Week of June 4th,  2018
Mississippi River Basin News

This Week in Washington
dd
EPA Forced to Provide Documents Supporting Pruitt's Disbelief in Humans' Role in Global Warming

It has been over a year since Scott Pruitt's declaration that he "would not agree that [carbon dioxide created by human activity i]s a primary contributor to the global warming that we see," contradicting the conclusions posted on the website of the agency he leads, the EPA. Immediately following this, the 
nonprofit Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER) filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request for "any EPA documents that 
support the conclusions" Pruitt made on television. After the EPA did not act
on this  request, PEER brought a case against the agency.

The EPA has maintained that Pruitt's statement was a personal opinion and 
did not reflect the agency's position. However, the court made it clear that, regardless of whether or not that is the case, personal opinion "may... guide 
the  agency's regulatory efforts and, to the extent any agency records provide 
the  basis for such public statements, those agency  records are a perfectly 
proper  focus of a FOIA request."
 
The court issued its ruling last Friday, requiring the EPA to produce the 
records that the nonprofit requested through its FOIA  request. Any non-
exempt records must be "disclose[d] promptly... on a rolling basis" by July 
2nd, 2018, and the agency must explain why documents were withheld by 
July 11th. The ruling was a result of two failures by the EPA. First,  it was 
unable to sufficiently explain why the search for these records "would  be overbroad and unduly burdensome."  The court found the agency's explanation 
too general, merely contending that  it "would not even know  where  or how to begin searching for documents for  such a broad, sweeping request" and it 
"would require EPA to spend countless hours researching and analyzing a vast trove of material."

Second, the EPA based its defense on the idea that it was being forced to 
"evaluate whether a particular document supports or refutes, or even relates 
to, [PEER]'s proposition concerning the effect of human activity on climate change." The court rejected this claim, holding that the FOIA request only required the EPA to find and provide "documents that explicitly draw a 
conclusion on that subject."





Senate Farm Bill Text Released, House Vote 
Is  Two 
Weeks Away
 
The Senate Agriculture Committee released the draft text of their version of 
the farm bill today, June 8th. The proposed legislation's markup session will 
take place next Wednesday morning. At the markup, Senators will debate, amend,  and rewrite their version of the bill, including the hotly discussed farm 
subsidies and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) that 
has been such a point of contention in the House.

The House is still set to hold its second vote on its version of the bill on June 
22nd. Last time, House Republicans failed to pass their bill, falling short 
198-213. Of the 213 representatives who voted against the proposed legislation, most were Democrats and Republican members of the Freedom Caucus. The 
latter rejected the farm bill in an effort to force other Republicans' hands and prioritize passing an immigration bill which still has not reached the House 
floor. In order for the House's farm bill to pass in two weeks, Republicans will either have to solve their party's in-fighting or reach across the aisle and create 
a more bipartisan bill.






News From Around the Basin

Energy











 
Water Resource Management








 
Agriculture








 
Biodiversity, Wildlife, and Invasive Species











       
                                                             
Infrastructure


 

Politics and People






 
Selected Hearings





 
Other News


 
e-Newsletters, Publications, Journals, Multimedia


 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

NEMWI: Strengthening the Region That Sustains the Nation