|
Ask the Expert
You are White v. Red in 2nd seat (mps) & hold KQ A AKQ63 AJ1085. You bid as follows (no opposing bidding:)
2C - 2D (waiting)
2NT - 3H (spades)**
3S - 3NT
?
**Over 2NT, you don't play Puppet but do play Smolen, so partner has exactly 5 spades & has fewer than 4 hearts.
(1) Do you agree with your auction thus far or would you bid your hand differently?
(2) What would you do over partner's 3NT call?
John Dickenson. Tough question. If we do not have 9 top tricks I am afraid they will have enough hearts to set me. I will correct to 4S and hope for the best. I do see the need to open 2C but I would prefer 3D over 2D, my hand is far from balanced. Now over 3S I would bid 4C. This is a better picture of my hand.
Dennis O’Brien. I don't like the bidding as given. Over 2D I would bid 3D. If partner bids a major, I would bid 4C (natural.) If partner reverts to 4D I’d use Blackwood to decide between 5 or 6D. Otherwise I’d bid 5C to give partner a choice at the 5 level. I predict a wide range of responses to this problem.
Mitch Snyder. I'm tempted to open 1D and jumpshift in clubs. It's very unlikely to be passed out, i.e., that no one at the table finds a one of a major overcall. I'm not fond of the 2NT rebid, 3D seems better. In the given auction, I see no way forward to look for a minor suit slam, so 3NT it is.
Bill Bauer. (1) No, I would certainly bid this distributional hand differently. First, over 2D (waiting) I would rebid 3D. Partner is likely to rebid 2S. I would now bid 3C and see whether or not I get any interest from partner in one of my suits. Of course, I am feeling slamish. (2) I would correct to 4S. It is too late to show my minors at this point.
Elaine Clair. I agree with the majority, John, Dennis and even Bill🤪 on this one. I’m fine with the 2C opener but would then show D and C. With a fit in either minor suit a slam is a good possibility.
Email your questions, or a pesky hand, or something you’d like to know about bidding or playing to Toysie at toysiewalker@gmail.com. She will forward them to the panel, one will be chosen, and the question and answers will be printed in the following week’s newsletter.
|