Tenants Send Message:

Landlords Must Follow the Law or Face Consequences

Images of Bentley Manor from complaint.


On March 12, three Philadelphia tenants at Bentley Manor, a large apartment complex in West Oak Lane owned by Odin Properties, filed a class action complaint alleging that Odin has illegally collected rent in violation of city laws while failing to address unsafe conditions.


The named plaintiffs—a Philadelphia police officer, a SEPTA transit operator, and a grandmother with disabilities—are represented by the Public Interest Law Center and Hausfeld in the lawsuit, which comes after months of organizing by Odin tenants and OnePA Renters United Philadelphia (RUP).


Dawn Colbourne, a RUP member and one of the named plaintiffs, moved into Bentley Manor in 2023 expecting a safe home. Instead, she found leaking around her window, flickering electricity and electrical outages, mold growth in the hallway, and a lack of security due to the building’s non-latching front door.


“We all deserve a safe place to live, no matter who we are or what road we’ve travelled to get here,” said Ms. Colbourne. “These landlord companies are quick to file an eviction when a tenant doesn’t pay rent, so it’s only fair that we hold landlords accountable when they don’t do what they’re supposed to do.”

Dawn Colbourne, Bentley Manor resident and plaintiff.


Philadelphia law prohibits a landlord from collecting rent if the landlord fails to correct a serious L&I violation within 30 days. The plaintiffs here allege that Odin has continued to charge, demand, and collect rent each month, even as the building remained in unsafe status.


“One of Philadelphia’s biggest landlords has let a building sit in unsafe status for months, collecting rent along the way,” said Madison Gray, staff attorney at the Law Center. “The tenants are sending a clear message: landlords must follow the law or face consequences.”


With this lawsuit, on behalf of the proposed class of tenants, plaintiffs are seeking a refund of illegally collected rent and late fees, a court order enforcing Philadelphia law, and injunctive relief requiring that the defendant companies make Bentley Manor safe.


Read the complaint here.


The Law Center Responds to the President's Threats

Brent W. Landau, Executive Director of the Public Interest Law Center, released the following statement in response to the President’s March 22, 2025 memorandum threatening lawyers:


“Our civil rights depend on lawyers with the courage to challenge injustice. Targeting attorneys who represent individuals and organizations against the government is a dangerous step toward undermining the rule of law. By threatening to punish lawyers who fight against illegal and unconstitutional actions, the Trump administration seeks to intimidate all those who would stand in its way. We simply cannot allow our civil rights to be diminished through fear.


The Public Interest Law Center opened its doors in 1969 as the Philadelphia affiliate of the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law. For 56 years, we have worked alongside lawyers in the private bar to defend constitutional rights, protect democracy, and ensure equal justice under the law. This latest directive threatens everyone’s fundamental rights by discouraging attorneys from taking on cases that challenge government overreach, enforce civil rights, or protect vulnerable communities. We will not be silenced, and we call on the entire legal profession to join us as we continue to pursue justice for all, no matter how difficult the fight.”


Click here to share the post on LinkedIn.

A Win for Transparency in Cyber Charter Spending

Cyber charter schools in Pennsylvania enroll nearly 60,000 students and are funded by more than $1 billion in taxpayer funding from school districts—but unlike school districts, public information on how public funds are spent by cyber charter schools is often hard to come by.


In 2022, Education Voters of PA (Ed Voters) filed a Right to Know request, that became a years-long quest to access records from Pennsylvania’s largest cyber charter school, Commonwealth Charter Academy Charter School (CCA). Submitted as part of Ed Voters’ efforts to understand how CCA spends Pennsylvanians’ tax dollars, the request sought records of CCA’s reimbursements to families for students’ activities and classes outside of the school day.


After CCA refused to provide the requested records, the Public Interest Law Center successfully represented Ed Voters in the Dauphin County Court of Common Pleas.  CCA appealed that decision and we won again, with the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania issuing an opinion this month affirming the trial court’s decision and ordering CCA to disclose the requested documents, redacted of any personally identifying information, to Ed Voters. 


CCA may still petition to further appeal this decision—and we will continue to stand with partners like Ed Voters to demand transparency and accountability from cyber charter schools in Pennsylvania.


Read more here.


Wilkes-Barre Students Show Improvements with Increased School Funding

Wilkes-Barre superintendent, Brian Costello.


