Our Mission Going Forward
I began this newsletter with a quote I found in the piece outlined below. Although the imagery is somewhat depressing, I take it as a call to redouble our efforts to encourage judges and attorneys to try civil jury cases.
As we reported in our September newsletter, our focus is turning from research to outreach. Filed in the "I wish I had written that" drawer I refer you to The Civil Jury: Reviving an American Institution.
The authors of this well-researched and compelling work are past CJP Research Fellow, Richard L. Jolly, current CJP Academic Advisor, Valerie P. Hans and Robert S. Peck.
In this white paper the authors set forth research-based, common sense reforms to reinvigorate the civil jury system. Reforms that our founder, Steve Susman, championed for years. At the risk of oversimplification, we work to revive civil jury trials for these reasons:
- The jury system was a pillar in our founding as a country.
- The jury system engages our citizens and benefits society as a whole and also individual jurors.
- Given the current political climate regarding judicial appointments, engaging the general public as jurors is even more important.
- Jury verdicts give judges, attorneys and litigants the sense of what the community considers to be valid and invalid claims.
- Even if we did not have the above 4 reasons, a 12-person jury is the best method for deciding disputes.
What can we do?
It is human nature to gravitate to the familiar, the known. We tend toward the easy when given a choice between easy and hard. Jury trials are "harder" than bench trials. When I give a talk on What Judges Want I ask the audience the rhetorical question, "What do judges fear the most?" For me, it was having to redo a jury trial due to an erroneous ruling I made at trial. I did not want to impose on another 75 to 100 potential jurors to have to make their way to courthouse for jury selection. I did not want to cause the litigants additional time and expense. When an attorney stands and says "Objection!" in a jury trial all heads swivel to me and I must timely call it a ball or a strike. Although "judicial discretion" is a wide road, it tends to narrow when it comes to jury trials.
Jury trials are harder on the attorneys. There is the additional burden of jury selection and instructions. The evidence must be presented in the best form possible to twelve, as opposed to one. The sorting out of objections must be, or should be, faster. And finally, and more importantly, jury trials tend to be harder on the litigants in terms of cost and the time it takes to get to trial, time that has only increased due to the pandemic.
Some judges and some attorneys simply do not like jury trials. Some judges are judged themselves by how fast they clear dockets. Jury trials simply take longer. Some judges regard a case going to a jury as a failure on their part to settle the case. Changing minds is a tough proposition.
So what can we do? First, we need to recognize, support and applaud those judges and attorneys who are willing to try civil jury cases. Second, we need to start early in encouraging and training new judges and new attorneys to take civil cases to juries. All of the jury innovations we propose will help.
What have we been doing since September?
Civil Jury Innovations: Oh, the Possibilities
We presented this 2-hour program on September 23 of this year. This CLE for the Connecticut Bar Association grew out of a presentation we made to the judges in Connecticut for their education conference. This was at the invitation of one of our Judicial Advisors, Judge Susan Cobb. All of the attendees that responded to the post-seminar survey "strongly agreed" that the presentation provided a relevant and worthwhile learning experience. One commented, "Very helpful, informative and engaging."
VI International Jury Trial Congress
The Power of the Jury: the Experience of Argentina and the World
During this past year we have benefited from articles and updates from our colleagues in Argentina, Andrés Harfuch and Juan Sebastián Lloret, as they have reported on the advent of civil jury trials in that country. We were delighted to be asked to participate in this comprehensive conference which spanned 8 days and included 17 panels or addresses covering a wide range of jury trial issues.
I was on the round table panel: The Importance of the Civil Jury for the Judiciary of the 21st Century. In honor of Mario Juliano. Other CJP Academic Advisors participating in the conference included Valerie P. Hans, Shari Seidman Diamond, John Gastil, and Nancy Marder.
We have kept in touch with the conference organizers and once the conference video is completed we will post the link in our next newsletter.
