|
Ask the Expert
From a reader...
You pick up this hand: J863 AJ AKQT T94. You are the dealer and the bidding goes:
1D - P - 2C - 2H
P - P - 3D - P
?
What is your call? If you didn’t pass over the 2H bid, what is your bid?
John Dickenson. Either I can’t count or this is a strong 1NT opener. A problem of the dealer’s own creation.
Mitch Snyder. This hand should be opened 1NT, avoiding a difficult second or, in this case, third call. Having more than partner suspects, I don't think passing over 2H is right either. If partner hasn't denied a 4 card major, 2S is right. Otherwise 2NT or double (support or value showing) could work. In the given situation, I'm going to follow Al Roth's advice to bid 3NT when in doubt.
Bill Bauer. A simple hand has been turned into a problem by opener's failure to open 1NT, the proverbial textbook bid. Now opener is faced with finding a rebid that says I forgot to open 1NT and we "experts" have been given that task. We will still be looking for that bid for the rest of eternity. With a gun to my head, I now bid 3NT. I now think to check to see whether the gun was loaded. And it was. I probably rebid 2S, rather than pass after RHO's 2H overcall. Now, for my nap after this tough work.
Elaine Claire. Since I seem to be the last one to see this problem, I have nothing new to add. I agree with Mitch and John on this. Once you don’t open 1NT, you leave yourself no rebid that describes your hand. A basic bidding rule is to think about your rebid before opening. This is a perfect example.
Dennis O’Brien. I agree that opener should have opened 1NT. Given the stated auction (I'm assuming 2C was 2/1) I am wary about 3NT given that responder seems to have 9 cards in the minors but it seems like the most likely contract to succeed.
Email your questions, or a pesky hand, or something you’d like to know about bidding or playing to Toysie Walker. She will forward them to the panel, one will be chosen, and the question and answers will be printed in the following week’s newsletter.
|