ScienceCastle.comScienceCastle.com - Jar Of Flies - Explained!

Greetings!

Jar of FliesCongratulations to all of you who were able to order their free dinosaur skeleton kit last week.

We are really proud of you. 67% of all students who participated in the quiz selected the correct answer.

Frank Cascarano, Physics Instructor at the Foothill College, CA was so kind to explain the physics occurring inside the jar.

Here is the question again for those who don't remember: Maxi and I had a little disagreement over the weight of flies in a jar.
You place the jar on a scale. The scale will register the most weight when the flies are
a) sitting on the bottom of the jar
b) flying around inside the jar
c) ... the weight of the jar is the same in both cases

Click here to watch Frank's explanation on our Youtube Channel or continue reading his explanation.

"Short answer is: it weighs the same whether the fly is hovering in the
middle of the jar or landed on the floor of the jar. Basically, when you weigh the jar you are weighing the jar and all of its contents. Another example, if the jar has air in it, the jar will weigh more than a jar that has been evacuated and just contains a vacuum.

Long answer is that it does depend slightly on whether the fly is moving (well, actually, whether the fly is accelerating). With the fly in the air the jar could weigh more or less than with the fly standing on the floor of the jar, depending on whether the fly begins moving up or down. Let's just say the average weight of the jar+air+fly when the fly is flying is the same as the weight with the fly on the floor of the jar."

We also liked deborah109's answer a lot! Thanks for your excellent explanation!

"Since the jar is closed when it is weighed all of its contents are being weighed. (jar, lid, air, and flies no matter the positin of the flies.) The flies in motion would still put pressure on the air then the jar then the scale."
Free ShippingBACK TO SCHOOL SALE - free shipping
Stock up on science kits. With our special BACK TO SCHOOL promotion you get free shipping on all U.S. orders of $50+. Click here to shop for science kits now.
ShrimperyNew Kits Arrived
Shrimpery - Educational Brine Shrimp Kit
Hatch Brine Shrimp. Just add water. An introductory kit for hatching Brine Shrimp Eggs. This is the perfect kit for children to learn about life and how it is created. The excitement that this kit sparks in children is enormous. Within 18-40 hours you have little brine shrimp swimming around in your Shrimpery. You can watch them hatch and escape out of their eggs. Click here to order this kit.
Science TestTest your Knowledge
How much do you really know about plants? Click here to do our plants test and see how you score against all the other smart students at ScienceCastle.com.
Plants BookLearn more about Plants
Join Mike and Maxi on their quest for Sarracenia Castle and learn everything about plants along the way ... This book is one of a kind because it is based on a unique 'storytelling' methodology. It starts out with a 'cliff-hanger' story and requires your fantasy and knowledge to be completed. After the story there are a number of science experiments related to plants that will help you arrive at a conclusion to the story. Click here to order this book from Amazon.com.
Yours,
Mike and Maxi
ScienceCastle.com