Volume 15, Issue 10

October 2026

 

Fifth Circuit Rules Constitution Does Not Guarantee Right to Clean Drinking Water or Accurate Information from Public Officials

By Scott D. Wilson



The U.S. Constitution does not guarantee a right to clean drinking water or a right to receive accurate information from public officials, a divided U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has ruled.


The decision affirms the dismissal of a lawsuit brought by Jackson, Mississippi, residents who alleged they were harmed by lead-contaminated drinking water. Sitting en banc, the Fifth Circuit concluded that the plaintiffs' claims rested on substantive due process rights not recognized by the Constitution.


Writing for the majority, Judge Kurt Engelhardt stated that neither the Constitution's text nor the nation's history supports the recognition of such rights under the Due Process Clause. "The Constitution does not provide redress for every governmental wrongdoing," Engelhardt wrote.


Counsel for the residents did not immediately respond to requests for comment.


Clarence Webster III, a partner at Jones Walker who represented the City of Jackson, described the ruling as "one of the most significant constitutional decisions the Fifth Circuit will issue this year."


"We are pleased that the en banc court affirmed the City's position and provided important guidance regarding the limits of constitutional liability," Webster said in a statement.


The majority emphasized that residents retain alternative avenues of relief, including pursuing tort claims, electing officials committed to improving water system management, and advocating for legislative solutions.


The plaintiffs alleged that city officials knowingly permitted lead contamination in Jackson's water supply, resulting in injuries to residents who consumed the water. The city has consistently denied those allegations.


In 2025, a divided Fifth Circuit panel revived the residents' claim, concluding that they had plausibly alleged a violation of their right to bodily autonomy. That decision was later vacated when the full court agreed to rehear the case.


Engelhardt acknowledged the plaintiffs' reliance on a constitutional right to bodily integrity but distinguished the circumstances from cases involving direct physical intrusions by government officials, such as sexual assault by law enforcement officers or the involuntary administration of medication to prisoners. The alleged mismanagement of a municipal water system, he wrote, is "wholly different."


The majority further rejected the plaintiffs' argument that public officials violated a constitutional right to accurate information. Although Supreme Court precedent recognizes certain due process rights grounded in the common-law doctrine of informed consent, Engelhardt concluded that those cases do not establish a general right to truthful information from government officials.


The court also held that, even if a constitutional violation had been sufficiently alleged, the defendant officials would be entitled to qualified immunity because no clearly established constitutional right was implicated.


Engelhardt's opinion was joined by nine additional judges.


Judge Catharina Haynes authored a separate opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part, joined by four judges. Haynes argued that, at the pleading stage, the court was required to accept the plaintiffs' factual allegations as true and should have permitted discovery to proceed.


"At bottom, the well-pleaded factual allegations in Plaintiffs' complaint, which we must accept as true, mirror in various ways one of the worst public health crises in recent American history — the Flint water crisis," Haynes wrote.


Haynes further contended that the plaintiffs adequately alleged a state-created danger claim, an issue she said the majority failed to address. Noting that other federal courts have recognized the doctrine, she criticized the Fifth Circuit for remaining "practically alone" in declining either to adopt or definitively reject it.


In her view, the state-created danger doctrine should be recognized, and the plaintiffs had plausibly alleged a violation of their constitutional right to bodily integrity.

 

Cornell Fraternity Sexual Assault: When Complaints Resurface

By Rachael Jeanfreau and Kenneth Nilsson


Recent headlines surrounding New York State prosecutors’ decision to reopen a criminal investigation into fraternity sexual assault allegations at Cornell University serve as a stark warning to institutions and businesses alike. In 2024, a then-student reported to the university that she had been sexually assaulted at a fraternity house after ingesting alcohol and drugs. While Cornell has stated that it previously investigated the allegations and took appropriate remedial action in response to the complaint, the story has recently returned to the news, including allegations that Cornell mishandled the university’s internal investigation and failed to properly discipline the alleged assailants. Although university Title IX proceedings such as these involve students rather than corporate employees, the public fallout demonstrates the importance of properly investigating and handling all allegations of harassment, including allegations of sexual harassment and abuse. Not surprisingly, such allegations can resurface years later – particularly when accompanied by claims that the initial investigation was incomplete or poorly handled – potentially causing severe legal, financial, and reputational fallout. As detailed in last month’s article, The Complaint Isn't Always the Problem: How Employers Can Avoid Creating Liability after an Employee Complains, how leadership responds to an initial grievance often dictates the organization’s ultimate legal exposure.


