Advance Access Highlights
April 10, 2018

Subscribe  
April Issue       
Culture, Relationship Norms, and Dual Entitlement

According to the dual entitlement principle, consumers find it fair for firms to price asymmetrically to cost changes -- that is, for firms to increase prices when costs increase but maintain prices when costs decrease. However, a meta-analysis reveals asymmetric pricing is less prevalent in collectivistic (vs. individualistic) countries. The authors propose a fairness-based explanation, demonstrating that interdependent consumers in collectivistic cultures perceive asymmetric pricing to be less fair than do independent consumers in individualistic cultures. They attribute this cultural variation to culture-specific relationship norms. Specifically, they argue that while the practice of asymmetric pricing is consistent with the exchange norms among independent consumers that emphasize self-interest pursuit, it is inconsistent with the communal norms among interdependent consumers mandating firm benevolence. Supporting this argument, the authors find that directly manipulating communal (vs. exchange) norms yields similar differences in fairness perceptions that mimic those due to culture, the cultural differences are mediated by the communal mandate for firm benevolence, and the cultural differences are mitigated when a firm frames asymmetric pricing as benevolent.  
 
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ ucx118        
Psychological ownership, or the feeling that something is "mine," has garnered growing attention in marketing. Prior work focuses on the positive aspects of psychological ownership, but the authors draw attention to the darker side of psychological ownership: territorial behavior. They demonstrate that when consumers feel psychological ownership of a target, they are prone to perceptions of infringement and subsequent territorial responses when they infer that another individual feels ownership of the same target. Potential infringers are held less accountable when they acknowledge ownership prior to engaging in otherwise threatening behaviors, and when they could not be expected to know that a target is owned, as it was not clearly marked. In addition, high narcissists are subject to a psychological ownership metaperception bias, and are thus more apt than low narcissists to perceive infringement. A multitude of territorial responses are documented for both tangible (coffee, sweater, chair, pizza) and intangible (a design) targets of ownership. Further, consumers infer the psychological ownership of others from signals of the antecedents of psychological ownership: control, investment of self, and intimate knowledge.

DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ ucx111          
Beauty, Effort, and Misrepresentation: How Beauty Work Affects Judgments of Moral Character and Consumer Preferences
Women engage in a variety of beauty practices, or "beauty work," to enhance their physical appearance, such as applying cosmetics, tanning, or exercising. Although the rewards of physical attractiveness are well documented, perceptions of both the women who engage in efforts to enhance their appearance and the high-effort beauty products marketed to them are not well understood. The authors demonstrate that consumers judge women who engage in certain types of extensive beauty work as possessing poorer moral character. These judgments occur only for effortful beauty work perceived as transformative (significantly altering appearance) and transient (lasting a relatively short time), such that they emerge within cosmetics and tanning, yet not skincare or exercise. This effect is mediated by the perception that putting high effort into one's appearance signals a willingness to misrepresent one's true self, and translates into lower purchase intentions for higher-effort cosmetics. The authors identify several boundary conditions, including the attractiveness of the woman performing the beauty work and whether the effort is attributed to external norms or causes.   
 
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ ucx116              
Stranger Danger: When and Why Consumer Dyads Behave Less Ethically Than Individuals
While joint ethical violations are fairly common in the marketplace and in workplace, sports-team, and academic settings, little research has studied such collaborative wrongdoings. The authors compare the joint ethical decisions of pairs of people (dyads) to those of individual decision makers, ultimately finding that dyads in which the partners do not share a social bond with each other behave less ethically than individuals do. The authors propose that this effect occurs because joint ethical violations offer a means to socially bond with others. Consistent with this theory, they demonstrate that the dyads' subethicality relative to individuals is attenuated if the dyad partners establish rapport prior to the joint decision making, and in decision-making contexts in which social bonding goals are less active-namely, making a decision with an out-group versus in-group member. 
 
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ ucx108         
Crumpled Money
Other People's Money: Money's Perceived Purchasing Power Is Smaller for Others Than for the Self
People believe their money has greater purchasing power than the same quantity of others' money. Using a variety of products from socks to clocks to chocolates, the authors found that participants thought the same amount of money could buy more when it belonged to themselves versus others -- a pattern that extended to undesirable products. Participants also believed their money -- in the form of donations, taxes, fines, and fees -- would help charities and governments more than others' money. The authors tested six mechanisms based on psychological distance, the endowment effect, wishful thinking, better-than-average biases, pain of payment, and beliefs about product preferences. Only a psychological distance mechanism received support. Specifically, the perceived purchasing power of other people's money decreased logarithmically as others' psychological distance from the self increased, consistent with psychological distance's subadditive property. Further supporting a psychological distance mechanism, framing one's own money as distant (vs. near) reduced the self-other difference in perceived purchasing power.   
 
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ ucx119                     
      
 

Curator: Lisa E. Bolton


Curator: Güliz Ger




Like us on Facebook     Follow us on Twitter
  
The Journal of Consumer Research is sponsored by: