Disability Rights in the Age of Trump
by Sandra Fulbright-Myers
The disability community has been under constant attack by the Trump administration since the day it took office.
From MAHA's (Make America Healthy Again) pseudoscientific hysteria against autistic people[1] to the weaponization of discredited psychiatric quackery against the LGBT community[2], attacks against the disabled are part of the Trump administration's broader attacks against every population that deviates from MAGA's white Christo-fascist ideal, as discussed in the Heritage Foundation's Project 2025.[3]
The most recent outrage against the disabled is a Justice Department opinion that reinterprets the Olmstead decision, widely hailed as the disability community's "Brown v Board." This 1999 Supreme Court case, Olmstead v. L.C, held that under the Americans with Disabilities Act, states must provide community-based services to individuals with mental disabilities when appropriate, rather than confining them to institutions. This landmark ruling pointed to the fact that unjustified institutionalization is a form of discrimination against people with disabilities.[4]
"The Justice Department released a new legal opinion Thursday that civil rights experts say represents a significant attack against people with mental, physical and intellectual disabilities who receive state-funded services. The Office of Legal Counsel opinion said the states are not actually required by law to integrate mentally disabled patients with their peers by providing community or home-based care, a finding experts say runs counter to long-standing legal precedent and would lead to greater rates of institutionalizing people with disabilities.”[5] The post on the DOJ website completely reinterprets an opinion that is “a cornerstone of America's disability rights law."[6]
In response, Mia Ives-Rublee, senior director for the Disability Justice Initiative at the Center for American Progress, said:
This is a direct challenge to a bedrock principle, protected by the ADA, that disabled people have the basic right to live and participate within their communities. More than 25 years ago, the U.S. Supreme Court reaffirmed this position, stating that the segregation of disabled people diminishes the everyday life activities of individuals and violates protections against discrimination from public entities. Through an ADA mandate, the attorney general issued an integration regulation that requires public entities to provide community-based services in the least restrictive settings.
The attempt to roll back Title II of the ADA undermines decades of progress toward independence, inclusion, and equal opportunity for millions of disabled people. The disability community has spent generations fighting for equal rights, and our hard-won gains are worth defending.[7]
One way disabled people are being discriminated against is through involuntary commitment (IVC), which is already problematic, and the DOJ’s plan appears to be moving toward more institutionalization and less community integration. Administration policies would only increase current abuse. Involuntary commitment is a debt trap for the disabled, and the Trump administration's intended policies will only worsen the situation.
According to Rusty Miles, director of the Emergency Department at Carteret Health Care in Morehead City, NC, the system is broken, and numerous hospital administrators agree that the IVC process is both misused and overused. Rather than being used to protect the person from harm against self or others, ICV is sometimes used punitively or for expediency, as when a spouse commits a partner, or when patients with dementia, a physical disease, are rehoused in mental institutions when nursing facilities take out IVC papers. Similarly, children end up in a committal process either because it is the only way they can get services or because they are fostered and need a place to live![8]
Financially, the disabled are often held responsible for their treatment, including inpatient hospitalization, which is often thousands of dollars of medical bills. No matter the facility or funding provider, costs can run well over $2,000 per day. A 30-day commitment order could easily mean a bill for $60,000. Funding sources seldom cover the entire amount leaving the client in debt and facing financial ruin. Indeed, the “Kaiser Family Foundation reported that in 2021, 15% of people with disabilities have unpaid medical debt, compared with 6% of their nondisabled peers. IVC poses a serious threat to the financial well-being of people with disabilities."[9]
On a personal level, this author has been the recipient of multiple verbal attacks dating back to 2017, in which MAGA supporters have used "The one who is unwilling to work shall not eat" (2 Thessalonians 3:10) as justification for the complete elimination of aid to the disabled. Never mind the fact that the verse itself specifies the unwilling rather than the unable. In fact, 2 Thessalonians 3:10 is interpreted as blanket permission to deny charity at every level, in spite of everything Jesus said to the contrary. It's one of the most hypocritical "clobber" verses wielded as a disingenuous weapon against the poor and disabled.
Empathy has been demonized on both the spiritual and secular fronts. Conventional arguments that appeal to common decency only work on those who deny the function of empathy in human society.
This isn't a fringe right wing belief. A Big 5 Publisher is in on the scam of convincing Evangelicals that denying people help is what's best for them. Penguin Random house is the publisher of Toxic Empathy: How Progressives Exploit Christian Compassion by Allie Beth Stuckey.
"The term [suicidal empathy] is commonly used by right-wing commentators and Christian nationalist figures to criticize empathy toward groups such as immigrants and racial minorities. In this context, it is sometimes linked to the Great Replacement conspiracy theory. Writing for The Bulwark, Cathy Young said the phrase was "becoming a right-wing buzzword"[10].
I have been the victim of many verbal attacks by mediocrities who think it's funny to use Nazi terminology like "life unworthy of life" and "useless eater". Nothing displays genocidal intent more strongly than the deliberate employment of phrases already used to justify mass murder in the past.
July is Disability Pride Month. Call your representatives and support policies that uplift every person in our society, and especially the disabled.
[1] “ASAN Reiterates: MAHA Strategy Is Dishonest & Dangerous - Autistic Self Advocacy Network.” Autistic Self Advocacy Network, 18 Sept. 2025, https://autisticadvocacy.org/2025/09/asan-reiterates-maha-strategy-is-dishonest-dangerous/
[2] Dallara, Angela. “Fact Sheet: Landmark Supreme Court Case Regarding Protections against So-Called Conversion “Therapy” for Youth.” GLAAD | GLAAD Rewrites the Script for LGBTQ Acceptance., GLAAD, 1 Oct. 2025, glaad.org/fact-sheet-landmark-supreme-court-case-regarding-protections-against-so-called-conversion-therapy-for-youth/. Accessed 22 June 2026.
[3] The Heritage Foundation. “Project 2025 Mandate for Leadership.” The Heritage Foundation, 2023.
[4] Olmstead Rights. “Olmstead Decision.” Olmsteadrights.org, Legal Aid Atlanta, 2011, www.olmsteadrights.org/about-olmstead/. Accessed 22 June 2026.
[5] Lynch, Sarah N. “States Aren’t Required to Provide Community-Based Care for People with Disabilities, New DOJ Opinion Claims.” Cbsnews.com, CBS News, 18 June 2026, www.cbsnews.com/news/doj-disability-opinion-community-care. Accessed 22 June 2026.
[6] Ibid
[7] Christian Unkenholz. “STATEMENT: The Trump Administration Is Laying the Groundwork to Roll Back Decades of Progress for the Disability Community.” Center for American Progress, 22 June 2026, www.americanprogress.org/press/statement-the-trump-administration-is-laying-the-groundwork-to-roll-back-decades-of-progress-for-the-disability-community/. Accessed 22 June 2026.
[8] Disability Rights NC. “Involuntary Commitment in NC: Overused, Misused, and Harmful.” DRNC, Disability Rights NC, 26 May 2025, disabilityrightsnc.org/news/involuntary-commitment-in-nc-overused-misused-and-harmful/#elementor-toc__heading-anchor-6. Accessed 22 June 2026.
[9] ibid
[10] “Suicidal Empathy.” Wikipedia, 17 June 2026. Accessed 22 June 2026.
|