Wilkes-Barre Area School District is one of the six school districts we represent in our landmark school funding lawsuit. Last year, the Commonwealth began the long road to addressing the $4.5 billion adequacy gap via a $500 million increase to the basic education budget, and now Wilkes-Barre School District is beginning to be able to provide their students and faculty with the resources they need to succeed. WVIA News recently went to G.A.R. Middle School to speak with faculty and students and spoke with Superintendent Brian Costello who shared,


“We now have an unprecedented opportunity to really change the way we fund public education, ensuring that every student, not just in the Wilkes-Barre Area School District, but also across Pennsylvania, has access to the resources they need to thrive. The increased funding from last year's budget truly initiated a transformational change,” Costello said during a press conference last month on the two-year anniversary of the court decision. “For our district, we have been able to see firsthand what is possible when we invest in our students.”


Read the full article here. 


Defending the Rights of Formerly Incarcerated Individuals

The Law Center works to reduce barriers to employment for individuals with criminal records, who are disproportionately people of color and who routinely face discrimination in the workforce for decades after they have successfully completed their sentences. In March, the Law Center participated as an amici in the Third Circuit in Phath v. Central Transport LLC. Pennsylvania’s Criminal History Record Information Act (CHRIA) prohibits employers from using a criminal conviction to deny employment unless the conviction directly relates to the applicant’s suitability for the particular position. Rodney Phath filed a lawsuit asserting a prospective employer violated CHRIA for refusing to hire him based on an old, unrelated, criminal conviction which Mr. Phath disclosed during his job interview.


Interpreting CHRIA narrowly, the district court dismissed the case holding that CHRIA’s protections apply only when the employer obtains the criminal history record information from a criminal justice agency and not from an applicant’s voluntary disclosure.


The amicus brief, coordinated by National Employment Law Project and their co-counsel at Outten and Golden, emphasizes the steep employment barriers faced by individuals with criminal records and the important public policies behind CHRIA including promoting gainful employment and decreasing recidivism. If allowed to stand, the district court’s misinterpretation of CHRIA creates a large loophole allowing an employer to exempt itself from CHRIA simply by asking the applicant for the information rather than relying on a background check report.


Read the brief here.

Law Center Staff Featured in Penn Carey Law Journal

"This case was one of the most meaningful fights you can take on. [Fair funding] is so important at the individual level and at a societal level," said Law Center legal director Mimi McKenzie of the landmark 2023 Commonwealth Court decision that declared Pennsylvania’s school funding system unconstitutional.


“Education was declared a fundamental right for the first time in the Commonwealth’s history,” added senior attorney Dan Urevick-Ackelsberg.


The two were featured in a Penn Carey Law Journal piece about the historic school funding lawsuit.


Read the full article here.

Goodbye, Ryan

After more than two years as the Environmental Justice Organizer, Ryan Gittler-Muñiz is leaving the Law Center to serve in a new role in the Philadelphia garden community. Ryan has been a valuable member of the team, helping us to build and deepen relationships with gardens and the neighbors who care for them across the city. We look forward to seeing Ryan thrive in their new role!

Funder Spotlight

Welcome to the Law Center’s Funder Spotlight, where each month we highlight one of the many foundation partners who make our work possible. This month, the spotlight is on the William Penn Foundation.

The William Penn Foundation, founded in 1945 by Otto and Phoebe Haas, is committed to expanding access to resources and opportunities that promote a more vital and just city and region for all. They do this through funding programs in the Philadelphia region in arts and culture, children and families, democracy and civic initiatives, environment and public space, and workforce training and services. In addition to two grants for our work on school funding, the William Penn Foundation has recently awarded us a two-year grant to support our garden work. Learn more at www.williampennfoundation.org.

Exciting News: David Dye Returns as Emcee!

We’re thrilled to welcome back David Dye as the emcee for our annual event on October 9! A Philadelphia broadcasting legend, David was just honored with a well-deserved place on the Philadelphia Music Alliance Walk of Fame, a testament to his incredible impact on our city’s music and culture.


Join us as we celebrate justice and community with David at the helm. Sponsorships are now available—a great opportunity for law firms and businesses to support our mission while gaining visibility at this inspiring event. Secure yours today!


Learn more: https://pubintlaw.org/events/2025-annual-event/

Donate!
Facebook  Instagram  LinkedIn  X

The official registration and financial information of the Public Interest Law Center may be obtained from the Pennsylvania Department of State by calling toll-free, within Pennsylvania, 1-800-732-0999. Registration does not imply endorsement.