Public Health Authority
Case Updates

November 3, 2023

Case updates this week:


Friday October 27th: The Supreme Court of Texas dismissed as moot two challenges to COVID-era anti-public health authority executive orders in State v. San Antonio Independent School District and Abbott v. City of El Paso. The litigation in San Antonio Independent School District arose when the local school district implemented a COVID-19 vaccine mandate for employees, despite the Texas governor’s executive order expressly banning such mandates. Abbott v. City of El Paso similarly involved a local government enforcing a COVID-19 mitigation measure (in this case a mask mandate) despite state government attempts to prevent it from doing so. In both cases, the governor’s executive order was issued under the Texas Disaster Act, and in both cases the Texas Court of Appeals held that the governor’s exercise of power was invalid. However, the Texas Supreme Court held that the cases were now moot because the challenged executive orders have been replaced by laws passed by the legislature. In addition to mooting the cases, the opinions siding with the municipalities from the Texas Court of Appeals were vacated.


Tuesday October 31st: A lawsuit was filed in the federal District Court for the Southern District of California challenging the state’s childhood vaccine mandate for not allowing religious exemptions. Royce v. Bonta was brought by Advocates for Faith & Freedom, an anti-vaccine advocacy group, alleging that the state’s law violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment because there are secular, but not religious, exceptions to the vaccine mandate. The complaint also argues that some other state-sponsored activities, like sports camps and public library programs, do not require proof of vaccination, and therefore the state already allows for contact between vaccinated and non-vaccinated and is irrationally singling out schools.

 
 
This newsletter is distributed by Public Health Law Watch as part of Act for Public Health, a working group of the Public Health Law Partnership that is convening to provide law and policy research, analysis, and expertise in support of public health authority.
The Public Health Law Partnership includes organizations with decades of experience in public health law, authority, and governance, including ChangeLab Solutions, the Network for Public Health Law, the Center for Public Health Law Research at Temple University, the Public Health Law Center at Mitchell Hamline School of Law, and Public Health Law Watch, a George Consortium initiative housed at the Center for Health Policy and Law at Northeastern University.
 
 
 
Twitter