Logo
Vol. 7, Issue 5
May 2, 2016

NY Attorney General Continues
Assault Against Auto Dealers

     During the past two years New York State Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman has conducted dozens of investigations into the sales practices of new and used car dealers resulting in millions of dollars of restitution paid to consumers and millions more in fines and penalties awarded to the State of New York.  In April Mr. Schneiderman announced that "consumers deserve to be treated honestly by car dealerships" and that "my office will continue to make it a priority to crackdown on these deceptive business practices that target unsuspecting consumers".

     In the past few months New York's Office of the Attorney General has initiated or completed investigations into the following dealership and repair shop practices:
  1. Sale of credit repair and identity theft protection services;
  2. Sale of "VIN Etch" reimbursement/replacement vehicle discount programs;
  3. Deceptive Internet and newspaper advertisements;
  4. Failure to clearly and conspicuously itemize the terms and cost of after-market products and/or services; and
  5. Issuance of fraudulent safety and/or emissions inspection certificates.    
     The Attorney General has auto dealers in his sights and apparently will continue to investigate dealership sales practices until dealerships cease making themselves easy picking for deceptive trade practice violations.  It is imperative that dealers look into the sales practices at their dealerships and to speak to their employees about the manner in which sales are conducted.  It is more important than ever for dealers to make sure that their employees are fully trained on NYS and federal regulations on vehicle sales practices.  

     The LaBonte Law Group can help to ensure compliance at your dealership through its regulatory sales training program that educates employees on the many laws which impact auto dealerships.  We can also review your deal jackets to determine if you may be exposed to potential fines and penalties from state agencies and consumer lawsuits.  For more information on scheduling a training program for your dealership call or e-mail Stevan LaBonte at 516-280-8580 or slabonte@labontelawgroup.com.

Is your dealership at-risk for a
TCPA violation  or class action lawsuit?

       The Telephone Consumer Protection Act ("TCPA") requires those businesses which engage in telemarketing to obtain prior express written consent from a consumer in order to make artificial or prerecorded telemarketing calls to a residential phone line or wireless number, or to send text messages or place calls to a wireless number using an automatic telephone dialing system.  Failure to follow the requirements under the TCPA can subject the dealership to extensive fines, penalties and possibly class action litigation seeking millions in damages for a group of consumers.  
 
     Several years ago the federal government revised the TCPA and removed the automatic exemption for marketing calls to customers with prior established business relationships.  Therefore, businesses must obtain the "prior express written consent" from a customer before telemarketing, advertising or texting from an auto-dialer, prerecorded device or software solution.  Written consent must be clear and conspicuous and not be a condition of purchase.  In addition,  a business cannot text a customer to ask if it is okay to text them without prior express consent.  The express written consent must be provided BEFORE you contact the customer. 
 
     In a non-telemarketing context, where the consumer gives the salesperson his or her cell phone number, there is no violation of the TCPA if the sales person calls or texts the customer on their cell without express written permission.  There is no violation if you are calling or texting the customer to complete an active sales transaction or to seek authorization for repairs to a vehicle already in the shop, or to notify the customer that the vehicle is ready to be picked up.  However, if the customer has not provided the dealership with the cell number or if the marketing call is unsolicited and done for the purpose of selling products or services then you must have prior written permission before calling the customer.   
 
     The statutory penalty is $500 per violation.  If a customer can show the violation was "knowing" or willful a court can increase the penalty up to $1,500 per violation.  In addition, the TCPA includes a private right-of-action provision allowing consumers to individually sue a business who violates the law for damages of up to $500 per call or actual damages for any violations (or up to three times the statutory or actual damages for willful or knowing violations).  This can result in hefty fines, penalties or even a class action suit.   The LaBonte Law Group is currently defending an new car dealer client from a class action suit alleging TCPA violations so it cannot be stressed strongly enough that dealers must ensure that all dealership employees are aware of, and comply fully with, the TCPA.     
 
     It is recommended that when you sell a vehicle to a customer or service their vehicle that you request their express written permission to text them in the future.  The same request for express permission should be listed on your websites and social media sites.     
 
     The biggest mistake you can make is to fail to honor customer opt-out requests.  Generally, if a dealer inadvertently contacts a customer without express written permission the customer usually will not file a complaint or pursue litigation if the dealer immediately honors their request to cease all further solicitations.  While the dealer may be in violation of the law a formal complaint may not be made if the customer's contact information is removed from your database and no further solicitations are made.  Therefore, it is imperative that you have a strict company policy to ensure that all opt-out requests are timely honored. 

     For more information on the TCPA call Stevan LaBonte at 516-280-8580 or by e-mail at slabonte@labontelawgroup.com.
Should you have any questions or need advice on anything related to dealership operations please do not hesitate to give me a call at 516-280-8580 or send me an e-mail to slabonte@labontelawgroup.com.  Your questions will be answered promptly.
Sincerely,

Stevan H. LaBonte
LaBonte Law Group, PLLC
100 Ring Road West, Suite 108
Garden City, NY 11530

516.280.8580 (Phone) 
631.794.2434 (Fax)