Current Issue Highlights
December 19, 2017

Subscribe  
December Issue       
Self-control is an important driver of choice, but might it also change choice's meaning, making it seem less indicative of preference? Choice often originates from one's preferences. As a result, choice is often seen as a reflection of preference, leading people to infer their preferences by observing their own choices. The authors suggest that self-control attenuates this process. Because self-control often overrides personal desires in favor of external constraints, norms, and long-term considerations, self-control is associated with a sense of attenuated correspondence between choice and individual preference. When the notion of self-control is salient, people are less likely to see their choices as reflecting their preferences or to infer preference from previous choices. As a result, evoking the notion of self-control attenuates the tendency to view choice as indicative of preference, even in contexts unrelated to where self-control was originally evoked. Thus, self-control shapes not only choice itself, but also the perceived meaning of choice.
 
Volume 44, Number 4, December 2017
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ucx069           
Consumer Responses to Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Contribution Type
The authors examine consumer reactions to two basic contribution types -- money versus in-kind -- in the CSR domain of disaster relief to demonstrate that while consumers evaluate a company more favorably when it makes in-kind rather than monetary contributions of equivalent value to CSR issues that are perceived to be less controllable, the pattern reverses when the company's contributions are made to CSR issues that are perceived to be more controllable. This interaction between contribution type and perceived issue controllability is more likely to manifest when controllability is accessible in the minds of consumers. The underlying process is driven by the extent to which the disparate emotionality of each contribution type matches the intensity of felt emotion evoked by CSR issues of varying perceived controllability, producing processing fluency.

Volume 44, Number 4, December 2017
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ucx063                    
The authors examine a new signal of self-expressiveness: whether the product is polarizing -- that is, whether some people strongly like the product and other people strongly dislike the product. They find that polarizing products are perceived to be more self-expressive and serve as stronger indicators of one's tastes and personality. As a result, people find products with bimodal rating distributions to be more desirable when they experience temporary or chronic low self-concept clarity. Further, people evaluate products with bimodal distributions more favorably in consumption contexts in which self-expression is important. These effects emerge when the bimodal distribution pertains to a self-expressive attribute (style) but not when it pertains to a non-self-expressive attribute (quality). Last, the effect is especially strong when people have the motivation to express an individual- rather than group-level identity. Hence, polarizing products are seen as vehicles for individual self-expression.
 
Volume 44, Number 4, December 2017
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ucx067            
Witnessing Moral Violations Increases Conformity in Consumption
Consumers frequently encounter moral violations (financial scandal, cheating, and corruption) in their daily lives. Yet little is known about how exposure to moral violations may affect consumer choice. By synthesizing insights from research on social order and conformity, the authors suggest that mere exposure to others' immoral behaviors heightens perceived threat to social order, which increases consumers' endorsement of conformist attitudes and hence their preferences for majority-endorsed choices in subsequently unrelated consumption situations. They show that exposure to moral violations increases consumers' subsequent conformity in consumption. Moreover, the effect disappears when the moral violator has already been punished by third parties and when the majority-endorsed option is viewed as being complicit with the moral violation. This research not only demonstrates a novel downstream consequence of witnessing moral violations on consumer choice but also advances our understanding of how conformity can buffer the negative psychological consequences of moral violations and how moral considerations can serve as an important basis for consumer choice.

Volume 44, Number 4, December 2017
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ucx061                     
Man Shopping
Out-of-Category Brand Imitation: Product Categorization Determines Copycat Evaluation
Copycat brands imitate the trade dress of other brands, such as their brand name, logo, and packaging design. Copycats typically operate in the core product category of the imitated brand under the assumption that such "in-category imitation" is most effective. In contrast,the authors demonstrate the benefits of "out-of-category imitation" for copycats, and the harmful effect on the imitated brand. Copycats are evaluated more positively in a related category, because consumers appraise the similarity between copycat and imitated brand more positively than in the core category, independent of the perceived similarity itself. This is due to a reduced salience of norms regarding imitation in the related category. Moreover, there is a damaging backlash effect of out-of-category imitation on the general evaluation of the imitated brand and on its key perceived product attributes.

Volume 44, Number 4, December 2017
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ucx065                      
The Price of Beauty: Differential Effects of Design Elements with and without Cost Implications in Nonprofit Donor Solicitations
Research on the optimization of donation solicitations has focused on language and content rather than appearance. The author considers how a solicitation's appearance influences donor response, finding that potential donors make inferences about the soliciting organization based on the aesthetics of the solicitation materials. In general, highly aesthetic elements increase perceptions of organizational professionalism, which consequently leads to greater donations. However, aesthetic enhancement can backfire; when high levels of aesthetics with cost implications (embossed cardstock, gold ink) are combined with high levels of aesthetics without cost implications (attractive background, appealing font), perceptions of organizational wastefulness discourage donations. Thus, the most effective solicitation is not the most beautiful but rather one offering high levels of aesthetics without cost implications and low levels of aesthetics with cost implications.

Volume 44, Number 4, December 2017
DOI: 10.1093/jcr/ucx059                     


Rik Pieters

      
 

Curator: Sharon Shavitt

Curator: Lisa E. Bolton
      
 
Washington Post
Pacific Standard
 
 




Like us on Facebook     Follow us on Twitter
  
The Journal of Consumer Research is sponsored by: