This newsletter is distributed by Public Health Law Watch as part of Act for Public Health, a working group of the Public Health Law Partnership that is convening to provide law and policy research, analysis, and expertise in support of public health authority.
This week's case updates:
Monday, 7/10: In Green Bay, Wisconsin, a lawsuit was settled between the Republican National Committee and the Green Bay City Clerk, Celestine Jeffreys. The issue at hand was that the city allowed election observers to have access to early voting during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic. Overall, the court favored the city.
Tuesday, 7/11: The Maine Department of Health and Human Services has proposed removing the COVID-19 vaccine from the list of required immunizations for health care workers. Currently, a lawsuit has been filed by workers against the state of Maine for removing this requirement.
Wednesday, 7/12: Magistrate Judge Patricia Dodge decided to dismiss the plaintiffs' claims in Ulery v. Jackson-Decarcia. This case involved a Pennsylvania employee who claimed that a COVID-19 paid leave incentive plan discriminated against those who are unvaccinated.
Spotlight: Michigan Court of Appeals Reverses Decision on Governor Whitmer’s Gatherings and Face Mask Executive Order
On June 29, 2023, in T&V Associates, Inc d/b/a River Crest Catering v. Director of Health and Human Services, the Michigan Court of Appeals, in a majority opinion written by Judge Gadola, reversed the Court of Claims’ previous decision and ruled that emergency orders limiting gatherings and requiring masking during the pandemic that were issued by Michigan’s health department were unconstitutional.
In a previous decision, on October 2,2020, the Supreme
Court of Michigan found Governor Gretchen Whitmer did not have authority under the state’s Emergency Management Act of 1976 (EMA) to declare a
“‘state of emergency’ or ‘state ofdisaster’” regarding the COVID-19 pandemic after April 30, 2020. Hertel then issued the challenged order using her powers under MCL 333.2253, which grants the department powers to respond to epidemics.
On April 13, 2021, T&V filed its claim against the HHS, seeking declaratory judgment. Their claim stated that the defendant’s orders were unconstitutional and violated the plaintiff’s procedural and substrative due process. The lower court granted HHS’, motion for summary judgment on
T&V’s claim under MCR 2.114(C)(8), which looked at the legal sufficiency of the complaint. The court stated the plaintiff failed to state a claim, the order was not unconstitutional, and it did not violate the plaintiff's due process.
On June 29, 2023, the Court of Appeals reversed the Court of Claims' decision. The appeals court examined the case's mootness, standing, the unconstitutional delegation of legislative power, and MCL 333.2253. The court determined the case was not moot as there was an actual controversy based on existing facts and rights. This was because the defendant limited the plaintiff's ability to operate its business; thus, the plaintiff was still affected by the defendant's actions. Additionally, although the defendant argued that there was no real controversy because the restrictions were no longer in effect, the judge contended that the plaintiff was an actual interested party and, therefore, had standing.
On the merits, the court sided with the plaintiff and found the executive branch’s exercise of power through the issuance of MCL 333.2253 under the EMA and EPGA was overwhelmingly broad. In
finding that MCL 333.2253 constituted an unconstitutional
delegation of legislative power to the executive branch, the court noted that the term “epidemic” was itself broad, and could apply to a wide range of threats.
The dissent, by Judge Yates, disagreed with the decision to reverse the Court of Claims’ holding. The Judge stated this case is “as moot as moot can be,” because HHS rescinded the Order and the T&V had closed its banquet facility. Therefore, T&V’s demand for declaratory relief is misplaced because they had ceased commercial operations and MCL 333.2253.