John McCabe - Symphonies No.'s 2 and 3, Cello Concerto "Songline". BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra, Raphael Wallfisch (Signum) LISTEN HERE | "What is striking and gratifying... is the lucidity of McCabe’s music, its textures remaining clearly defined through writing of enormous colour and scope. The Symphony No 3, Hommages, inhabits a lusher soundworld, densely weaving in nods to Haydn and Nielsen while also looking in other directions – one passage with muted strings and celeste could almost be Shostakovich reimagined by the Strauss of Der Rosenkavalier. Vividly energised and expressive throughout, the performances do all three works justice." Erica Jeal, The Guardian | Gramophone Editor's Choice and Best New Classical Recordings for McCabe Symphonies and Cello Concerto | |
"The earliest work here is the Second Symphony of 1971, which enjoyed initial fame when recorded for EMI soon after its premiere by the CBSO and Louis Frémaux, coupled with the previous year’s Notturni ed Alba sung by Jill Gomez (11/73). With this landmark collection currently unavailable it is good to welcome a magnificent new recording by the BBC Scottish under Kenneth Woods to refresh the memory of a standout score. It bristles with kinetic energy...The Third Symphony...[w]ritten in 1978 for the RPO and Charles Dutoit, this seems to me an even more exciting work than its predecessor and its first recording thus long overdue. The writing feels freer and the structure flows naturally as a fast-slow-fast arch which finally grows inexorably into an overpowering Nielsen-like climax that immediately fades magically with a Haydnesque surprise. A similar trajectory informs the much later Cello Concerto, commissioned by the Hallé for Truls Mørk and Mark Elder in 2007. Raphael Wallfisch is the passionate soloist here – but again it seems perverse to have waited two decades for such a compelling score to be recorded. The narrative is inspired by ‘the invisible pathways of the Australian Aboriginals, routes that they sing into life’ and which the cellist traces eloquently through a vivid landscape, often evoking the natural world and suggested by the title, Songline. No praise can be too high for these splendid performances, detailed notes by our own Guy Rickards and top-notch production by Andrew Keener. A winner!" Geraint Lewis, Gramophone Magazine
| | |
Lebrecht’s Album of the Week
7 June, 2026
Norman Lebrecht - The Critic
"If the name John McCabe still resonates, it may be for his Decca recordings of the complete piano music of Joseph Haydn, father of the four-movement symphony. Raised on Merseyside by Irish and German-Finn parents, McCabe was drawn to Carl Nielsen and Karl Amadeus Hartmann as primary influences. His orchestral music was regularly performed up to his death in 2015, seldom since.
"It is wonderfully refreshing to hear his second and third symphonies again. Both offer structural assurance from the opening statement, one a solo flute, the other a full-ensemble theme. You know where you’re going with McCabe and you sense that the musicians are enjoying the journey every bit as much as you are. The music tells a story and there’s enough going on to sustain concentration. I am reminded of other lost-property symphonists — Alan Rawsthorne, Edmund Rubbra, Malcolm Arnold, Peter Maxwell Davies. All male, none diverse. Don’t expect to hear them any time soon.
"The BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Kenneth Woods, give full expressive value to McCabe’s civilised painterly scores, full of dips and dashes that you’ll want to revisit. Raphael Wallfisch is a mite introspective in the pastel cello concerto but his restraint matches the composer’s undulating understatement. This is such good music I cannot imagine it will be forgotten. The literary novel is making a vigorous comeback from its long-proclaimed death. The modern symphony is overdue a comparable comeback"
| | "This is an intelligently planned and finely executed release, restoring three major works to the centre of McCabe’s achievement. Wallfisch brings to Songline wisdom and emotional reserve; Woods and the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra bring to all three scores structural conviction, colour and urgency. This is indispensable listening for anyone interested in the British symphony after Tippett and Simpson – and persuasive evidence that McCabe’s neglect is becoming increasingly indefensible. Taken as a whole, the disc makes a compelling case for McCabe as both master craftsman and unmistakably personal musical dramatist of distinction...the three works reveal not a composer repeatedly reinventing himself, but one continually refining an individual language – rhythmically alert, harmonically mobile and fastidiously scored, with argument and colour held in unusually productive balance." Europadisc CD of the Month | | "I like John McCabe as a composer, and I think that, outside of the UK, we do not hear enough of his music performed, so this is a very welcome recording of three major works, performed by an orchestra and soloist who provide a fine account of these works, and a conductor who understands the intricacies and direction of this music. I do hope there is greater interest in this quite individual composer of our time. The recorded sound is warm and clear, and the booklet is informative. This is a recording to savour." Geoff Pearce, Classical Music Daily | | "This is a major release. McCabe’s cello concerto, a work of extraordinary construction and beauty, is one of his most important and compelling works. Premiered by Truls Mørk in 2007, its recording by the equally accomplished Wallfisch is long overdue. ..The BBC SSO play with huge commitment under Kenneth Woods, the recording is exceptionally clear, and all instrumental spotlighting has been achieved subtly and naturally. McCabe has been finely served, and it is to be hoped that another issue is on the way." Andrew Plant, British Music Society | | Recording McCabe with BBC SSO, Raphael Wallfisch and Andrew Keener. A joy! | | Steve Elcock - Symphony No. 4, Viola Concerto, Hammering, Fermature. Moravian Philharmonic, Paul Silverthorne, viola. (Toccata) LISTEN HERE | | |
"When writing my Contemporary Composer profile of Steve Elcock (5/25), the unrecorded piece that excited my anticipation most acutely (from a synthesised performance on the composer’s website) was the Fourth Symphony (2012‑13, rev 2017). It has an important place in Elcock’s story, being one of the scores (Symphony No 3 was another) that caught Martin Anderson’s attention at Toccata Classics, initiating the series of recordings of the past decade. The Third made it on to disc, No 4 did not; its BBC premiere was cancelled due to Covid and only now has it appeared, in this fine, committed performance from the Moravian Philharmonic Orchestra in Olomouc, conducted by one of Elcock’s growing band of champions, Kenneth Woods. The result does not disappoint.” —Guy Rickards, Gramophone
| | |
Four Stars for Steve Elcock's Orchestral Music, Volume Four from BBC Music Magazine!
“Big climaxes, busy and spangled, regularly arrive to shake your speakers. Sinuous instrumental solos tug at your heart. … committed conducting from Kenneth Woods, and polish and gusto from his Moravian orchestra.” —Geoff Brown, BBC Music Magazine
| | |
World Premiere Symphony Recordings by Kenneth Woods
Click on cover image for more details, reviews, streaming links and CD purchase
| | |
Kenneth Woods is
Artistic Director and Conductor of the:
| | | | |