Volume 04 Issue 05 | November 2019
November 2019 · Happy Thanksgiving!
Wilderness and Chocolate · ECW Podcast · Symposium Line-Up Announced · News & Notes
10 Questions with Steward Henderson · ERW News
From the Editor
My childhood smelled of chocolate.

I grew up in Hershey, Pennsylvania, in the 1970s. Although my childhood was not without its challenges, I mostly remember it as idyllic. (For a glimpse, check out this essay I wrote a few years ago ).

In the fall of sixth grade, I came home from school one day to find my street clogged with fire engines. Our house had exploded. Literally.

The accident ended our idyllic time in “the Sweetest Place on Earth.” We moved away.

I still have family in the area, though, so I make it back to Hershey once or twice a year, always glad for the chance to drive down memory lane. But of course, as the saying goes, you can never go home again. The town has undergone significant transformation to better accommodate the all-important tourist trade. Former cow pastures have disappeared beneath ballooning subdivisions. The store where I bought comic books is now a physical therapist's office. The old chocolate factory in the heart of downtown has vanished.

When I drive around, I clearly notice the many differences—but because I look through the rose-colored lenses of nostalgia, I mostly see what used to be. 

The willow tree in the cul-de-sac of my old street—long since been chopped down—still stands in memory, and I can see the eight-year-old me swinging from its whip-like branches. I can still see, too, the mudpuddles beneath the tree that, beginning in late fall, would freeze over with thin sheets of ice that my brother and I would rush out to break with our stomping feet. In the spring, we would race our bikes around that cul-de-sac, round and round like bicycle NASCAR and the playing cards woven into the spokes of our tires rattled like tommy guns.

A few years ago, the Hershey Civil War Roundtable invited me to speak there. As it happened, it was on my birthday, which allowed me to spend yet another birthday in a place where I’d celebrated so many happy ones. That talk ended up putting me in touch with some of my former elementary school classmates and that, in turn, led me to a 25th high school class reunion with friends I hadn’t seen since sixth grade.

Because of my Hershey connection, I’ve developed a warm affinity for the roundtable there. I’ve been fortunate to speak to them a few times since. (They pay in cholcoate!)

In mid-November, the folks from Hershey teamed up with the Harrisburg CWRT for a day-long bus tour with me of the Wilderness (with some overlapping Chancellorsville thrown in, too).

While it may be true that you can’t go home again, it was nice to have a little bit of home come to me.

— Chris Mackowski, Ph.D.
Editor-in-Chief
The Emerging Civil War Podcast
November 1862 saw the replacement of George B. McClellan with Ambrose Burnside. In the first ECW Podcast of November, Chris Mackowski spoke with Kevin Pawlak about McClellan’s tumultuous time after Antietam and the lead-up to his final firing.
 
The second ECW podcast for November featured a conversation Chris had with historian Emma Murphy of the Andrew Johnson National Historic Site. Chris and Emma talked about Johnson’s impeachment. Learn about the precedent and the process behind today’s headlines!

Subscribe for only $1.99 a podcast through the ECW Patreon page . Subscription fees help defray our operating costs and the cost of producing the podcast.
The Seventh Annual Emerging Civil War Symposium at Stevenson Ridge
By Kevin Pawlak

Planning ECW's next annual symposium begins before the previous one ends. Once we settle on the topic—2020's is "Fallen Leaders"—then the organizers of the symposium pull together topic proposals from other ECW historians. We debate amongst ourselves and select the speakers and topics based on a wide variety of criteria. Is this story well-known? Does it fit the overall theme? How do the ideas balance with each other? Who’s spoken recently and who deserves a chance in the spotlight?

After the selections are made, the chosen historians submit all of their marketing materials. Biographies, topics, and stories of many fallen leaders scream between inboxes back and forth across the internet before landing on the ECW online blog. 

But the job is not done there. With many more months to go, preparations will continue until the doors open at Stevenson's Ridge and ushers in the next ECW symposium.

Gordon Rhea will be our keynote speaker this year. He’ll talk about the loss of Jeb Stuart at Yellow Tavern.

We recently announced the rest of our line-up of speakers:

  • Edward Alexander
  • Matt Atkinson
  • Sarah Kay Bierle
  • Sean Michael Chick
  • Meg Groeling
  • Kevin Pawlak
  • Dave Powell
  • Dan Welch
  • Kris White
 
Additionally, Greg Mertz , National Park Service historian at Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania National Military Park will lead Sunday's tour on the wounding of General James Longstreet during the battle of the Wilderness.

