Ignore the 2♣ overcall for a moment. At most tables the auction was simple and without interference: 1♦ – 1♥; 2♥ – 3NT; 4♥ all pass. The 3NT call gives North a choice of games, and with 4 hearts and a doubleton club, the 4♥ decision seems clear. After a trump lead, Declarer can see 4 potential losers, 2 diamonds and 2 clubs, and particular attention should be paid to the diamond suit in isolation.
If the diamond King is onside, only 1 diamond loser is a sure thing, but it appears that if it’s offside, there will definitely be 2 losers. There are a couple of ways to improve the odds, however. One possibility is to start the suit low from dummy. If your RHO holds the King without the Jack, he may be reluctant to play low, afraid you hold Jx. If the King doesn’t appear immediately, you can finesse the Queen when you play diamonds a 2nd time.
Another way to play the suit is to lead from your hand and if LHO plays low, play dummy’s 9. If West holds the ♦J10, the 9 will force the King; if the 9 loses to the 10 or J, you can finesse the Queen the next time you play diamonds. On the other hand, if LHO plays the 10 or J the 1st time, cover it, and if your Queen loses to the King, the next time you can finesse the 9. This assures only 1 loser whenever (1) the ♦K and/or (2) the ♦J-10 are to your left, giving you about a 75% chance of losing only 1 diamond.
In the actual deal, since the King is onside, both suggested methods result in the loss of only a single diamond. Unfortunately, the ♣A is offside for 2 more losers, so you are making 4♥ on the nose.
When Monday Mundane stepped to the plate, she had the advantage of her LHO’s interesting or perhaps inadvisable 2♣ bid in the middle of the auction. Her RHO was once again Nick Dangerhand, this time playing with dear, sweet Ova Bitter. Following the 1♦ and 1♥ bids, Ova Bitter, as her name might suggest, jumped into the fray with her 2♣ overcall with a paltry 10 HCP’s and the dreaded 5-3-3-2 distribution. Truth be told, Ova never met an “Ova-call” she didn’t like.
Perhaps Ova intended 2♣ to be lead-directing, but had she been doubled, she would have been down 500 or 800 for a sure bottom. Frank Stewart, ACBL Bulletin and syndicated newspaper columnist, would have been appalled by her bid, but he would have been proud of what happened to her next.
After a trump lead by Ova, Maggie contemplated the Ova-call and the fact that once again Dangerhand was to her right. She needed to keep him off lead as best she could. That’s when she recalled the earlier Thursday deal. It was obvious to her that even Ova wouldn’t have made her 2-level bid without the ♦K, so she won the opening lead in hand and immediately played a diamond to the Queen, Ova playing the 6.
Now for the part that would have delighted Stewart. When Maggie finished drawing trumps, she played 3 rounds of spades ending in her hand, noting that Ova had followed suit to 3 heart and 3 spade tricks. Ova’s distribution had to be 3=3=2=5 with the doubleton ♦K6 to go with her 5-card club suit. Maggie led a diamond from her hand and when the King popped, as predicted, Maggie ducked!
Ova was endplayed, holding nothing but clubs. The ♣A followed and Maggie collected her King next and ruffed her 3rd club in dummy, thereby making a very well-deserved Ova-trick by holding the defense to just the ♣A and the ♦K. Once again Maggie had succeeded in keeping that Dangerhand from obtaining the lead, this time with the help of her opponent’s unwise Ova-call. Since the conservative-bidding Stewart is frequently accusing players of making unwarranted bids that give their opponents much too much information, he would have been Ova-joyed with the outcome. In fact, he would probably have observed that this Mundane board was Ova-easy, undoubtedly leaving West with egg on her face.
Postmortem: The Mamas & The Papas would have also loved Monday Mundane, but for a different reason. Ova could have held the contract to 10 tricks by playing the ♦K the 1st time the suit was led, thereby avoiding the endplay. Monday Mundane’s objective in leading a diamond at trick 2 was to preclude Ova from realizing that an endplay could be forthcoming. Maggie knew that if she waited too long to start the suit, Ova may well have foreseen the endplay and put up her King immediately. As Ova lamented (go ahead, sing along):
----Monday Mundane, you gave me no warning of what was to be
----Oh, Monday Mundane, I won 2 tricks instead of three.
|