Spring has sprung, bringing with it seasonal celebrations – and the legal questions that often follow. 

In this issue, we're sharing an article on holiday celebration compliance to help Boards navigate the balance between festive community spirit and the legal obligations around Free Expression and Fair Housing. Below, you will also find a brief update on the state of the Corporate Transparency Act.

As always, our goal is to help you lead your communities with confidence, care, and legal clarity.

AJ Jahanian, Esq.

Naughty or Nice: How Homeowner Associations Can Handle Large Holiday Celebrations

Kyle Meade, Esq.



Homeowner associations (HOAs) in California often face challenges with large-scale events that cause disruptions like traffic, noise, and other nuisances. The Morris v. West Hayden Estates First Addition Homeowners Association, Inc. case examined the dynamics of balancing an HOA’s authority to regulate large scale events, with owners’ rights of free expression and religion. In Morris, an HOA in Idaho attempted to regulate a large-scale Christmas celebration lasting five days and attracting hundreds of guests. The event caused significant disruptions according to the HOA, whose board gave notice to Morris, stating that their plans for a large-scale Christmas event could upset "avowed atheists.” Despite holding the Christmas event for two years straight, the residents who hosted sued the HOA, claiming religious discrimination based on the board’s letter.

The court initially sided with the HOA, finding the event violated the HOA’s governing documents and that the HOA did not discriminate against the residents’ religious beliefs. On appeal, the 9th Circuit affirmed the District Court’s findings that the HOA did not engage in religious discrimination that prevented access to housing, but also noted that the board’s letter which discouraged the Christmas event was coercive and intimidating under the Fair Housing Act (FHA). The 9th Circuit found the HOA liable for violations under Section 3617 of the FHA and vacated the injunction by the District Court that barred the residents from hosting further large-scale Christmas events.

The Morris case emphasizes the importance of HOAs adopting neutral policies to avoid discrimination claims, especially in situations involving religion. Clear and consistent enforcement of HOA rules, without animus towards religion, is imperative to minimize legal risks when regulating the conduct of residents and guests. HOAs are empowered by their governing documents to place restrictions on activities, but that must be balanced with federal and state law prohibiting discrimination. To adopt best practices, HOAs should consult with legal counsel. 

Corporate Transparency Act Update: Reporting Requirements Lifted for U.S. Companies

The federal government has announced that U.S. companies, including community associations, no longer have to report ownership information under the Corporate Transparency Act. Now, only foreign companies doing business in the U.S. need to report.

For more information or guidance, please contact your Team at Beaumont Tashjian. 

TEAM WINS

• $72K Recovered – Collected unpaid assessments, fees, and costs from a delinquent owner.
• $29K Judgement & Foreclosure – Secured judgement allowing foreclosure against a nonpaying owner.
• $19K Settlement – Recovered unpaid assets, fees, and costs through successful negotiation.
• 4275 Petitions Approved – Secured two (2) favorable judgements to update governing documents.
• $13K Recovered – Collected from an owner delinquent since 2021.

BTS with BT



Even Behind the Scenes, Beaumont Tashjian goes the extra mile – literally! Our team hit the pavement for the Ventura Marathon, proving our teamwork goes beyond the office. Jeff powered through the full marathon, while AJ and Tawnee crushed the half.

BEAUMONT TASHJIAN

866.788.9998