|
This week’s newsletter discusses lawsuits related to physician speech, access to gender affirming care, and limits on grant terminations. You can find our archive newsletters here.
Physician’s Free Speech and Spreading Medical Misinformation
In Jensen v. Minnesota Board of Medical Practice (U.S. District Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit, Docket No. 25-1812; U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota, Docket No. 0:2023-cv-01689) the court reversed a lower court decision that dismissed claims of politically motivated investigations by the Minnesota Board of Medical Practice. Plaintiff, a physician and former state senator in Minnesota, alleged that during the COVID-19 pandemic he opposed vaccine mandates and closures of businesses and schools and that he was subsequently the target of multiple investigations from the Minnesota Board of Medical Practice. The complaint alleged that Plaintiff suffered injuries to his medical practice as well as lost time during his reelection campaign because of these investigations. He argued for relief based on First Amendment grounds. Specifically, Plaintiff argued that he had to self-censor his campaign messaging to avoid further scrutiny from the Board since each of the four separate investigations stemmed from complaints alleging that Plaintiff was spreading misinformation and endangering public health. One of these investigations lasted throughout the 2022 campaign. Plaintiff filed the initial complaint in June 2023 while Plaintiff was a candidate for governor in Minnesota and was dismissed in March 2024 for lack of standing. The district court determined that Plaintiff had not established a "chilling" effect on his speech stemming from the investigations.
Plaintiff appealed the dismissal on February 11, 2026, and the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals filed its decision on Sept. 15. 2026. The court held that Plaintiff did have standing to bring his claims, reversing the district court’s dismissal. The court noted the threat of continued investigations as having a chilling effect on Plaintiff’s political speech and that this constituted an ongoing injury for which injunctive relief was proper. However, the court did not decide the merits of the case and remanded the case back to the district court for further proceedings.
Gender Affirming Care Access in Prisons
In Trump v. Kingdom (U.S. Supreme Court, Docket No. 26A416; U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, Docket No. 1:25-cv-00691) the Supreme Court denied a request from the federal government to stay a lower court ruling that granted an injunction against a Bureau of Prisons (BOP) policy restricting gender affirming care in prisons. The initial complaint was filed on March 10, 2025 in the D.C. Circuit Court by three transgender prisoners in opposition to restrictions on treatment for gender dysphoria following Executive Order 14168, which defines sex as unchangeable and doesn’t recognize gender identity, and BOP’s February 2026 policy prohibiting hormone therapy and social transition accommodations, including clothing and grooming items consistent with a person’s gender identity. Plaintiffs allege that withdrawing medically necessary care would cause severe psychological distress and increase the risk of self-harm and suicide. They assert claims under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), the Fifth and Eighth Amendments, and the Rehabilitation Act.
On June 3, 2025, the district court certified a class encompassing current and future people in BOP custody diagnosed with gender dysphoria and granted a preliminary injunction. The preliminary injunction was renewed in August and November 2025 and a supplemental complaint was filed on April 27, 2026. On June 17, 2026, the district court filed an updated preliminary injunction order requiring BOP to continue providing care under its prior policies. The government sought a stay, which was denied by the D.C. circuit, and subsequently sought emergency relief at the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court denied that request, leaving the injunction in place without deciding the underlying merits. In the denial, the Court indicated Justices Thomas and Alito would have granted the stay.
Limits on Grant Terminations
State of New Jersey et al. v. Office of Management and Budget et al. (U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, Docket No. 1:25-cv-11816) involves twenty states, three governors, and the District of Columbia challenging the federal government’s use of a grant regulation to cancel previously awarded grants. The plaintiffs filed their complaint on June 24, 2025, and an amended complaint, which added several states as plaintiffs, on July 31, 2025. The regulation, 2 C.F.R. § 200.340(a)(4), allows an agency to terminate an award “if an award no longer effectuates the program goals or agency priorities.” After 2025 executive orders directed agencies to review and terminate grants that did not align with the administration’s policies, agencies cited this “Termination Clause” to end billions of dollars in grants to the Plaintiffs, often stating only that the funded activity no longer aligned with agency priorities.
The Plaintiffs are not seeking to restore grants already terminated. Instead, they are asking for declaratory relief limiting how agencies may use the Termination Clause going forward. On July 17, 2026, the District Court of Massachusetts granted summary judgment to the Plaintiffs, declaring that the regulation at issue does “not allow terminations of awards based on new program goals or agency priorities that an agency identifies after granting the award.” The court relied on the regulation’s text, the broader regulatory scheme requiring agencies to announce program goals and priorities before making awards, Office of Management and Budget’s rulemaking history, and the Constitution’s Spending Clause’s requirement that conditions on federal funds to states be unambiguous. The court emphasized that the administration remains free to set new priorities for new grants, so long as grantees know those priorities before the awards are made.
After the court entered final judgment on the Plaintiffs’ declaratory judgment claim on October 7, 2026, declaring that the regulation does not permit terminations based on priorities identified after an award, the Plaintiffs dismissed their remaining claims and the government appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit on October 22. On November 3, Judge Indira Talwani denied the government’s motion for a stay pending appeal. She explained that the judgment is limited to declaratory relief: it does not bar agencies from terminating grants for other lawful reasons, does not reinstate grants already terminated, and does not order the government to pay money.
The terminated grants include grants for public health and the arbitrary termination of that funding could affect states’ ability to combat infectious diseases, ensure immunizations, and bolster emergency preparedness.
|