Then and Now

EIHS News


April 2025

Together, we are stronger! Celebrating local nonprofits

Local nonprofit organizations are helping Fort Myers Beach regenerate and thrive after

Hurricane Ian devastated our island in September 2022. At the Cocktails and Conversation event on Tuesday, April 15, the Estero Island Historic

Society was joined by the Ostego Bay Foundation, Friends of Matanzas Pass

Preserve, Estero Bay Buddies and Restore the Arches FMB to share stories of our

environmental, historical and cultural initiatives. We thanked residents and visitors for

their support in rebuilding and preserving what makes this island so special.

Thank you to all the members, volunteers and sponsors who help us keep moving

forward.

Murder mystery on Fort Myers Beach

EIHS President Ellie Bunting led two popular sessions, on March 1 and March 22, about the notorious Galloway murders in 1953 on FMB.


A husband and wife were murdered on their north-end property — near the current Pink Shell — by two drifters who may have chanced upon them as hapless robbery victims.


Or perhaps there was a sinister back story to the gruesome murders, and the arson of

their home that followed. Audience members added details and speculation to the two lively sessions at the Historic 1921 Cottage.


EIHS Board members will explore more FMB mysteries in the months ahead, and share their findings. Stay tuned!

Lessons learned, history shared

The EIHS 2025 season featured several public presentations on a range of topics that

piqued interest among EIHS members and friends.


On January 13, we learned about the Gullah-Geechee culture and history of the Sea

Islands off Georgia and South Carolina from Martha Bireda, Director of the Blanchard

House Museum of African American History and Culture of Charlotte County. While

learning about Gullah healing practices, herbal medicines and an ethos of community

sharing, attendees were treated to sassafras tea and sesame candies popular on the

Sea Islands.


On February 10, EIHS President, Ellie Bunting, and Board member of the EIHS and

Friends of Matanzas Pass Preserve, Terry Cain, shared lessons from the precarious

history of establishing the 600-acre Estero Bay Aquatic Preserve (Florida’s first) and

the 60-acre Matanzas Pass Preserve (adjacent to the EIHS Historic Cottage) that

shelters native flora and fauna. These unique ecosystems — threatened by

development or encroachment from their inception to the present day — are a hard-won legacy that we must be vigilant to preserve.


Perennially popular speaker, Robert Macomber, on March 10 regaled the EIHS about

The Freedmen’s Bureau in Florida after the Civil War — including one fact-finding

mission to then-desolate southwest Florida. Macomber traced resistance in both the

southern and northern US to aiding free slaves’ integration into post-war society, and

the heroic efforts of military and civilian teachers to help educate and empower them.

EIHS exhibits: How hurricanes and Gulf shrimp shaped FMB history

Photos and memorabilia curated by EIHS President Ellie Bunting featured in two

fascinating exhibits at the EIHS Historic Cottage.


The fall-winter Hurricane Exhibit’s grim timeline of Florida’s most damaging known

hurricanes, accompanied by historic photos, illustrated our state’s vulnerability to these

powerful storm systems that since the 1880s have taken thousands of lives. Locally, the ravages of Hurricanes Donna (1960), Charley (2004) and Ian (2022) reshaped FMB. Ian took lives and destroyed property and infrastructure on a scale our community has never experienced.


On a brighter note, the Gulf Shrimping Exhibit (coinciding with the 2025 Shrimp Festival

in early March) celebrated the tasty and profitable “pink gold” shrimp discovered

offshore by FMB fishermen in the 1950s. This edible treasure has been an economic

and gastronomic boon to the island. Today, a smaller shrimping fleet carries on this

tradition, and local restaurants proudly serve the bounty with a rich flavor unlike any

imported shrimp.

Looking Ahead


The 2025-26 EIHS season of events and exhibits promises immersion into local history and our environment by guest speakers and EIHS Board members.


The Summer 2025 issue of Then and Now will have more details.

Thank you to the following donors:

FMB Woman’s Club

Ron Hemstreet

Neil Wilkinson

Thomas Myers Family

AJ Bassett Family

Shipwreck

Anita Cereceda / The Islander

Annette’s Book Nook

Beach Talk Radio

Support Our Corporate Members.

Guerrilla Marketing

Ostego Bay Foundation

The Islander

TriPower Vacation Rentals

TriPower Realty

Beach Talk Radio

Fort Myers Beach Mosquito Control

Affordable Flooring SWFL

If you are not yet an EIHS member, the annual dues are only $30 for an individual, $50 for a supporter and $100 for a business.


Join us today! Visit our website and click on Membership.