Creditor News
A Newsletter for individuals and businesses concerned with Creditor’s Rights

August 2026 | 413th Edition

 

Inside This Issue:


  • Construction Case Garnishments
  • Dischargeability - False Oath
  • Making Owners and General Contractors Personally Liable to Subcontractor, Laborer or Materialman
  • Deeds of Trust

Also Featuring:

  • Ted's Tips
  • Law Review: Litigation
  • Firm Attorney Biographies

Employee Spotlight:

Anne Adams

Creditor's Rights - It's Our Focus!

Creditors hear too much about debtors' rights - creditors need to fight back! Bankruptcy laws are primarily drawn to protect debtors. The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act also protects debtors, and limits creditors' activity. Both laws prescribe punishments for violations.

We believe that creditors deserve due process and consideration. We work hard to protect our clients' rights through collection activities, civil litigation, and bankruptcy practice. To be competitive, we offer retainer plans and several fee options. To be accessible, we promise prompt and consistent communication.

We would greatly appreciate the opportunity to meet with any prospective client to review your needs and services. Please schedule your appointment by calling Eddie at 804-545-6251, Jennifer at 804-545-6242, or Daniel at 804-545-6220.

 
 

Collections: Construction Case Garnishments

The United States District Court in Alexandria has reviewed a matter important to many supplier and contractor creditors: the garnishment of funds due their debtors from another party. The case was U.S. v. Harkins Builders Inc. In Harkins a material supplier was pursuing a garnishment proceeding against a builder who owed money to the judgment debtor, a drywall subcontractor. The Court ruled that the supplier was not bound by a mandatory arbitration clause in a separate contract between the builder and the drywall sub.


In Harkins a materials company supplied drywall materials to drywall subcontractors. When the drywall subs failed to pay for the materials, the supplier obtained a federal court judgment for $278,520. The supplier then initiated a garnishment proceeding against a builder to attach monies owed by the builder to the drywall sub under a contract between them. As garnishee, the sub confessed assets but argued that the amount it owed to the drywall sub should be reduced by setoffs totaling $50,853 allegedly owed by the sub to the builder under their contract. The garnishee also argued that any dispute about these setoffs must be resolved through arbitration, as provided in the contract between the drywall sub and the builder.


The Court rejected the contention that the resolution of the amount of money owed by the builder to the drywall sub and subjected to garnishment must be accomplished through arbitration. As a judgment creditor of the drywall sub, the supplier was not a party to the contract between the sub and the builder, and its interest was limited to the drywall sub's property interest in the builder's hands. The parties to the drywall builder contract agreed to arbitration as an efficient procedural mechanism for resolving contractual disputes, including disputes over amounts owed. The agreement to arbitrate, however, does not add or subtract value in the calculus for determining the value of the contract right. The Court ruled that since the judgment creditor was afforded court procedures for determining the value, the fact that the property before the court was created by a contract containing an arbitration clause did not require a non-party to the contract to follow the contract's procedural mechanisms for dispute resolution. Accordingly, the federal courts assumed jurisdiction to make the decision.

Ted's Tips

When giving us your delinquent accounts, always include a social security number, birth date, and other identifying information that could be helpful for skiptracing.

 

Bankruptcy: Dischargeability - False Oath

In the case of Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. v. McFarland, the United States Bankruptcy Court, sitting in Arlington, Virginia, Judge Tice, denied the debtor, a real estate developer, a discharge in bankruptcy because of false testimony.


The creditor had brought a complaint objecting to dischargeability because of allegedly false testimony given by the debtor in examinations under oath after the filing of the debtor's bankruptcy petition.


The Court found as fact that the debtor gave false testimony under oath 1) that he did not receive from a closely held corporation any proceeds of a $440.00 certificate of deposit, when in fact he and his co-shareholder each received $220,000 and 2) that he had no bank accounts in nor made any deposits to offshore banks, when in fact he drew checks in amounts in excess of $300,000 payable to a Cayman Island bank. 


Although the debtor denied that he had any fraudulent intent when he testified, the Court found it "highly implausible" that the debtor forgot about the withdrawal of the $220,000. The debtor also failed to produce any credible evidence refuting the natural presumption that some $300,000 worth of checks admittedly drawn by debtor payable to an offshore bank were transfers of funds to the bank or to an account in the bank.


Accordingly, Judge Tice found the evidence sufficient to warrant denial of the debtor's discharge.

Law Review of the Month: Litigation

The firm has extensive experience in litigation. Firm attorneys have tried cases in a broad range of matters across Virginia.

