Originally, Evergreen residents, Antweilers, Fahnenstiels, Keifers, Wilkeys and several others were members at Bethlehem Lutheran Church in Lakewood, CO. Adele Fahnenstiel asked Irving if he thought they might be able to start a Lutheran Church in Evergreen. Irving spoke with the pastor at Bethlehem to find out how to go about it. He suggested Irving invite some folks to their home to see how many might want to have a congregation in Evergreen. So, the first meetings about Evergreen Lutheran Church happened at Irving and Gertie Antweiler’s home in June 1954 when Gary Antweiler was 7 years old.
There was a Norwegian Lutheran Church in NE Colorado (Brush) called Ebenezer Lutheran Church. They had a summer camp located above the town of Evergreen called Ebenezer of the Pines. On July 10, 1955, this small group of Lutherans met there. They put an ad in the local paper about this new congregation. There were 38 people who attended the first service. The following Sunday, July 17, the first officers were chosen. They were: Irving Antweiler, President; Bert Ranum, Treasurer; Ralph Evans, Secretary.
Pastor O. R. Graumann who was the Chaplain of Lutheran Hospital was asked by the Colorado District Mission Board to serve this new mission church. He continued on as Chaplain while serving this congregation until they had their own church building (1955-1959). Pastor Graumann’s wife also played the organ.
The congregation only met at the church camp during the summer of 1955. They had to be out by winter since where they met only had an old wood stove for heat and no back wall, so they got permission to meet in the grade school in the old brick schoolhouse which was located where the library currently is. Then they moved to the Junior High School which was located adjacent to the old brick school house (now the south parking lot of the library). Next they moved to Wilmot Elementary School. Later, they moved to the high school (where it currently is).
The church was growing and they needed a permanent home, so they got a loan from the Missouri Synod to start a building program. By this time, they had about 100 members. Ground was broken for the new church on October 27, 1957. The cornerstone laying ceremony took place on November 16, 1958 and the first worship service at the new site was conducted in the basement on December 7, 1958. The dedication ceremony and installation of the Rev. Frederick H. Worthman occurred on January 4, 1959.