This co-op producer consistently turns out amazing wines that are also well-priced for their quality. Although the price of this has gone up over the last few years, it's still a bargain compared to the overall market for these wines. This wine will be drinkable with good food in a year or two, and will age twenty years with grace and style.
From Parker: "The 2016 Barbaresco is a tight and beautiful wine that will require more time to unwind and soften. This beautifully balanced vintage is characterized by a tight inner core of fruit that underlines the graceful aging capacity of these wines. The 2016 is shaping up to be one destined for long cellar aging. Now in its youth, the wine offers wild berry, rose and licorice aromas."
As I've written before, the nerello mascalese-based wines coming from the volcanic soils high on Sicily's Mount Etna are some of my personal favorites these days. This is the entry level bottling from Etna's finest producer, and is
already showing a supple mouthfeel and deep fruit flavors. This wine has the fine, elegant structure of Burgundy, but the black fruit flavors of Nebbiolo, all in one package. Irresistible. And look at the price!
From Vinous: "Bright red. Pure nose offers red cherry and raspberry fruit aromas complicated by herbs and minerals. Suave and rather tightly wound, but nicely lifted by salty minerality that accentuates the bright red fruit flavors. Finishes firmly tannic but not drying, with outstanding persistence. Simply a great entry level Etna Rosso."
From Parker: "I had tasted this wine from barrel last year, and the wine was already shaping up beautifully back then. Staying the course, the 2015 Barolo Bricco Boschis shows extreme elegance and finesse. These are the characteristics of what is surely one of the most beautiful vineyard sites in Barolo. The Bricco Boschis cru affords a panoramic view onto much of the Langhe, with snowcapped Alps in the background. Barolo from Castiglione Falletto tends to show characteristics that are very fine, precise and linear. That's fundamentally what you get here despite the more exuberant and fleshy 2015 vintage. This wine is truly beautiful."
Kelley Fox Pinot Noir Hyland Vineyard Coury Clone
World Class Club
Winemaker Kelley Fox makes some of the most intensely elegant wines in Oregon, and has gained a loyal cult-y following as a result. This wine should make her followers geek out big time.
The Coury Clone pinot noir was among the earliest plantings in Oregon, having been smuggled into the state in a suitcase, as the legend is told. Some of it was sold as Pommard, and later correctly identified. Some have even surmised it is not even pinot noir . . .but in any case, the clone tends to produce finished wines that are high-toned, racy, with a texture and vinosity unlike the other pinot noir clones found here. The character of the clone combined with the winemaking of Kelley Fox could be a magical thing, and should be an exciting combination.
That said, this wine is currently tight and focused, like most higher-end 2017s. It has excellent extract, and exceptional persistence on the palate now, with refined tannins coming in on the finish. But It must have some time to develop in the bottle before drinking. I recommend at least 12-18 months. After that, it should age well for a decade or more. 150 scant cases produced.
2016 Eminent Domaine Pinot Noir Estate
Spectator 94 Points
World Class Club
Winery owner and winemaker Jeff Meader had some property taken from him by the City of Portland, via the eminent domain process. Making lemonade out of lemons, Meader bought some land in the famed Ribbon Ridge AVA and started Eminent Domaine - you see what he did there, right?
The winery has grown steadily and the products are of high quality. It's been limited in some past vintages, but growth now allows somewhat easier access to the wines.
This 2016 bottling is a terrific example of the great 2016 vintage, featuring a rich, broad palate of juicy fruit flavors that run the gamut from mid-red to blackberry. It has a classic, layered mid palate, and a complex and long finish. Like many of the '16s, it is quite approachable now, but also has the weight to age well for those with patience. Drink or hold.
This wine was awarded a Wine Spectator 94 Points with these notes: "Polished and expressive, but impeccably structured, with rich raspberry and smoky, dusky spice flavors that dance toward refined tannins. Drink now through 2025."
