LAWYERS' PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY RESULTS | |
|
Jack Slimm (Mount Laurel, NJ) obtained an order from the Superior Court in Burlington County, New Jersey, on the eve of trial granting our motion to dismiss in a multiparty, complex legal malpractice action. This suit was filed against a court-appointed administrator of an estate, the sellers of the property, the beneficiaries of the estate, and the estate itself. The case involved two actions in the Chancery Division, two actions in the Law Division, and an appeal arising out of the same, all involving claims for breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, negligence and legal malpractice against the administrator. The case was filed because the property was contaminated. It was alleged the estate and the administrator knew or should have known about the unlawful dumping but ignored those activities, allowed the property to become damaged, and kept the information about the contamination from the plaintiff’s beneficiaries. However, the court found that the claims against the lawyer/administrator were barred because in the underlying probate action, the court had held that the administrator fulfilled his duties and was discharged from all duties and obligations under New Jersey’s Probate Code. Accordingly, the court dismissed the Law Division action based upon the Entire Controversy Doctrine, res judicata, collateral estoppel and judicial estoppel.
Carly Edman (Pittsburgh, PA) obtained a dismissal of a plaintiff’s legal and accounting malpractice claims in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. The plaintiff filed suit against a number of defendants as a result of tax liability stemming from a prior unrelated legal settlement. The plaintiff claimed that our attorney client was negligent in providing legal and accounting advice in regard to corrective tax filings following a legal settlement with a state entity. The plaintiff asserted claims of legal malpractice, accounting malpractice, fraud and a host of constitutional violations. Carly sought dismissal via a number of arguments, including a lack of subject matter jurisdiction. After multiple rounds of amended pleadings and briefing, the court entered an order adopting our jurisdictional argument and dismissed the plaintiff’s latest complaint without prejudice based upon a Rule 8 violation for his failure to plead a proper jurisdictional basis. While the dismissal order was without prejudice, the running of the statute of limitations resulted in our client obtaining the win.
Nicholas Chrysanthem (New York, NY) received a “no further action” letter on a grievance where the attorney was accused of a conflict in helping the client’s adversary in a litigation after the attorney was terminated in his role as counsel.
*Prior Results Do Not Guarantee a Similar Outcome
| |
|
Marshall Dennehey Attorneys Successful in Legal Malpractice Action Arising Out of a Complex Wrongful Medical Diagnosis Case
By John “Jack” Slimm, Esq. and Jeremy J. Zacharias, Esq., RPLU
On October 10, 2023, Marshall Dennehey attorneys Jack Slimm and Jeremy Zacharias were successful in a legal malpractice action arising out of a multi-party and complex wrongful medical diagnosis case. In reaching its decision, the trial court relied upon Morris Properties, Inc. v. Wheeler, 2023 WL 2249975 (App. Div. February 28, 2023), another case which Jack and Jeremy successfully handled at both the trial and appellate level.
The legal malpractice action arose out of an underlying medical malpractice lawsuit in which the plaintiff sued a hospital and several pulmonologists alleging permanent injuries as a result of a misdiagnosis of interstitial lung disease. The plaintiff alleged that the medical malpractice law firm handling her case deviated from the standard of care.
In deciding the legal malpractice action, the trial court looked to the Morris Properties decision which dealt with the very same issue presented to the court in this case. The court held that, like in Morris Properties, the plaintiff’s expert failed to present competent expert evidence on proximate causation and damages, and thus barred the plaintiff’s expert report and testimony.
Following the decision, the plaintiff moved for reconsideration, which the court denied. The plaintiff also sought to submit a revised expert report on the eve of trial, but the court also denied this motion, finding it would be unduly prejudicial to the defense.
Once the court properly barred the plaintiff’s expert’s opinion, it was compelled to grant summary judgment to the defense as the plaintiff did not have a medical liability expert to testify to the claims asserted in the complaint. The court properly held that without expert testimony, the plaintiff was not able to satisfy her burden of establishing applicable standard of care and breach of the standard, as well as damages.
As a result, Jack and Jeremy were successful in having the potential highly-valued legal malpractice action dismissed.
| |
KEY DIFFERENCES BETWEEN DISCIPLINARY MATTERS AND CIVIL LITIGATION | |
|
by Alesia S. Sulock
One of the most important things for an attorney to understand when faced with a disciplinary proceeding is that the disciplinary process is not civil litigation. An attorney who understands the differences between a disciplinary matter and litigation is likely to have a far easier time navigating the disciplinary system than one who lacks that knowledge.
