|
Deal Analysis
by Mitch Snyder
Plain & Fancy
There is often more than one way to complete a task or reach a destination. Sayings such as ‘there is more than one way to skin a cat’ or ‘all roads lead to Rome’ reflect this sentiment. But sometimes the quality of the result is affected by the chosen route.
First, an admission, I am a fan of control bids in response to a 2C opening. For the uninitiated, an ace is worth 2 controls and a king, 1. A common set of control responses to 2C are:
2D: 0-1 control (no aces maybe 1 king)
2H: 2 controls (1 ace or 2 kings)
2S: 3 controls (1 ace and 1 king)
2N: 3 controls (3 kings)
3C: 4 or more controls (yes, it happens occasionally)
Using controls can benefit you by setting game/slam expectations early in the auction. A response of 2 controls or more is game forcing, so you can bid slowly to find the best spot. Sometimes you even know precisely which control(s) responder holds. For example, you open 2C holding 3 aces and 3 kings and responder shows 2 controls then you know it is the 4th ace. Downsides are that the auction can get out of hand if opener has to bid his suit for the first time on the 3 level or the contract ends up being played by the weaker hand.
The standard responses to 2C are 2D(waiting), 2H, 2S and 2NT. 2H/S/NT promise at least 8 HCPs and 2H/S also promise a 5+ card suit with 2 of the top 3 or 3 of the top 5 honors.
Today’s hand features a bidding comparison, (yep, you guessed it) between controls and standard.
Here are the east-west hands. West is dealer and all are vul.
|