|
Recently, a reader sent me a link to an article in Electro IQ, with a title guaranteed to generate clicks: "Adobe Premiere Pro vs Final Cut Pro Statistics – Which One is Better? (2025)"
A great title, but a useless article. Why? Because it was written by someone who has never edited, nor understands how NLEs are used.
Their analysis was based on market share, the industries and companies using each software, target audiences, pricing models, and industry reputation. None of which are relevant to picking an editing toolset.
Their conclusion: "The right choice depends on platform preference, budget model, and professional demands—both deliver professional-grade editing tuned to very different user paths." Did they describe the paths? No.
Sigh... What a useless waste of pixels. Imagine a comparison between a hammer and a screwdriver. Clearly, there are more screwdrivers in the market than hammers, but hammers are cheaper. Both can be used by professionals or hobbyists. A screwdriver is useless for driving nails, but a hammer has problems twisting a screw. Conclusion: Which you pick depends upon the job you are doing.
How helpful is a review like this? Not helpful at all.
When it comes to comparing software - especially complex tools like NLEs, or audio DAWs, the KEY question is: Which software has the tools you need to accomplish your tasks quickly, easily and with the quality you expect.
If everyone in the world is using a hammer, but I need to twist a screw, market share is not meaningful. Even if a screwdriver is half the price of a hammer, it is still a bad choice for pounding nails. Hammers are easy to use, while screwdrivers require muscle coordination, does that make hammers the best choice?
Be careful when reading reviews. Lots of people have opinions. Opinions are easy. Informed opinions - those are harder to find, but much more valuable! Beware of anyone pitching "The best...". Those articles - especially from no-name sources - are simply click bait.
When it comes to video editing, the only answer to: "What is the best video editor?" is: "It depends upon what you want to do." Instead, here's a much better question: "This is what I need to do, what's the best NLE that will enable me do it?"
Until next Monday, stay healthy, stay hopeful and edit well.
|