|
Case updates this week:
Monday November 13th: The United States Supreme Court declined to review a New Jersey COVID-19 booster shot state mandate for health care workers in Sczesny v. Murphy. In dismissing the appeal, the Court let stand the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeal’s finding that the appeal was moot, as the state mandate was rescinded before the matter was resolved. The case was appealed from a decision by the federal District Court for the District of New Jersey, which denied four nurses’ application for a preliminary injunction alleging that the mandate violated their fundamental right to bodily integrity. The District Court held that the plaintiffs had not demonstrated a likelihood of success on the merits, citing Jacobson, as well as the history of judicial support for similar mandates for healthcare workers.
Monday November 13th: The U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal of a proposed class action by teachers who were fired for refusing to receive the COVID-19 vaccine. In Broecker v. New York City Department of Education, the plaintiff teachers claimed the New York City Department of Education violated their due process rights when it suspended and fired them for not complying with their vaccine mandate. However, the federal District Court for the Eastern District of New York held that the Department of Education’s process was sufficient. The teachers had the opportunity to seek vaccine exemptions before they were fired. They also had the opportunity to contest their firing through arbitration, and New York law provides state courts review of state executive action.
Tuesday November 14th: New York’s First Department Appellate Division upheld a decision by the New York County Supreme Court dismissing the petition of a teacher who alleged religious discrimination after she was fired for not receiving the COVID-19 vaccine. In Lynch v. Board of Education of the City School District of the City of New York, the First Department affirmed that the City of New York Reasonable Accommodation Appeals Panel that denied the plaintiff a religious accommodation did not act arbitrarily or capriciously because there was enough evidence to show that either masking, testing, and social distancing or teaching remotely would impose an undue hardship on the Department of Education.
We wish you a Happy Thanksgiving. The PHLW Newsletter will be taking a break for the holiday, and the next Litigation Update will be in your inbox 12/1.
|