 

Real Estate: Making Owners and General Contractors Personally Liable to Subcontractor, Laborer or Materialman

Virginia Code §43-11 provides a way for owners or general contractors to be made personally liable to subcontractor, laborer or materialman if notice is appropriately given, and if the payer makes payment to the owing party without paying the notifying creditor. Specifically, §43-11 (2) states that:


“…if such subcontractor, or person furnishing labor or material shall at any time after the work is done or material furnished by him and before the expiration of thirty days from the time such building or structure is completed or the work thereon otherwise terminated furnish the owner thereof or his agent and also the general contractor, or the general contractor alone in case he is the only one notified, with a second notice stating a correct account, verified by affidavit, of his actual claim against the general contractor or subcontractor, for work done or materials furnished and of the amount due, then the owner, or the general contractor, if he alone was notified, shall be personally liable to the claimant for the actual amount due to the subcontractor or persons furnishing labor or material by the general contractor or subcontractor, provided the same does not exceed the sum in which the owner is indebted to the general contractor at the time the second notice is given or may thereafter become indebted by virtue of his contract with the general contractor, or in case the general contractor alone is notified the sum in which he is indebted to the subcontractor at the time the second notice is given or may thereafter become indebted by virtue of his contract with the general contractor. But the amount which a person supplying labor or material to a subcontractor can claim shall not exceed the amount for which such subcontractor could file his claim.”


The notices referred to in this code section are commonly referred to in the industry as “42-11 letters”. We have experienced attorneys and staff who can examine title, file mechanic’s liens, and litigate to enforce the same. If you have a need, please call us.

 

Foreclosure: Deeds of Trust

It all starts with the deed of trust. The deed of trust is the primary method of acquiring a lien against real estate in Virginia. With a deed of trust, the owner of the real estate conveys legal title to a trustee, in trust, to secure the noteholder’s indebtedness. A deed of trust establishes a lien on the subject real estate upon execution by the grantor and recordation in the land records of the Circuit Court for the jurisdiction (County or City) in which the property is located. While recording the deed of trust is not essential to the validity of the deed of trust between the parties, an unrecorded deed of trust does not establish a lien on the subject real estate as to other creditors and purchasers of the grantor. An unrecorded deed of trust will not provide the beneficiary of the deed of trust with a priority position against other creditors with recorded liens, even if they are subsequent in time.

Looking for more Creditor News articles? Check our our Creditor News Blog!

Lafayette Whitlock Fischer Hughes PLC is a full-service creditor’s rights firm. While many attorneys do “collections”, few attorneys have the trained expertise and staff to represent creditors in all four areas of Creditor’s Rights—Collections, Bankruptcy, Real Estate and Foreclosure. We do, and, we represent credit unions, banks, loan companies, homeowner associations, doctor’s offices, landlords, small businesses and individuals. In Creditor News we will explore all four areas of Creditor’s Rights.

Meet the Attorneys of LAW, PLC

Edward S. Whitlock, III, Esq.

Editor

Eddie is a Richmond native with a concentrated law practice in creditor representation. His practice focuses on creditor’s rights (Collection, Bankruptcy, Real Estate, and Foreclosure), but also includes the general practice of law (Business and Will & Estate Planning). Eddie holds a B.A. (1984) in Political Science, and a Juris Doctor (1987) from the University of Richmond. He is the former Chief of Admin/Military Law for the 329th Support Group (Area) in the Virginia Army National Guard. Eddie is the former President of both the Henrico County Bar Association and the Virginia Creditors’ Bar Association. He is the chair of the Virginia State Bar’s Fee Dispute Resolution Program, and a former member of the Virginia State Bar’s Disciplinary Committee. He is the chairman of the Henrico Economic Development Authority. He is the President of Home Loans for KOVAR Corporation. He is also a former director of Henrico CASA, and a former adjunct professor of criminal law at J. Sargeant Reynolds Community College.

Jennifer W. Fischer, Esq.

Editor

Jennifer concentrates her practice in creditor representation (Collection, Bankruptcy, Real Estate, and Foreclosure), but also Business and Will & Estate Planning. Jennifer holds a BS (2011) in business administration from Christopher Newport University, and a Juris Doctorate (2014) from University of Richmond, T.C. Williams School of Law. She was admitted to the Virginia State Bar in October 2014. She is a Past President of the Virginia Creditors' Bar association and the Henrico County Bar Association.

C. Daniel Waters, Esq.

Editor

Daniel Waters primarily represents consumer and commercial finance companies, credit unions, medical practices, landlords, and construction material companies in creditor’s rights and civil litigation matters in Virginia. He has represented clients in Virginia Circuit and General District Courts as well as the Federal District Court in Richmond. After graduating from Old Dominion University with a double major in Political Science and Philosophy, Daniel studied law at Regent University School of Law in Virginia Beach. He serves as the President of the Virginia Creditors' Bar Association and as Trustee at a local private school. He resides in the Richmond area with his wife and children.

Megan C. Jones, Esq.

CREDITOR NEWS © 2026. This newsletter is prepared and published by Edward S. Whitlock, III, Esquire, Jennifer W. Fischer, Esquire, and C. Daniel Waters, Esquire and is provided free of charge. The information contained in this newsletter is general in nature. It is intended to be helpful but does not, and is not meant to, replace consultation with an attorney in connection with a legal problem. Readers needing legal advice should retain competent legal counsel.

 

Lafayette Whitlock Fischer Hughes PLC

www.lawplc.com

 
Facebook  Twitter  Linkedin