This reality was recently on display in the employment context by Beran v. VSL North Platte Court LLC, where a federal court upheld a $3 million verdict against an employer after supervisors dismissed an employee’s harassment reports as “workplace stress” instead of conducting a meaningful investigation. To actively prevent and defend against liability, employers should (1) recognize and respond to complaints including informal or verbal complaints, (2) conduct prompt, thorough, and neutral investigations, and (3) enforce appropriate corrective measures that genuinely remedy verified misconduct. Involving labor and employment counsel at the beginning of such process ensures that the investigative process remains objective, compliant, and defensible from day one.

 

Another Circuit Court Holds That Harassment Allegations Can Pull an Entire Case Out of Arbitration

By Philip Giorlando


On September 30, 2026, the federal appellate court out of New York held that the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (EFAA) allows a plaintiff to invalidate a pre-dispute arbitration agreement as to the entire lawsuit, not just the sexual harassment claims within it. This decision joins recent decisions by the federal appellate courts out of California and Ohio, but there is no nationwide consensus on whether EFAA should apply to the entire suit or just the sexual harassment claims. In the case, the plaintiff, a fired executive, alleged sexual harassment along with tort claims tied to her stock options. The court concluded that the statute's reference to a "case" relating to a sexual harassment dispute covers the lawsuit as a whole.


The court did not resolve another unanswered question, namely, what a plaintiff must plead to allow the plaintiff to send the case to arbitration. Two different schools of thought exist: some courts require only nonfrivolous allegations of sexual harassment, while other district courts in the circuit require plausible claims capable of surviving a motion to dismiss. That standard may ultimately determine how easily a plaintiff can use the federal to move an entire arbitration dispute into court.


Arbitration agreements can remain a very valuable resource for employers to help reduce the potential cost of litigation and exposure in court. If a complaint includes a sexual harassment allegation, employers should expect additional litigation over whether related wage, contract, retaliation, and tort claims should remain in court as well. Employers should closely scrutinize the factual sufficiency of the harassment allegations before conceding that the claims should leave arbitration and be heard in court. Clear anti-harassment policies, accessible complaint procedures, and prompt investigations remain the best way to reduce both the risk of a claim and its leverage.

 

Upcoming Seminars

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Labor & Employment Attorneys

Murphy J. Foster, III

Murphy.Foster@bswllp.com

(225) 381-8015

Philip Giorlando

Philip.Giorlando@bswllp.com

(504) 680-5244

Alexandra Cobb Hains

Alex.Hains@bswllp.com

(225) 381-3175

Kayla M. Jacob

Kayla.Jacob@bswllp.com

(504) 584-5451

Rachael Jeanfreau

Rachael.Jeanfreau@bswllp.com

(504) 584-5467

Alyse Richard Latiolais

Alyse.Latiolais@bswllp.com

(225) 381-8021

Eve B. Masinter

Eve.Masinter@bswllp.com

(504) 584-5468

Kenneth J. Nilsson

Kenneth.Nilsson@bswllp.com

(504) 584-5442

E. Fredrick Preis, Jr.

Fred.Preis@bswllp.com

(504) 584-5470

Melissa M. Shirley

Melissa.Shirley@bswllp.com

(225) 381-3173

Scott D. Wilson

Scott.Wilson@bswllp.com

(225) 381-8005

 
LinkedIn  Instagram  Facebook  X  Web