Courtroom View Network
When I first started with the CJP, Steve Susman told me that he was in discussions with the Courtroom View Network about their work recording civil jury trials. While there are now a variety of platforms that stream criminal trials, few pay attention to civil jury cases. CVN has recorded over 1700 civil trials. This is a deep resource for those who are interested in the civil jury system. Several of our Judicial Advisors and Jury Consultant Advisors have been involved in these recorded trials. Going forward we are going to be reviewing the CVN archives to select clips from those trials that may highlight the use of the jury innovations we have been promoting. We hope to provide this resource to you through our newsletter, Twitter and Facebook accounts. We thank the Courtroom View Network for providing this resource to us at no cost. If you would like to see any of their recorded trials, CVN is glad to offer two weeks of free unlimited on-demand access to friends of the Civil Jury Project. Please email hello@cvn.com and reference the Civil Jury Project, and they will be happy to set you up with a complimentary account.
Social Media
Due to my lack of social media savvy I have neglected our social media platforms. This was a mistake. Many items of interest pass my desk each day that bear on civil jury trials. Accordingly, I am going to be posting these on our two media platforms, Twitter at https://twitter.com/JuryMatters and Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/JuryMatters/.
Preserving the Civil Jury Trial through Agreement and Innovation
This is a working title for the presentation I will be making in May for the Section of Litigation retreat for the Connecticut Bar Association.
News
We contacted Judge Matthew Williams (King County Superior Court) and he had much to report from the State of Washington. First, preliminary indications are that remote jury selection may show improvement in jury diversity according to a study conducted by Seattle University. The initial report has been withdrawn pending an algorithmic review and the final report has not yet been completed, but we will keep tabs on this and report the final results once released.
NPR interviewed Judge Jim Rogers (Chief Presiding Judge), Judge Regina Cahan (Chief Civil Judge), and Judge Williams, about their experiences and the future of remote jury operations. Judge Cahan reported that the King County Superior Court (KCSC) has used remote voir dire for all jury trials (criminal and civil) since June of 2020. If a juror can not appear for voir dire remotely, they are allowed to appear in-person. Since the pandemic began King County has conducted over 1050 fully remote bench trials. They have conducted over 311 jury trials. This includes 190 criminal jury trials and 121 civil jury trials. Of the 121 civil trials, 40 jury trials were in-person trials conducted in early 2021 at a local conference center following remote jury selection. The remaining 81 civil jury trials were totally remote.
For criminal trials, the KCSC has been conducting voir dire remotely, but having the jurors attend the actual trials in-person with stringent COVID protocols. Due to Omicron, King County Superior Court will suspend in-person jury trials for two weeks with the likelihood that in-person jury operations will remain suspended through the month of January. This suspension impacts criminal trials. Fully remote civil jury trials and remote jury operations will continue.
Judge Williams was recently interviewed by Law 360 and that article can be found here.
Congratulations are in order for Judge Williams and Judge Marsha Pechman (USDC WD WA). The Washington State Chapter of ABOTA named them "2021 Judges of the Year" for their efforts to keep jury trials going during the pandemic.
Training the Next Generation, Expedited Trials and Trial by Agreement
"With jury trials a rarity, few new lawyers will learn the art of trying a case before a jury,
thereby creating an endless cycle of lawyers opting not to go the jury route." p. 20
For every CJP presentation, whether it be a jury improvement lunch or a presentation to the bench and bar, we use a chart outlining what we think are the reasons for the decline in jury trials and assign to those reasons the label of "easy to change" or "hard to change".
Under the label "easy to change" we have (1) Lack of real trial lawyers and (2) Insufficient judicial education. Since September I have been a trainer for 3 separate advocacy programs for the National Institute for Trial Advocacy and New York Law School. In all of these advocacy training sessions we tell the attendees to treat the case as if it were a jury trial, even when the fact pattern would normally be a bench trial. We tell them that if they can persuade a jury, they can persuade a judge. Hopefully, these trainings will result in advocates who are not hesitant to try cases to a jury.
While viewing the excellent presentation Conducting Expedited Jury Trials produced by the ABOTA Foundation we were gratified to hear attorney Michael P. McGuire's (ABOTA National President 2019) positive reference to Steve Susman's Trial by Agreement. We agree that efforts to streamline and cut the costs of civil jury trials will assist in keeping them alive.