SHARE:  
Runkle Consulting Inc.
The Castle
March 20, 2013
Container Lift
Greetings!

Many of us are finally seeing improvement from the many years that we struggled through the Great Recession.  I don't know about you, but it's changed the way I look at the world now.  I'm much more thrifty than I ever was, and I have a lot more sympathy for people less fortunate than myself.. 
.
As this year begins we are actively working on projects in Canada, Africa, and Saudi Arabia.  We've added an engineer, Minfei Yang, who is currently a graduate student at Columbia University in New York.  Ms. Yang has a Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering from the University of Melbourne in Australia and is expecting to graduate with an MS in Civil Engineering from Columbia University this Spring.  She has previously worked as a field inspector in Nanjing, China and as a research assistant at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.  
 
I personally am continuing my graduate studies at Columbia, and I hope to have my MS sometime next year.  This semester I am taking Wind and Earthquake Engineering, and Uncertainty and Risk in Infrastructure Systems.  

With all the exotic locales we're working in, we're actually putting a full push on our Forensic Engineering here in the US - in Georgia specifically, concentrating on damage to residential structures.  We're gearing our website to this type of work, and we've been able to double it in the past few months.  The intent is to develop a mix of work so we aren't dependent on any one thing.  

In this newsletter I'm going to cover some mundane topics that I hope will be of some interest to you.  The first article will be more of what I've been learning about travel, and the second is going to cover the lifetime you can expect for your house.  I hope you enjoy this issue, and I look forward to working with you this year..

 

George   

 

George W. Runkle  III,  P.E., PEng

Runkle Consulting Inc.

678-225-4900

 

Avoiding the Agony of Air Travel

 

In the past few months I have been traveling a lot between here in Lawrenceville, GA and the Northeast US.  As this travel started a few years ago, I tried driving.  Flying is fairly expensive, and a car trip was only about $120 or so in gas.  However, it's 10 to 12 hours of driving to get to the Washington, DC metropolitan area, and that's if you don't stop.  Figuring you have to eat, and sometimes rest, it can take 14 hours or so.  This swallows a day, and for me, I am worn out the next day.  At the very best, you lose two days by doing this drive, and counting lost productivity due to being tired, it's three or four days lost.  So, it didn't really save me anything from flying.

 

So, the alternative seemed to be flying.  However, here in Atlanta you need to get to the gate a half hour before your flight is scheduled to leave.  Airlines have improved their "on-time" performance by adjusting their flight time from when boarding stops to being a half hour after boarding stops.  It can take an hour or more to get through security depending on the crowd, and there of course is the shoeless shuffle while holding your pants up because you also have to take off your belt, and somehow you have to get your laptop in a bin all by itself.  Oh, and think about this - when you are standing in the scanner, somebody in another room is looking at you naked.  

TSA Scanning
This rates a 9 on the Fun Meter

 

In addition to the agony in the airport, there is the trip to get there.  One trip I allowed an hour and a half to get to the airport, but there were no less than three accidents on the way.  It took two and a half hours, and I missed my flight.

 

So, looking for an alternative, I examined taking the train.  Amtrak has a station in Atlanta that is poorly located with no good long term parking, but go about 30 miles northeast of the city to Gainesville, and there is a station with free parking across the street.  It's not hard to get to for me, and there are no security lines or other airport hassles.  The train leaves at 9 PM and arrives in the DC area late the next morning.  It gets to New York about 2 PM.  While you do spend the night on the train, you lose about the same portion of the day as you would if you flew.  

 

The cost is less than gasoline for driving, and it is possible to be productive during the train trip.  For most of the trip cell phone access is good, and so is Internet access if your phone can work as a hotspot.  The Cafe Car has large tables that allow you to layout your work very easily.  

Dining Car
Amtrak Dining Car - you have to admit, this is a much more civilized way to travel than flying or driving.

For personal travel, I would consider the train for traveling with elderly people, since security lines are difficult for them.  It also may be easier for traveling with children for the same reason, however it depends on the child.  Not all children can take being on a train for 12 to 14 hours, although most of the ones I've seen travel take it well since they have a lot to see and can get up and walk around if they need to.

 

So, as an alternative to driving or flying, you may want to consider the train.

 

  

How Long Will Your House Last?

 

As I visit various people and examine their homes, I am surprised by how many don't realize that their home has a finite life.  Like people, houses only last so long.  At some point in time, someone will make a decision to tear down the house you live in today.  How long will your house last, and what determines it's life?

 

A house an be compared to a person in its lifetime.  There are common factors that determine how long it lasts:

1.  How well it is built - like your heredity.  If you are lucky to be born with a strong heart and so on, you will live longer.  If your house is well built, it will last longer.

2.  How well is it treated - like you, if the house is abused during its life, it will not last too long.  If you smoke, drink excessively, do drugs, and eat too much, your life is going to be rather short.  If a house is allowed to get infested with termites, the roof is allowed to leak, and the gutters not maintained, a lot of structural damage will happen over time.

3.  What happens to it.  If you get hit by a car, it can end your life suddenly.  Likewise, if your house gets hit by a tornado, or a tree falls on it, that could be it no matter how well it was built or how well it was maintained.

