|
What the new PSA screening guidelines mean for your family
What changed and why I’ve been asking men to start the conversation since my diagnosis at 35.
Hi Friends,
Before this week, the American Cancer Society (ACS) last updated its prostate cancer screening guideline in 2010. That same year, I was diagnosed with prostate cancer at 35. I had no prostate cancer symptoms and no known family history of the disease. My first PSA test was part of an evaluation for low testosterone. Back then, the ACS advised men at average risk to talk with their doctors at age 50 about whether to get screened. The guideline stopped short of recommending routine PSA testing.
This week, the ACS issued its first update in 16 years. It now directly recommends regular PSA testing at specific ages and intervals based on a man’s risk. The conversation about benefits and risks still comes first. The update reflects stronger evidence that screening can reduce the risk of advanced prostate cancer and death from the disease, along with better ways to decide who needs a biopsy.
What is a PSA test? It’s a blood test that measures prostate-specific antigen, a protein made by the prostate. An enlarged prostate, inflammation, or cancer can all raise PSA.
What the American Cancer Society recommends
These recommendations apply to screening before a diagnosis. If you’ve already been diagnosed with prostate cancer, your care team will guide how often to check your PSA.
-
Men at average risk should get a PSA test every two years from age 50 through 69.
-
Black men should get a PSA test every year from age 45 through 69.
-
Other men with a father, brother, or son who had prostate cancer should start at 45 and continue through 69. Test yearly if one relative was diagnosed before 65 or if more than one had prostate cancer. If only one was diagnosed, at 65 or older, test every two years.
-
Men with known or suspected inherited risk, such as a BRCA2 gene mutation, should ask their doctor when to start and how often to test.
At ages 70 to 74, the ACS recommends deciding with your doctor whether to continue screening. If you continue, the ACS recommends testing every two years. From age 75 on, the ACS generally advises against routine screening. The PSA blood test is the recommended screening test. A doctor may still use a rectal exam during a follow-up evaluation.
Read the updated American Cancer Society guideline
How the urology guideline compares
The American Urological Association and the Society of Urologic Oncology say doctors may offer a first PSA at ages 45 to 50 for men at average risk and should offer screening at ages 40 to 45 for men at increased risk. That first result is called a baseline. It helps you and your doctor decide when to test again.
Read the AUA/SUO screening recommendations (2023 PDF)
(The 2026 update kept the same starting ages.)
What happens if your PSA is high?
The ACS recommends repeating the blood test first. If it stays high, a prostate MRI, another blood or urine test, or both can help most men and their doctors decide whether a biopsy is needed.
If a biopsy finds low-risk prostate cancer, the ACS recommends offering active surveillance first. That means keeping a close eye on the cancer and considering treatment if tests show it’s becoming more likely to grow or spread. That’s what my doctors and I chose. Sixteen years later, I’m still on active surveillance and haven’t needed surgery or radiation.
You can ask about PSA before you’re due for a test
Since I founded Blue Cure in 2010, I’ve encouraged men to keep up with checkups, know their numbers, and ask questions early. That includes men in their 30s and 40s.
Screening guidelines give you and your doctor a starting point. On the Blue Cure Men’s Health Podcast, I’ve asked urologists how they decide when it makes sense to talk about PSA testing with younger men. Here are a few examples from those conversations.
-
Dr. Adam Weiner (Cedars-Sinai) discussed what a PSA at 35 or 40 might tell him about a patient’s long-term risk when there’s a reason to test that early.
- Dr. Larry Lipshultz (Baylor College of Medicine), my urologist when I was diagnosed, said his practice generally starts testing around 40 and may start earlier depending on a man’s risk.
- Dr. Geoffrey Sonn (Stanford Medicine) favors checking PSA by 45 and using the first result to help decide when to test again.
One conversation you can start this week
If you’ve had prostate cancer, tell your sons or brothers how old you were when you were diagnosed. That’s a detail they can take to their next checkup. If a friend comes to mind, forward him this email and ask if he’s ever talked with his doctor about PSA.
If you’re newly diagnosed, ask your care team, “What’s my risk level, and is active surveillance an option for me?” If you’re asking about a first PSA, try “Given my age, family history, and other risk factors, does testing make sense for me now? If I should wait, when should we talk about it again?”
Gabe Canales
Founder, Blue Cure
P.S. Our free Men’s Health Checklist is available in English and Spanish. Print it, put it on the fridge, and jot down questions as they come to you. Bring it to your next checkup.
If this email helped you, please consider a gift to Blue Cure. Your support helps us bring free education to more communities, share resources in English and Spanish, and take men’s questions directly to physicians on our podcast. We do this so men and families know what to ask when it’s time to make decisions about screening or care.
|