|
This week’s newsletter discusses two cases filed by conservative public interest organizations challenging race and ethnicity requirements in public health programs. We also cover a recent paper published by members of the Public Health Law Watch team. You can find an archive of our previous newsletters here.
Jimenez v. Pan et al.
In Jimenez v. Pan et al. (Docket No. 2:26-cv-03500, U.S. District Court for the Central District of California), a non-Black mother is challenging California's Black Infant Health (BIH) program, a state-funded maternal and child health initiative that restricts enrollment to Black and African American women who are pregnant or up to six months postpartum. The program was established by the California Legislature to reduce Black infant mortality rates and other racial health disparities. It is administered at the state, county, and city levels, providing participants with prenatal and postpartum group sessions, health insurance enrollment assistance, family planning counseling, and other support services. The program receives federal funding through Title V Maternal and Child Health Services block grants. Plaintiff Erica Jimenez was told she was ineligible for the BIH program because she is not black.
On April 2, 2026, Jimenez, along with a similarly situated class of individuals who meet every eligibility criterion for the program except race, are seeking a declaration that the racial eligibility requirement is unconstitutional, a permanent injunction barring Defendants from enforcing it, and nominal damages. The Plaintiff alleges that conditioning access to public health benefits based on race violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits racial discrimination in federally funded programs. The case was filed by the Pacific Legal Foundation, a conservative public interest law firm.
The case was filed on April 2, 2026, and is still ongoing.
Do No Harm v. HHS
In Do No Harm v. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services et al. (Docket No. 1:26-cv-01062, U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia), Plaintiff Do No Harm is seeking to remove the race and ethnicity requirements of the Native Hawaiian Health Scholarship Program, which is administered by HHS. Do No Harm, a conservative advocacy group that has filed several similar racial discrimination suits on behalf of their healthcare professional members, alleges that the scholarship program violates the Fifth Amendment's equal protection principle because scholarship assistance is only available to students who are Native Hawaiian.
The Native Hawaiian Health Scholarship Program was established in 1988 to provide funding and improve healthcare outcomes for Native Hawaiians. As part of the program, recipients must commit to working in medically underprivileged communities in Hawaii for at least two years. Papa Ola Lōkahi, the nonprofit that administers the scholarship, says the program has awarded more than 330 scholarships to Native Hawaiians, who receive funding for tuition, books, other educational costs, and a monthly stipend. The program was established in response to a 1985 study, which identified the lack of accessible healthcare providers as a key driver of health disparities among Native Hawaiians, with increased Native Hawaiian representation among healthcare providers identified as a critical solution. Dr. Sheri-Ann Daniels, CEO of Papa Ola Lōkahi, said that efforts like Do No Harm's lawsuit “ignore both the historical context and the ongoing need to safeguard equitable access to care throughout Hawaii.”
Plaintiff claims that several of their members have attempted to apply for the scholarship program, but after noting they were not Native Hawaiian on the application, they were told they were ineligible for the scholarship. Do No Harm argues that the program’s race and ethnicity requirements do not meet the strict scrutiny standard of employing measures that are narrowly tailored to further a compelling government interest. The government’s justification for the program is that there are “unique health needs of Hawaiian communities” that require “quality, culturally competent health services.” Do No Harm falsely asserts that this justification is not compelling, and cites to their own study with flawed conclusions that there is no meaningful relationship between patient-physician racial matching and clinical outcomes. Several studies refute this claim, including research published in 2025 by UCLA, which showed patient-surgeon racial and ethnic concordance was associated with lower readmission and reduced length of stay for patients.
Plaintiff seeks a declaratory judgment that the scholarship program is unconstitutional, as well as a preliminary and permanent injunction prohibiting the Secretary of HHS from enforcing the program’s race-based requirements. The complaint was filed on March 30, 2026, and HHS has not yet responded to the complaint.
In an interview, Dr. Daniels said she has limited confidence that the Trump Administration, which has been hostile toward any initiatives resembling diversity, equity, and inclusion, will “mount a vigorous defense.” In our Health Equity Litigation Report published in July 2025, PHLW tracked litigation challenging efforts to improve health equity, including challenges to programs with racial preferences or requirements. We will continue to monitor these types of lawsuits, including cases against the federal government, who is unlikely to defend these equity-promoting programs.
“The Detrimental Shift: How the Judiciary is Eroding Our Health”
This month, the Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics published “The Detrimental Shift: How the Judiciary is Eroding Our Health,” an article written by Shannon Rempe, Madison Lee (’27), and Wendy Parmet from Northeastern University, and Jami Crespo from ChangeLab Solutions. This paper explores how U.S. courts have generally deferred to public health authorities except in recent years when courts, particularly the Supreme Court, have limited deference to administrative agencies, undermined equal protection, and constrained governments’ capacity to protect health equity. The authors draw on an empirical review of 30 lawsuits filed between January 2024 and May 2025 challenging governmental and institutional health equity initiatives.
This article analyzes and expands upon the litigation tracking captured in our July 2025 Health Equity Litigation Report (linked above) and comes at a time when public health and health equity efforts continue to be weakened by the courts. As you read this article, we ask that you think about any local or state cases you have come across that impact public health and health equity. Please share those cases to help inform the work of Northeastern's Advancing Public Health & Health Equity in the Courts team. We will continue to track this type of litigation and get involved, as appropriate, through amicus briefs or other meaningful support.
|