The Seventh Annual Emerging Civil War Symposium at Stevenson Ridge will be held Aug. 7-9, 2020. Early bird tickets are $155 now through December 31. The regular ticket price, beginning January 1, 2020, will be $175. You can order tickets or find out more information here
ECW News and Notes

Chris Mackowski  and  Dave Powell  traveled to California in November to serve as the keynote speakers at the West Coast Civil War Roundtable Conference. Chris offered a talk on Burnside’s leadership at the battle of Fredericksburg and one on Confederate leadership at the battle of Chancellorsville. Dave talked about leadership at the battles of Chickamauga and at Chattanooga. ECW’s  Sarah Bierle  also spoke at the conference, where she addressed leadership at the battle of New Market. Meg Groeling attended. (see bottom photo)

Edward Alexander  spent a day on the battlefields of Petersburg with ECW’s friend  Brian Swartz,  the blogger behind Maine at War ( check it out here! ). Brian is working on a biography of Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain for the Emerging Civil War Series. (right)

Sean Michael Chick  has been on the speaking circuit. Most recently, he spoke about P.G.T. Beauregard and the battle of Petersburg to the Mobile Civil War Roundtable. Sean’s biography of Beauregard will be coming out this spring as part of the Emerging Civil War Series.

Doug Crenshaw  will be speaking on the battle of Glendale at the Powhatan CWRT in January and at the Richmond CWRT in February.

Jon-Erik Gilot  has published an essay in  Volume III  of the Journal of the Shenandoah Valley During the Civil War, published by the McCormick Civil War Institute at Shenandoah University. In "Hardships and Dangers Bind Men as Brothers," Gilot examines the 170th Ohio National Guard during the summer of 1864. You can get the journal at Amazon .

In commemoration of the battle of Franklin  Robert Lee Hodge  hosted two showings of his 74-minute Emmy Award-winning film “The Battle of Franklin” on Sunday, November 10. The programs included a brief discussion on the battle, the film, and preservation efforts; a succinct recital of soldier’s accounts of the battle by Franklin historian Thomas Cartwright; a 30-minute set by Nashville musicians Richie Owens and the Farm Bureau; and a showing of the film. The event raised $3,400 for preservation efforts in Franklin.

The pre-publication notice for  Dwight Hughes’ s Emerging Civil War Series volume,  Unlike Anything that Ever Floated: The Monitor and Virginia and the Battle of Hampton Roads , was featured for spring 2020 release in the Savas Beatie Facebook page. Pre-order this exciting addition to the ECWS today!

Dwight  was also recently invited by  The Civil War Monitor  to write a book review on “Our Little Monitor:” The Greatest Invention of the Civil War by Anna Gibson Holloway and Jonathan W. White (Kent State University Press, 2018). Look forward to his review in an upcoming edition of the magazine.

Speaking of book reviews,  Dan Welch  will have several book reviews in the coming issues of  The Civil War Monitor  and Gettysburg Magazine. Look for them when they hit the shelves. 

ECW's Chief Historian,  Chris Kolakowski  has some exciting news to share. He will be leaving his post at the MacArthur Memorial in Norfolk, Virginia, and heading to the colder and snowier environs of Wisconsin where he will take the reins at the Wisconsin Veterans Museums in Madison. Congrats, Chris!

On Saturday, November 16,  Chris Mackowski  gave a bus tour of the Wilderness battlefield for the Hershey and Harrisburg Civil War Roundtables.

Kevin Pawlak  and  Dan Welch  spent a day at Antietam National Battlefield, braving the cold, to bring more videos to ECW's YouTube channel. We'll have plenty of great videos on the battle coming out over the next several weeks so stay tuned!

Dan  had an article on the battle of Cedar Mountain published by the Essential Civil War Curriculum. You can find it here .

Eric Wittenberg  made a trip to South Carolina to do some field work on Sherman’s 1865 march through the Palmetto State. “The size and scope of the swamp associated with the Salkahatchie River was stunning,” Eric says, “as was the accomplishment of Sherman’s army in forcing passage of it.”
10 Questions...
with Steward Henderson
Steward Henderson is a Fredericksburg-based historian who specializes in the role of the United States Colored Troops in the Civil War. We first profiled him in the December 2016 newsletter . You can read his full Emerging Civil War bio here .

1) During the Sesquicentennial, you were exceptionally busy doing living history events and talks related to your favorite regiment, the 23rd USCT. You said you were going to slow down once the 150th wrapped up. But it seems like you've still been plenty busy! What have you been up to?
I had been working as a park ranger at the Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania National Military Park (FSNMP). After many of the seasonal rangers across the country were laid off in 2018 due to a paperwork change, I started to volunteer at the park again. I especially liked leading tours and talks and working at the battlefields. Additionally, I had been working on a Civil War medical and surgical project for the park and completed the first portion of that project. I continue to work with Chief Historian John Hennessy on tours and projects. I also continue to work at the park’s bookstores, where I am purchasing and reading the newest Civil War books, as well as reading some of the books that I do not own. This lets me continue to be at the park several days per week.

