Public Health Authority
Case Updates

November 10, 2023

Case updates this week:


Wednesday November 1st: An anti-vaccine lobbying group filed suit in the federal District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania challenging Philadelphia’s policy of allowing some minors to consent to vaccination without parental approval in Children’s Health Defense v. City of Philadelphia. The policy, first enacted in 2007 by the Philadelphia Department of Public Health, allows minors aged eleven and older to receive vaccinations after being provided with an information sheet on the vaccine, with or without parental approval. The suit alleges that this policy does not adequately ensure informed consent. The suit also alleges that the policy violates the First Amendment’s guarantee of Freedom of Religion and the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause by infringing on the parental rights regarding the vaccinated children.

 

Friday November 3rd: The federal District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed a suit by an employee who was fired for not receiving the COVID-19 vaccine after her religious exemption was denied in Bobadilla v. New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation. Bobadilla claimed that by firing her after declining to accommodate her religious beliefs by letting her work remotely, the hospital violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act as well as other Constitutional provisions, including the Free Exercise Clause and the Due Process Clause. The court held that the hospital did not violate Title VII because no reasonable accommodation would permit Bobadilla to perform the essential functions of her job and granting Bobadilla a religious exemption would have violated New York’s vaccination mandate for health care workers, causing the employer undue hardship. Additionally, the hospital’s vaccine mandate was generally applicable, regardless of religion, served a compelling purpose, and therefore did not violate the Free Exercise Clause. Finally, the vaccine policy and religious exemption process were clearly communicated to Bobadilla, eliminating the Due Process claim.

 

Monday November 6th: In Snyder v. Chicago Transit Authority, the federal District Court for the Northern District of Illinois granted in part a motion to dismiss in a vaccine religious exemption case. Snyder, an employee of the Chicago Transit Authority, refused to comply with the Authority’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate, and was terminated after his religious exemption was denied. After he was fired, he sued, alleging that the Transit Authority violated Title VII, the Due Process Clause, the Illinois equivalent to the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA), and various other state and federal statutes. The court dismissed most of these claims, but allowed the Title VII and Illinois RFRA claims to proceed, holding that Snyder had informed the Transit Authority of his religious objection to the vaccine and the Transit Authority fired Snyder for violating their vaccine requirement, which was sufficient to state a claim for relief.

 
 
This newsletter is distributed by Public Health Law Watch as part of Act for Public Health, a working group of the Public Health Law Partnership that is convening to provide law and policy research, analysis, and expertise in support of public health authority.
The Public Health Law Partnership includes organizations with decades of experience in public health law, authority, and governance, including ChangeLab Solutions, the Network for Public Health Law, the Center for Public Health Law Research at Temple University, the Public Health Law Center at Mitchell Hamline School of Law, and Public Health Law Watch, a George Consortium initiative housed at the Center for Health Policy and Law at Northeastern University.
 
 
 
Twitter