|
Ask the Expert
Playing a team game, West holds 1094 QJ74 A52 843.
East opens 2NT in 3rd seat.
Playing Puppet Stayman, what should west respond holding this hand?
John Dickenson. If partner has 5 spades, at matchpoints 3N rates to take the same tricks as spades given there are no ruffing values in the short hand. If I am plus 430 and others are plus 420 that is a big win at matchpoints. OTOH at teams, I want to be in the SAFER contract, so now I would seriously consider trotting out 3C and raise to 4S if partner bids 3S. I risk a lead directing double of 3C though, and if partner does not have five spades I might get the only lead that beats 3N.
Bill Bauer. Although I am almost sure the hand belongs in 3NT, why not find out if partner has a 5-card major? So, I will respond 3C, Puppet Stayman. The real question is what do you do if partner rebids 3S? or 4S or 3NT with that square hand? I would still bid 3C, but with a bit more resolve.
Dennis O’Brien. With no ruffing value in my hand, I will bid 3NT.
Elaine Clair. 3NT with that flat hand.
Mitch Snyder. I considered 3C but I think just bidding 3NT is best.
Email your questions, or a pesky hand, or something you’d like to know about bidding or playing to Toysie Walker. She will forward them to the panel, one will be chosen, and the question and answers will be printed in the following week’s newsletter.
|