E~Credit News & Updates

March 2024

The Lurking Danger of Artificial Intelligence: Greater Preference Exposure


By: Joseph Frank & Jeremy Kleinman, FrankGecker LLP

Recent growth in the use of artificial intelligence (“AI”) is changing business processes at a rapid pace, and the management of credit relationships is not immune from this influence. Indeed, AI can use machine learning and predictive analytics to better identify customers at risk of non-payment and to communicate effectively with those customers to optimize collection. Used correctly, these tools can be a valuable part of credit management and may enhance the ability to get payments in the door. But if the customer making those payments is insolvent and ends up in bankruptcy, the use of AI may impact a creditor’s ability to keep those payments and create exposure to preference liability under section 547(b) of the United States Bankruptcy Code (11 U.S.C. §§ 101 et seq., hereinafter, the “Bankruptcy Code”).

 

Preferential Transfers and Defenses

We begin with a quick primer on preference liability under section 547(b). Subject to a few enumerated affirmative defenses, a debtor or trustee in bankruptcy may generally avoid and recover as “preferential” a transfer of an insolvent debtor’s property (over a threshold amount) made on account of an unsecured antecedent debt within the 90 days prior to bankruptcy. 

 

While this definition of “preferential transfer” seems to capture virtually every payment made by a debtor to its unsecured creditors during the 90 days before its bankruptcy filing, section 547(c) of the Bankruptcy Code provides affirmative defenses that can shield a creditor from liability. The two most commonly used defenses are:

 

(i)   the “subsequent new value” defense under section 547(c)(4), providing a dollar-for-dollar reduction of preference liability for additional unpaid goods or services provided after payment of one or more of the alleged preferential transfers; and

 

(ii)  the ordinary course of business defense under section 547(c)(2), protecting payments made consistent with either the prior history of the parties’ credit practices, or the “ordinary business terms” of the creditor’s industry. These alternative criteria are presented disjunctively in section 547(c)(2). However, some courts have suggested that intensified collection efforts could invalidate a defense under both alternative prongs of section 547(c)(2). See In re: Lyondell Chemical Company, 2015 WL 5560283, at *9 (Bkrtcy.S.D.N.Y., 2015) (“the Court notes that there is nothing in the record indicating that LR2 took any ‘extraordinary collection efforts’ that could jeopardize the . . . satisfaction of the elements of the ordinary business terms defense). Furthermore, to prevail on an ordinary course of business defense based on ordinary business terms, a creditor “must provide admissible non-hearsay testimony related to industry credit payment, and general business terms in order to support its position.” FBI Wind Down, Inc. Liquidating Tr. v. CareersUSA, Inc. (In re FBI Wind Down, Inc.), 614 B.R. 460, 495 (Bankr. D. Del. 2020). Where a defendant presents only its own practices without any general industry standards for comparison, it has not met its burden. Id.

To Continue Reading

Laura Clemons has earned the professional designations of Certified Credit Professional (CCP) and Certified Professional Collector (CPC). Ms. Clemons has experience in accounting and office management auditing, in addition to credit & Collection. Laura has completed the 32 credit and collection course. Ms. Clemon has 15+ years in Credit & Collections. Congratulations Laura!

American Society

Credit and Collection Professionals 

Why should business credit and collection professionals apply for Credentialing Standards Board (CSB) accreditation as soon as the opportunity is available? By having accreditation in place, Certificate holders can more easily respond to business and employment opportunities available. Certified professionals always earn more and are better positioned for advancement.


Here are the usual steps leading to CSB certification:


One way the American Society of Credit and Collection Professionals (ASCCP) serves the credit and collection profession is through the administration of an accreditation program through the CSB. The first step toward CSB accreditation is to complete an application for a Council Record. The CSB verifies and maintains a record of an applicant's education, training, examination, registration, and character. When his or her Council Record has been completed, the CSB will examine the applicant's qualifications and determine the applicant's eligibility for certification. If CSB requirements are met, an eligibility certificate will be issued.


As long as an eligibility certificate is active, the local jurisdiction office will, upon application by the eligible certificate holder, transmit a copy of the individual's Certificate Record to the CSB. The Certificate Record is the individual's Council Record together with the local jurisdictions certification that the individual has complied with the Council's standards of eligibility for certification and the a recommendation that the individual be registered as a Certified Credit Professional (CCP), Certified Professional Collector (CPC).


