.
As always, if your court or bar association is interested in a presentation on jury trials, the Civil Jury Project or jury innovations please contact me at markd56.md@gmail.com.
|
|
|
|
The Hon. Mark A. Drummond (ret.) is the Executive / Judicial Director of the Civil Jury Project. He was a trial lawyer for 20 years before serving on the bench as a trial court judge in Illinois for 20 years. He is a program director and co-director for Teacher Training for The National Institute for Trial Advocacy. For over 25 years he has written the Practice Points column for Litigation News, a publication of the Litigation Section of the American Bar Association. He has returned to the practice of law and is currently licensed to practice in Illinois and has applied to be licensed to practice in New York.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Look out for the April 2023 Newsletter!
|
|
|
|
Civil Jury Project, NYU School of Law
Wilf Hall, 139 MacDougal Street, Room 407, New York, NY 10012
markd56.md@gmail.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Samuel Issacharoff
Faculty Director
|
|
Mark Drummond
Executive/Judicial Director
|
|
Kaitlin Villanueva
Admin. Assistant
|
|
|
|
|
|
|