BOOKS
What’s Our Problem? by Tim Urban: What’s Our Problem? builds on the work Tim Urban, creator of the uber-popular blog Wait But Why, began six years ago. His purpose was to find out why political discourse had turned into a cesspool of negativity. His book is good, many feel very good, but it could have been great. Let me explain why.
Urban believes the problem is less about what people believe, but rather, how they think, the level of civil disagreement they’re willing to engage in, and the degree they attempt to silence those they disagree with. He deems those open-minded and willing to listen and learn as “high-rung” thinkers. On the other hand, individuals entrenched in echo chambers, who demonize others with different worldviews as “low-rung” thinkers. This first section of the book is funny, wise, and insightful.
The second half dissects the history and present of the right and left sides of the political spectrum. It’s well-researched and I learned a lot. For example, I had no idea the Democrats won the House of Representatives (elected every two years) 13 times straight. The consequence of two-and-a-half decades of Republican losses was a hard pivot to negative, cut-throat politics (under Newt Gingrich). Urban asserts that this, and the abolishing of the Fairness Doctrine in 1987, began the slide into the toxicity we see today. (The Fairness Doctrine required news broadcasters to present opposing perspectives of a controversial issue that was in the public interest.)
Following his critique of the political right, Urban shifts to the other side of the political spectrum. As a left-leaning classical Liberal, Urban highly values freedom of expression in most situations. While he fully embraces the principles of social justice, he is very concerned with the punitive and anti-liberal principles the far left currently enforces in universities and other organizations. This part of the book is thorough and well-researched. But, perhaps, too thorough. In illustrating so many examples and studies, this section feels bloated and never-ending. Possibly to the point of turning off the moderates Urban worked so hard to reach.
I still feel this is an important book. And people interested in how we got here should read it. But do so knowing that one section, in an attempt to make its argument rock-solid, is over-litigated – to a fault.
|