First, the disciplinary process proceeds differently than litigation. It begins with the filing of a complaint with the relevant disciplinary authority. The attorney against whom the complaint is filed typically will not know the complaint has been filed unless it survives the initial intake process (although this is not the case in all states). The majority of complaints are dismissed on intake as lacking merit. If the complaint survives intake, a request for the attorney’s position will be issued. This is often the first time the attorney knows a disciplinary matter has been commenced. The attorney has an opportunity to respond, after which disciplinary counsel determines whether to proceed. This is the time when an attorney should retain counsel experienced in disciplinary matters. We have all heard the adage “a lawyer who represents himself has a fool for a client.” This is even more true in the area of disciplinary matters. If the matter proceeds, it moves on to a formal complaint, an answer, discovery, a hearing, and ultimately, a recommendation for discipline. The high court of the state typically must approve any imposition of discipline.
Second, the disciplinary process is confidential, to a point. The intake process and the initial request for the attorney’s position are usually entirely confidential. An attorney facing a disciplinary matter that has survived intake will have an opportunity to respond to the allegations of ethical violations before the matter becomes public. (There are very rare occasions where an immediate emergency temporary suspension is warranted, and those matters may become public sooner.) This gives the attorney a unique opportunity to resolve matters which simply need explaining before they are required to be disclosed to the public.
Third, and most importantly, the way an attorney responds to the initial request for information can “make or break” the disciplinary process. Unlike litigation, it is not advisable to simply deny the allegations made. Instead, an attorney should provide responsive, thorough, and honest answers. It is critical to accept responsibility for mistakes and show remorse for misconduct or ethical violations. An attorney should share mitigating factors, or explanations for the conduct, when appropriate.
Lastly, the attorney should provide a plan for moving forward that includes rectifying mistakes and putting procedures in place to prevent future problems.
By understanding these key differences and, of course, retaining counsel experienced with the disciplinary process early, attorneys can navigate the disciplinary process more smoothly.
| |
|
September 8, 2023 - Jeremy Zacharias (Mount Laurel, NJ) presented at the New Jersey ICLE’s “Commercial Real Estate: From Handshake to Closing Seminar.” Jeremy’s topic pertained to ethical considerations in handling commercial real estate transactions. He discussed the implications of the Rules of Professional Conduct on certain real estate transactions, including multiple representations, dealing with unrepresented parties, and practical pointers when facing a motion to disqualify when an attorney handles multiple representations in a commercial real estate deal. This presentation was well attended by members of the Bar, and Jeremy discussed the importance of assessing the Rules of Professional Conduct in everyday practice.
September 15, 2023 - The Legal Intelligencer published “You Diligently Protect Your Clients; What About You? Part 2 (The Middle and the End)” written by Josh J.T. Byrne and Alesia S. Sulock (Philadelphia, PA). You can read their article here.
September 21, 2023 - Dana Gittleman’s (Philadelphia, PA) article “Trying the PL Case: Lessons Learned in the Courtroom” was published on the PLUS Blog. You can read Dana’s article here.
September 29, 2023 - Josh J.T. Byrne and Alesia S. Sulock (Philadelphia, PA) were featured speakers at the Professional Liability Defense Federation (PLDF) annual meeting in Denver on September 29. They were part of a panel titled “Defending and Avoiding Disciplinary Complaints.”
October 2023 - Scott Eberle (Pittsburgh, PA) presented “Ethics Issues in Auto Law" at the Pennsylvania Bar Institute's Auto Law Update webinar.
November 1, 2023 - Josh J.T. Byrne (Philadelphia, PA) joined a Pennsylvania Bar Institute panel to present a CLE on ethical use of social media for attorneys.
November 8, 2023 - Scott Eberle (Pittsburgh, PA) presented “Avoiding Legal Malpractice” to members of the Beaver County Bar Association.
| |
Legal Update for Lawyers' Professional Liability, November 2023, has been prepared for our readers by Marshall Dennehey. It is solely intended to provide information on recent legal developments and is not intended to provide legal advice for a specific situation or to create an attorney-client relationship. We welcome the opportunity to provide such legal assistance as you require on this and other subjects. If you receive the alerts in error, please send a note tamontemuro@mdwcg.com. ATTORNEY ADVERTISING pursuant to New York RPC 7.1. © 2023 Marshall Dennehey. All Rights Reserved. | | | | |