This newsletter is distributed by Public Health Law Watch as part of Act for Public Health, a working group of the Public Health Law Partnership that is convening to provide law and policy research, analysis, and expertise in support of public health authority.
This week's case updates:
Friday, 1/27: The Texas Supreme Court agreed to consider challenges to Governor Abbott’s ban on mask mandates.
Monday, 1/30: New York parents sued the Riverhead Central School District in Long Island, New York, claiming the district’s mask requirements caused their children “emotional distress.”
Tuesday, 1/31: Unvaccinated Navy personnel claim they are still facing discrimination even after the military COVID-19 vaccine mandate was lifted. The Fifth Circuit will hear oral arguments Monday, 2/6.
Spotlight: Eleventh Circuit Hears Oral Arguments in the CDC Transportation Mask Mandate Case
On January 17, 2023, a panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit heard oral arguments in the CDC’s transportation mask mandate case, Health Freedom Defense Fund v. Biden. Judge Charles R. Wilson (appointed by President Clinton), Judge Adalberto Jordan (appointed by President Obama), and Judge Andrew L. Brasher (appointed by President Trump) questioned attorneys on both sides about the CDC’s mask mandate for airports, airplanes, and other transport issued in January 2021.
In April 2022, Florida federal district court Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle, issued a nationwide injunction against the mandate, finding the mandate exceeded CDC’s statutory authority. Also in April, another judge, Florida federal district court, Judge Paul G. Byron, ruled that CDC did have the authority to issue the mandate.
The judges questioned counsel on the CDC’s authority under Sec. 361 of the Public Health Services Act, and whether CDC violated the Administrative Procedure Act by not going through the rulemaking process before issuing the mandate.
The attorney representing the Health Freedom Defense Fund, one of the parties challenging the mandate, argued that adopting the CDC’s interpretation of the Public Health Services Act could give the agency the authority to issue a vaccine mandate.
Judge Jordan and Judge Wilson seemed to lean towards CDC’s interpretation of the statute, which would give the agency authority to issue the mask mandate. “If they [CDC] don’t have that authority, what authority do they have?” asked Judge Wilson. Judge Jordan questioned why the narrower definition of “sanitation” was the correct way of reading the Public Health Services Act, a key question in whether CDC is able to issue the mandate under the statute.
In terms of whether the CDC violated the Administrative Procedure Act by issuing the mandate via an emergency order, rather than a regulation, Judge Brasher called it a “slam dunk case” for plaintiffs. Judge Wilson didn’t seem as sure. Distinguishing the case from Alabama Ass’n of Realtors v. HHS, in which the Supreme Court struck the CDC’s eviction moratorium, Judge Wilson compared the “$50 to 80 million impact on landlords around the United States” with “require[ing] someone to wear a $2 mask.”
Public Health Law Watch submitted an amicus brief last year in support of the government.