2) Why has it been hard to slow down?
It’s been hard to slow down because I have continued to be a living historian and reenactor for the 23rd USCT and the 54th Massachusetts Co. B.  We are still being asked to participate in many programs. I have not been able to do as many as I want, but I still do quite a few. I have tried to help out friends by participating at various Civil War battlefields, and I have participated in a few New Market Heights programs (for instance, I did the voiceover for the American Battlefield Trust’s Richmond Battlefield App for New Market Heights). I participated in the Appomattox Court House Lantern Tour. I was going to do the Cold Harbor Lantern Tour, but it was cancelled by inclement weather for the past two years. Spotsylvania Court House Battlefield had a living history audience-immersion event, in which the visitors got to follow the reenactors on Upton’s Charge of May 10th and the Battle of the Mule Shoe. A couple of us from the 23rd USCT escorted the Confederate prisoners to the rear.  

I fulfilled one of my bucket list items: I participated in the 155th anniversary reenactment of the Battle of Wilson’s Wharf at Fort Pocahontas, in Charles City County, Virginia.  This was the battle that I talked about at the 2017 Emerging Civil War Symposium. 

Speaking to various groups ensures that I am keep entrenched in the history of the Civil War. I constantly reinforce my themes and seek more information to add to my presentations. 

I have given lectures and speeches to the various organizations. At the University of Mary Washington Elder Study program, I gave a two-hour lecture, “Fighting for Their Freedom: The United States Colored Troops.” I gave a portion of the same lecture to the Powhatan Civil War Roundtable. At St. George’s Episcopal Church, I gave a lecture titled, “War Comes to the Church.” For the Hampton Roads Civil War Roundtable and two Senior Citizen organizations, I gave lectures on “The Importance of the Fredericksburg Area in the Civil War.” Plus, I gave several talks on the 23rd USCT at various churches, Juneteenth programs, Veterans Day programs, and Black History Month programs. 

I have acted in two of the skits in the first two annual “Fredericksburg Untold Stories” programs. Both skits were about the 23rd USCT.  Those skits have made our friend and Supervisory Historian, FRSPNMP, Greg Mertz a star actor! 

Another treat has been working with my fellow Emerging Civil War friends, Chris Mackowski, Kris White, Dan Davis, Phil Greenwalt, Ed Alexander, and Doug Crenshaw, participating in American Battlefield Trust Facebook Lives for Chancellorsville and the Overland Campaign. I cannot forget Garry Adelman and all of the energy he brings to the events. But the real star is Connor Townsend, behind the camera, who had to keep us crazy Civil War guys in line—and she did a fantastic job!

Finally, I had been asked to get involved in several committees in the Fredericksburg area: the St. George’s 300th Anniversary History Committee, and a Fredericksburg committee to decide what to do with the slave auction block. Just in the last month, I have been asked to serve on the City of Fredericksburg Memorials Commission and the African American History Committee.

3) Aside from the 23rd USCT, what are some of the other Civil War interests you've been pursuing these days?
I am researching and writing a book on the United States Colored Troops. I had long planned to do this, but I was happy just writing for Emerging Civil War. Then my wife, Malanna, several of my former bank colleagues, and some who know me as a Civil War living historian kept pushing me to write my book on the USCT. So, I am finally in the process of writing it.  

The 23rd USCT and 54th Massachusetts Company B (I belong to this regiment as well) have been asked for this year and next to participate in the 200th Anniversary of Israel Metropolitan CME Church (formerly Israel Bethel). One of the church’s founding members was Reverend Henry McNeal Turner, Chaplain of the 1st USCT and the first African American Chaplain selected by President Abraham Lincoln. We also hope to be a presence in the 155th Anniversary of the battle and surrender at Appomattox Court House next year.

4) You've pioneered something new at the Spotsylvania battlefield: instead of dressing in your park service uniform, you've been dressing in your Union uniform and interacting with visitors that way, appearing more as a living historian instead of just as a park ranger. What have those interactions been like for you?
FSNMP recently had a three-day planning workshop I was able to attend. One suggestion for the future was for a living historian to appear on the battlefields to interact with visitors. Since I was working the Spotsylvania Battlefield on that following Sunday for the park, I volunteered to experiment with this suggestion. That day was very enlightening. More visitors approached me in my Civil War uniform, as a percentage, than when I was dressed in my park ranger’s or park volunteer’s uniforms. I gave four 20-minute programs of the battle of Spotsylvania Court House and the role that the USCT played. I had several conversations of why I was there in my Civil War uniform. Next time I try it, I would do some first-person scenarios.  

