Statement On Oakland Losing The A's From Former Councilmember Loren Taylor

As a kid who grew up rooting for Oakland's hometown baseball team from the bleachers with my grandparents, I'm now forced to accept that I will never share that same Oakland experience with my own grandkids. The pending departure of the A's is a major loss for current and future Oaklanders.


Some will trivialize the departure of the A’s by saying that “baseball is just a game,” while others will focus on this as the inevitable outcome of billionaire greed and capitalist deal-making, and others still will emphasize the lack of political will or business savvy by government leaders. There is truth in all of those statements… but what this situation most represents to me is yet another squandered opportunity to deliver on the promise and potential of Oakland.  


Sure there is plenty of blame to go around - the majority of which rests squarely on Oakland A’s ownership and their lack of commitment to a true win-win solution. But we knew they were never loyal to Oakland despite their "Rooted in Oakland" slogan. And we knew the chances of pulling off a successful win-win deal were shrinking with increasing interest rates and construction costs. And we also knew that the passive, passenger-seat approach of Oakland’s elected leaders over the past 4 months all but assured this outcome. But the reality and finality of Wednesday's announcement still hurt. 


The grieving process is real and shouldn’t be underestimated because this is about more than just a game. It is about a longstanding relationship that has been nurtured for over 50 years but was prematurely and unilaterally terminated by the A's. It not only hurts those of us who are longtime Oaklanders but also many others whose bonds with the team were formed more recently. We will each process this loss in our own way, and we will all eventually arrive at the same “acceptance and hope” stage of our grief. When ready, we will begin figuring out how we turn our lemons into lemonade and work toward a thriving future for Oakland without a major league sports team.


But moving forward requires more than the empty promise of “something better” made by Mayor Thao and other city leaders in response to Wednesday's announcement by the Oakland A’s. Instead, it requires:

  • An honest assessment of our strengths and weaknesses
  • A vision for where Oakland could go that is unconstrained by where we have been
  • A balanced focus on both long-term and immediate benefits to Oakland residents and businesses
  • Value-centered leadership that taps into the individual and collective expertise of Oakland’s diverse stakeholder groups
  • An unwavering commitment to efficiently and effectively implement transformational solutions


I know that Oakland’s potential remains strong despite this most recent setback, but politics and business as usual will continue to limit our progress if we don’t do things differently. Moving forward, I stand ready to collaborate in new ways across traditional lines of division to realize the amazing potential of Oakland. And I look to others to do the same because that is what it will take and what Oakland deserves.

Loren Taylor - Website

Facebook  Twitter  Instagram