With this certification, registration may be obtained from CSB without further examination and without the certificate holder being required to make a personal appearance. CSB may require that the certificate holder's qualifications be supplemented by a personal interview and/or by additional examination.

To Learn More or Apply

Comprehensive Credit Professional’s Training Series


In collaboration with the American Society of Credit & Collection Professionals, this series of courses was developed to provide comprehensive training for individuals in credit and collection in order to prepare them for their role in this ever-changing field.


You may apply for the Certified Professional Collector (CPC) and Certified Credit Professional (CCP) after 5 years on-the-job experience. However, by successfully completing the CPC and CCP Modules and passing all the exams, you will be eligible to apply for the Certification(s). If you are approved by the CSB Board and work one year in business credit and/or collection you, will be recognized as a Certified Credit Professional and/or a Certified Professional Collector.


This series will help those who aspire to become Certified and also those who wish to use these courses to learn techniques that will improve their job skills immediately!


You can apply for the Credentialing Standards Board (CSB) Accreditation without taking the course.

To Learn More

Upcoming Webinars

APRIL 17

Collection Principles, Why

We Continue To Have Debtors

 

MAY 15

Smart Credit Policies That Improve Collections

 

JUNE 19

Rolling Out A Credit Card Surcharge - Hot Topics & Best Practices

 

JULY 17

Overridden Credit Decisions

 

AUGUST 21

Legal Aspects Of Credit And Collections

 

SEPTEMBER 11

Acquired, Sold, Merged, Or Goes Bankrupt - What To Do

 

OCTOBER 16

Effective Collections, The Art Of Getting Paid

 

NOVEMBER 20

How To Set Customer Credit Limits Correctly

 

DECEMBER 18

Emerging Challenges In Credit And Collections

**NEW in 2024** Webinars On-Demand

**NEW in 2024** Webinars On-Demand


We have 27 pre-recorded educational webinars on these subject matters:


  • Credit Department Management 
  • B2B Debt Collection Best Practices
  • Financial Statement Analysis
  • Credit Risk Management
  • Negotiation and Conflict Resolution
  • Legal Aspects for B2B Creditors


For more information and to register, click here.


To register for our Educational Opportunities, complete the registration form or email Nicole Thompson at nicolet@wcacredit.org


Opportunities abound for you and your staff to take advantage of scholarship grant dollars available to eligible members! The application and guidelines are available for download below.


WCA Education Scholarship Application


WCA Education Scholarship Fund Guidelines


WCA Education Awards Committee Rules & Guidelines

GLOBAL ECONMIC OVERVIEW

March 21, 2024

11:00 AM - 12:30 PM CT

 

Live Webinar - 90 minutes 

Please join ICE for a virtual program with Byron Shoulton for a Global Economic review that is a must for credit managers and your international trade team. He will focus on the recent developments in Mexico, Argentina, and Brazil and will discuss the economic causes of the migrant crisis and how they impact trade relations. 


Byron Shoulton is FCIA's Senior Global Trade & Political Risk International Economist and is the author of the monthly article Major Country Risk Development for FCIA Trade Credit & Political Risk.


ICE is thrilled to partner with Byron Shoulton and excited for him to share his business and economic insights. The takeaways from this webinar will empower you to make informed decisions about the future of your business. 


Click HERE to register.
business_people3.jpg

March 8, 2024

Electrical Suppliers Industry Credit Group

Brookfield, WI 

March 11, 2024

Metals & Industrial Suppliers Credit Group

Book Of Reports

March 12, 2024

Fine Paper/Graphic Arts Industry Credit Group

Book of Reports

March 13, 2024

Plumbing & Heating Industry Credit Group

Teleconference Call



Regional Paper & Packaging Industry Credit Group

Teleconference Call

March 15, 2024

IL Fine Paper Industry Credit Group

Teleconference Call

UPCOMING INDUSTRY CREDIT GROUP MEETINGS

March 18, 2024

Western Electrical Suppliers Industry Credit Group

Book of Reports

March 19, 2024

Minnesota Fine Paper Credit Group

Teleconference Call

March 20, 2024

MN Electrical Suppliers Credit Group

 Coon Rapids, MN



Building & Construction Materials Credit Group

Milwaukee, WI


Construction Industries Credit Group

Appleton, WI


Food Service Supply Hospitality Industry Credit Group

TBD

Credit Professional Alliance

Credit Management Association 

The Business Credit Management Association Wisconsin

Business Credit Intelligence

Mountain States Commercial

NACS Credit Services, Inc.

Facebook  X  LinkedIn