2016 Antica Terra Pinot Noir Antikythera
Suckling 99 Points
Reserve Club
Winemaker Maggie Harrison migrated to Oregon after a long stint at California's Sine Qua Non, an iconoclastic producer known for exceptionally bold wines that have garnered a long string of 100-point scores. Maggie now produces a variety of high-end pinot noirs here, with Antikythera being the top bottling (perhaps). This is dense, bold, concentrated, but also shows balance. This is fully extracted, but is in no way harsh or overdone. There are not many Oregon wines that combine such power and intensity while retaining such a sense of poise. This is meant for the cellar, so wait at least a couple of years.
This is also interesting because of the "compare and contrast" between Maggie Harrison and Kelley Fox, and their wines. The two very popular female winemakers approach wine with a bit of a . . . spiritual bent. But the style of their wines about as different as they could be.
From Suckling: "This is a selection of the estate-vineyard pinot noir that is planted on a solid sheet of parent rock. The nose is ebulliently fruited with intense, poached berries, as well as a pastry-like edge, flowers and stones, serving up what proves to be a deceptively charming, seductive impression. The palate arrives as a layered array of sheet-like tannins in very vertical form; the flavors have to climb up and across to be tasted and they are pristine, fresh cherries and red plums when they arrive. As the flavors abate, the stony, noble tannins remain like a rock face, just begging to be climbed again. Sheer brilliance. Hold for more than a decade, if you can."
2017 Kelley Fox Pinot Noir Flower Block
Reserve Club
Maresh Vineyard is one of the most prized vineyards in Oregon, and any good Oregon winemaker would jump at the chance to get some of that old vine fruit. Kelley Fox gets a good chunk of it, and uses it to produce exquisite wines that combine the elegance and purity of classic pinot noir with seriously complex flavors and the kind of structure that allows pinot noir to age gracefully for years and years.
In recent years, Fox has learned that the vines from The Star of Bethlehem Flower Block - so named after the lily-related flowers that grow between the vines -- produce a distinctive and special wine, so she started bottling it as a stand-alone wine about three vintages ago. Her notes on the wine are lyrical and on point, so I'm going to use her info in this review:
"Only six barrels comprised this bottling. The 2017 is a transparent, brilliant light red with blue and fuschia lights and tones that catch the eye. This year, the Star is a little deeper than that of the Maresh, but that said, both remind me a bit of my 2007 or 2011 in several ways. The nose is noble and pure, with a moving, diaphanous layer of minerality over the refined strawberry character always present in my Maresh bottlings when young. This wine, my most subtle and refined 2017 Pinot, is a sleek and strong beauty. This one is like a person who sits quietly in one place and to whom others are magnetically attracted and approach on their own, perhaps not even knowing why or that they did in the first place. It is a wine of silence and will likely be spellbinding as it matures."
2018 Patricia Green Cellars Pinot Noir Reserve
Pinotguy 93 Points
This entry-level pinot noir from winemaker Jim Anderson at PGC is basically a vinous give-away at this price. Think of it as a loss-leader. This is a blended with fruit from around Oregon, including many of the wineries prized single-vineyard sources. It has above-average concentration, and is already nicely layered and also quite lengthy. While approachable and enjoyable now, it should continue to improve in bottle for the next six months or up to 6-8 years.
The last few vintages have seen this wine awarded 93 points on a consistent basis, making it one of the best Quality-to-Price Ratio wines from Oregon. This 2018 bottling as at least as good as those past bottlings, and worthy of case buys.
2016 Battle Creek Pinot Noir Reserve
Premium Wine Club
Battle Creek Vineyard was established in 1989 in the mid-Valley, not far from Salem, and has 110 acres planted to pinot noir - a decent sized vineyard around here. They've been producing pinot noir since that same year, and continue to produce estate pinot noir as well as bottling single-vineyard wines from other local sources.
Winemaker Sarah Cabot is best known locally for her years at Belle Pente winery, where she made a full lineup of pinot noir and other wines. Stints at Willakenzie, Omero Cellars, and a stage in New Zealand all populate her resume.
The 2016 Reserve Pinot Noir has a surfeit of rich fruit flavors, tending towards black fruits, all wrapped up in some fine tannins and supported by good balancing acidity. The wine is medium-bodied, a bit spicy on the palate, and lingers nicely through a good finish. There's a lot of fruit here for this level, and enough stuffing to cellar for a few years. Drink now, or hold.