|
As dealer I opened 1C and Susan Morse responded 1H. I jumped to 3C thinking that was a slight underbid, but not wanting to reverse into a singleton diamond nor jump shift to 2S on a 3 card holding. Susan now jumped to 4D which in our methods sets clubs as trump and asks keycards. I responded the 4th step, 5C, to show 2 keys with the trump queen and she signed off in 6C. Opening lead was the spade jack and as Susan put the dummy down she hoped we did not miss a grand and perhaps should have continued 5D to ask for specific kings. I won in dummy perforce, unblocked the stiff diamond king and ruffed a spade, pitched my 3rd spade on the diamond ace and pulled trump – when the trumps split 4-0, there was no grand slam! My losing heart went on the diamond queen with the heart ace being my entry back to dummy.
As it turns out, if trumps break 2-2 (40.7%) or 3-1 (49.7%), we make 13 tricks – 6 clubs, 3 diamonds, 2 hearts, the ace of spades and a spade ruff in dummy. But on this deal, West held all 4 clubs behind declarer and the grand slam is doomed.
Should I have come up with a better rebid than 3C? Should Susan respond 1D initially and then bid hearts? I leave this for the bidding theorists to decide. As it stood, the other table did not get to slam and we won 10 IMPs.
Considerations
Minor suit slams are difficult to bid, even for experts. Roman Keycard Blackwood is pretty useless – picture Susan bidding 4N at her second turn and I respond 5D, 0 or 3 keycards, now we are above 5 of our trump suit and perhaps off two keycards. Granted on this particular auction and with Susan’s strong hand this is impossible but I can easily construct deals where you would have to bid slam off two keys if using RKCB. We play a system known as Redwood where 4D is keycard for clubs and 4H is keycard for diamonds and use the same 4 steps in response. Even the highest response, “2 with” is 5 of our trump suit and we can stop there if the keycarder has only one key.
To learn more about Redwood which is a subset of Kickback, click here.
Second hand I wish to present was a disaster for us.
|