Roberta said she assumed the ♦K could have been led from either AK or KQ, per Eddie Kantar’s “52 Facts of Bridge Life,” since he recommends the lead of the King from AKx (or longer) at the five or six level, or when leading from a supported suit. How in the world did she know about Kantar, I asked. Roberta disclosed she was a card-carrying member of the birds-only Audubon Contract Bridge League, and the “52 Facts” had been written up in their ACBL Flyover magazine, delivered monthly by carrier pigeon.
Returning to the 1st trick, my feathered friend advised she would ruff the ♦K, so I played East’s ♦Q, intended as suit preference for spades. Roberta called for the ♥4, I played low, and her 10 lost to West’s Ace.
My partner (also me) led the ♠2 and Roberta won dummy’s Ace and played the ♥Q. When I ducked smoothly (covering would be no better), she cackled merrily and bird-splained: “West must have a doubleton heart as East’s auction showed 4 of them. Surely if West held ♥AK tight, he would have led hearts first, since a diamond was far more likely to be ruffed.” The ♥Q won the trick, Roberta pitching her losing spade, leaving just one more hurdle.
Roberta led a low club from dummy, hoping to see the King. When I played the ♣6, she stopped to count. She knew from the bidding that East likely held 5 or 6 diamonds, exactly 4 hearts, probably 3 spades and at least one club. That accounted for 13 or 14 cards, which meant East had 5 diamonds and a singleton club. To test check: that would give West 4 spades, 2 hearts and 6 diamonds, plus the stiff ♣K. Could West be 5=2=6=0? Perhaps, but she sensed that was less likely.
Roberta crowed triumphantly as she played the ♣A, crashing West’s King, and proudly announced that even she knew the “Rabbi’s Rule,” i.e., whenever the King is singleton offside, play the Ace. She ruffed her 2nd diamond in dummy, and claimed +1540, which would have been a cold top at our club (99% in the Common Game). Her 14 HCP slam had succeeded!
I asked Roberta why she thought others went down in 6♣ after a diamond lead. Her response: either they decided to take the club finesse since East had opened, or more likely, the declarers were too focused on diamond ruffs and didn’t consider that they might have a way to make 12 tricks, but only if they started hearts immediately after ruffing the opening lead, as she had done.
Postmortem: Roberta pointed out that a somewhat unlikely spade lead would have beaten the contract, but even a vulnerable 6♣x down 1 (-200) would have been a good score, since 5♦ was ice cold. Visualization of the play during the bidding certainly helped her realize that 6♣, either making or down one, would be an excellent contract.
I could have made life more difficult for Roberta by popping the ♥K at trick two. When hearts are played again and I follow low, she would have had to guess to ruff to pick up West’s doubleton Ace. Was she up to it? I don’t know for sure, but my red-breasted acquaintance had convinced me she was certainly no bird-brain.
|