|
Case updates this week:
Friday, October 6th: The First Circuit reversed a lower court’s denial of a preliminary injunction in Brox v. Woods Hole. The suit was brought by several employees of the Woods Hole, Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket Steamship Authority who claimed that the Authority’s failure to grant them religious exemptions to the Authority’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate and decision to place them on unpaid suspension violated the First Amendment. The First Circuit held that the district court incorrectly assessed the plaintiffs’ likelihood of success and also improperly relied on that flawed reasoning over the other relevant factors.
Tuesday October 10th: In Caspersen v. Western Union, the federal District Court of Colorado granted in part a motion to dismiss, while leaving an employee’s claim that Western Union violated his Title VII rights. The employee, Caspersen, alleged he was improperly placed on leave and subsequently fired after his religious exemption to the COVID-19 vaccine was denied. The court held that the plaintiff had pled sufficient facts to allow his claim regarding denial of reasonable accommodation to move forward, but dismissed his second claim for being functionally identical to the first claim.
Wednesday October 11th: The federal District Court for the Middle District of Florida allowed a case alleging Title VII violations to proceed in Ciavardone v. Raytheon Technologies. Plaintiff, Ciavardone, was provisionally granted a religious exemption to her employer, Raytheon’s, COVID-19 vaccine mandate, given that she masked and tested weekly. However, Ciavardone alleged that Raytheon denied her request to take saliva tests rather than nasal swabs, because they wanted to terminate her for her religious beliefs. The court held that Ciavardone had included adequate information in her suit to allow this claim to proceed, though an additional wrongful termination claim was dismissed.
|