 

In general though, it is my observation that house will last 50 to 60 years.  At that point the wood is losing strength, the floors are sagging, and the different bits of abuse and poor maintenance are adding up.  Furthermore, houses are built in styles to match the way people live.  A 50 year old house probably isn't generally suitable for what people want today.  The space layout is totally different and doesn't work with how we live in our current culture.  So, in many cases we see the older homes become "tear downs" if the neighborhood is desirable.  

 

Here is what I've seen for lifespan for different components of the house:

 

1.  Foundations:  If the foundation is on good soil  and drainage is maintained, the foundation has an almost indefinite lifespan.  When archaeologists dig up old villages, they find the foundations pretty much in the same condition as when the buildings were built hundreds to thousands of years ago.

 

2.  Wood framing - If termites get to wood, that's it.  However, if you keep the termites away, the wood framing loses strength in about 50 years as it dries out.  Floors start to sag and creak.  By 100 years, you need to do major reinforcement, so I give this part of the house a 75 to 100 year life span.  However, many of the houses around Atlanta built in the 70's and 80's don't have moisture barriers behind the veneer.  In these houses, the wood framing is already beyond hope due to rot.

 

3.  Brick veneer -  brick can last a long time.  I had the fortune of seeing the Roman Coliseum a couple of years ago, and it is made from brick.  I was amazed.  It's lasted 2000 years for the most part, which is good considering it made it through barbarian invasions, the Dark Ages, scavengers, and two World Wars.  However, you won't be so fortunate.  In older houses the mortar was mixed by hand, and homebuilders weren't any better back then in spite of the belief that "they don't make things like they used to".  In older homes the brick mortar is failing, and you can figure on about a 60 to 75 year lifespan for many brick veneers.  The mortar is still in good shape at the Coliseum, which says a lot about the Romans.

 

4.  Heating and Air Conditioning Systems - you will be lucky to get 10 to 15 years out of your system.  I know older homes have ancient furnaces and so on, but they require a lot of repair work, and will cost you more in lost energy due to their inefficiency than if you replaced them.  The mechanical parts just wear out.

 

5.  Electric - other than the old knob and tube electric, the lifespan is theoretically indefinite.  You have minimal corrosion worries, and there are no moving parts. You can have rodent damage, and damage from DIY projects, but that's it. However, power needs change over time.  Houses built in the 50's rarely had air conditioning, and you didn't have 3 or 4 TV's and computers either.  So, older electrical systems always need an upgrade.  Figure 30 to 40 years.

 

6.  Plumbing - in older homes you don't have mixing faucets.  The seats of the valves wear out.  Leaks develop in the joints.  Stuff builds up in the pipes.  Toilets in houses built in the 50's are at child height and don't work too well for us older fatter people of today.  Your plumbing fixtures have a 15 to 20 year lifespan.  The pipes can last 75 to 100 years from what I've seen.  The PVC pipes we use now may have an indefinite life depending on how they were put in.

 

7.  Concrete - while I was in Rome, I had the good fortune to visit the Pantheon.  It has concrete dome that is in amazing shape. No cracks, no cold joints, and no spalling after 2000 years.  I would love to know how the Romans mixed concrete so good, and managed to pour such a structure using pretty much hand tools.  You will not be so lucky.  Exterior concrete has a lifespan of 20 to 40 years.  If you have a concrete driveway, you probably will have to replace it at 30 years of age. 

 

Pantheon
The Pantheon, that dome is concrete poured over 2000 years ago - your concrete driveway will NOT look this good 2000 years from now. The Romans didn't build it, which is your loss.

 The problem is the quality control of residential concrete.  It's never cured correctly, there is almost never the proper additives placed in it, and the contractors never pay attention to batch-to-placement time.  Further, if the mix is a bit stiff, the contractors just add some water to it.  The result is a concrete driveway, patio, or basement slab that cracks up after a few years.  The Romans avoided this problem by feeding people to lions in the Coliseum if they didn't do the work right, today we don't have that leverage.  

 

8. Roofs:  Your roof shingles will last 10 to 15 years.  I know you can buy "20 year" shingles, but the warranties are for the material only, and are pro-rated.  So, when your roof needs replacement in 15 years, if you kept receipts, you might get a few hundred dollars off replacing it.  If you let your roof leak, the water damage will affect your wood structure, your finishes, and your heating and ac equipment, hastening the end of your house.  Don't let that happen.

 

9.  Windows:  The glazing dries out, the frames shrink, moisture gets in the insulated panes.  The lifespan of your windows is about 20 to 30 years.  You can find old houses with the original windows, but they are drafty, and the windows don't open and close like they should.

 

That is a fairly good summary of what I've seen in examining about 2000 houses.  When you buy a house, you need to take the life of the different parts under consideration, because you might be buying into an expensive proposition that you haven't budgeted for.  Also, you have build in your budget the different things you have to do to maintain and repair the house you have. 

 

About Runkle Consulting Inc.
Runkle Consulting Inc. is a structural engineering firm that specializes in buildings made from recycled shipping containers, modular construction, and structural design for architectural metal products.

Runkle Consulting Inc.
930 New Hope Road, Suite #11-145
Lawrenceville, GA 30045
USA
1-678-225-4900 (US/Canada)

www.runkleconsulting.com
Find us on Facebook
In This Issue
Avoiding the Agony of Air Travel
How Long Will Your House Last?
Forward to a Friend
Visit Our Website