This newsletter is distributed by Public Health Law Watch as part of Act for Public Health, a working group of the Public Health Law Partnership that is convening to provide law and policy research, analysis, and expertise in support of public health authority.
This week's case updates:
Friday, 1/13: A New York judge struck the state’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate for healthcare workers.
Tuesday, 1/17: The Eleventh Circuit heard arguments in the government’s appeal of a Florida judge’s ruling striking the CDC’s transportation mask mandate.
Tuesday, 1/17: The Supreme Court will not hear a challenge to Chicago's COVID-19 vaccine mandate for city employees.
Wednesday, 1/18: Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders announced her official support for a state ban on mask mandates by public entities.
Join us next Thursday, Jan. 26, at 1pm ET for Act for Public Health's webinar, "Assessing Legislation and Litigation Impacting Public Health Authority."
Spotlight: Union lawsuits against city vaccine mandates
The Massachusetts Supreme Court heard oral arguments Friday, January 6th in Boston police and firefighter unions' lawsuit against the city of Boston for its COVID-19 vaccine mandate for city employees. A lower court blocked the mandate for union members last February, and the city appealed. The unions claim the city is not only violating their collective bargaining rights, but that the mandate will negatively affect already understaffed public agencies and current workers, causing irreparable harm.
Other unions around the country have brought similar suits, with varying results. Several courts have ruled in favor of union plaintiffs. In September 2022, a New York judge ruled that New York City’s vaccine mandate did not apply to police union members as it constituted “a new condition of employment.” In June 2022, a Minnesota judge ruled that St. Paul’s vaccine mandate constituted an unfair labor practice, as the city did not negotiate with union representatives before instating the mandate.
Not all unions have been successful, however. In February 2022, an arbitration panel ruled against a Philadelphia police union to uphold the city’s vaccine mandate. In June 2022, another arbitration panel ruled against a Philadelphia firefighter union, allowing the city to put on leave or fire employees who do not receive the vaccine.
In November 2022, an Illinois appeals court refused a police union’s request to invalidate an arbitration award in favor of Chicago that found the city could, within the collective bargaining agreement, unilaterally implement a vaccine mandate. The court stated that the unions “failed to identify a violation of a well-defined and dominant public policy requiring the invalidation of [the] arbitration award.” (Fraternal Order of Police, Chicago Lodge No. 7 v. Chicago, 2022 WL 16710025 (Nov. 4, 2022)).
According to the CDC, protection service employees, including police officers and firefighters, had the highest COVID-19 death rates in 2020.