|
On Tuesday, September 29th, Staten Island judge Wayne Ozzi – who had previously issued a Temporary Restraining Order barring New York City from enforcing the Pied-A-Terre Tax (“PAT Tax”) – issued a Decision and Order granting the request by a group of homeowners to stop enforcement of the current PAT Tax and force the City to “start over.”
The ruling directly addresses concerns CCU has raised about an implementation process that placed an unfair burden on homeowners, relied on incomplete information, and treated primary residences as though they needed to qualify for an “exemption.” The court found that primary residences are not subject to the surcharge in the first place, and that the burden of making that determination rests with DOF, not homeowners.
DOF must now restart the process, using available tax and other information to make individualized determinations before sending new notices. The pied-à-terre surcharge itself remains in effect, but the current rollout has been invalidated.
CCU will continue to monitor the situation and advocate for a fair, accurate, and workable implementation process for New York’s co-op and condo communities.
Read the full court ruling at the link below:
|