I thought that it was good to pioneer this program because there were visitors who did not know that the USCT played a role in the battle. Plus I could talk about the 23rd USCT becoming the first African American regiment fighting against the Army of Northern Virginia.  

5) You've been doing some work with Fredericksburg Tours lately. Tell us about that.
Working for Fredericksburg Tours, leading private Civil War battlefield tours of the Fredericksburg-area battlefields, lets me keep doing what I love to do. People contact us, and I ride with them in their personal vehicle and give them a private battlefield tour in greater detail than I can give working as a ranger. The tours range from two to eight hours on a battlefield. Most tours I have led have been for more than one of our battlefields, usually lasting a day and a half to two days. Next year, we are going to add the Bristoe Station, Mine Run, North Anna, and Rappahannock Station battlefields. One day, I hope for a tour of Fort Harrison and New Market Heights in the Richmond battlefield!

I am creating a new tour for Fredericksburg Tours, “From Enslaved to Soldier.” This tour will be an African American History tour about slavery in the Fredericksburg area, the escape of 10,000 slaves during the first Union occupation of Fredericksburg, and the ones who return in the 4th Division of the IX Corps. The first tour is planned for February 22, 2020. It also is helpful that the City of Fredericksburg wants to encourage more African American history of the city and surrounding counties.

Lightning Round (short answers with a one-sentence explanation)
Favorite primary source?
Official Records of the War of the Rebellion.  I also like to read letters and diaries of soldiers who fought in the Civil War.

Favorite Civil War-related monument?
The African American Civil War Memorial and Museum in Washington, DC. It is dedicated to all of the African Americans who played a part in the Union war effort and pays tributes to the soldiers and sailors. The museum across from the monument is the home of all of the USCT living history regiments.

Favorite unsung hero of the Civil War era?
Frederick Douglass. He was the most important African American of the 19th century. He was an orator, author, abolitionist, and USCT recruiter.

What’s a bucket-list Civil War site you’ve not yet visited?
I would like to visit Fort Monroe to honor the XXV Corps, the contrabands, and Major General Benjamin Butler’s dedication to the United States Colored Troops.

Favorite ECWS book?
I still think the first one is my favorite,  Simply Murder: The Battle of Fredericksburg , because I think it made Emerging Civil War more identifiable and well known to the public. Look what has followed since it was written! 
Emerging Revolutionary War News
 
November saw some of the members of the Emerging Revolutionary War take their annual American Revolutionary War road trip. This year's agenda included sites both in the French and Indian War and American Revolution in New York and Vermont. Highlights included Saratoga Battlefield, Fort Ticonderoga, and the only battlefield in Vermont, Hubbardton. Check out ERW’s Facebook site for Facebook Live videos from some of these sites, and read the blog for posts generated from the trip. 
 
Plans are in motion, as well, for the second annual Emerging Revolutionary War symposium in partnership with Historic Alexandria. Updates are on the blog as well under the "symposium" tab.
Speakers Bureau Spotlight
Doug Crenshaw, a strategic consultant with the Commonwealth of Virginia, is an author, speaker, and tour leader specializing in actions around Richmond. You can read his full bio here .
 
Talks and Tours: 
·        The Seven Days 
·        Glendale: Lee's Lost Opportunity 
·        Fort Harrison and the battles of Chaffin's Farm 
 
Tours: 
·        Seven Pines
·        Hanover Court House,
·        June 1 at Cold Harbor
 
Descriptions about his talks and a full bio are available as part of the 2019-2020 ECW Speakers Bureau Brochure,  available here .
Upcoming Presentations
December 2019
5th: Sarah Kay Bierle, "Then Christmas Came: The Justification & Condemnation Of War In 1862," Cobb Civil War Round Table, Atlanta, GA

7th: Chris Mackowski, Civil War Historical Impressions annual party, Gettysburg, PA

9th: Chris Mackowski, “Plenty of Blame to Share: Ambrose Burnside and the Battle of Fredericksburg,” History Happy Hour Series, American Civil War Museum, Richmond, VA

14th: Dave Powell, Grant at Chattanooga, Kenosha Civil War Museum, Kenosha WI, 1-3 PM

19th: Phill Greenwalt, The Battle of Fredericksburg, Miami Civil War Roundtable (FL)

January 2020
11th: Jon-Erik Gilot, "The Battle of Philippi," Andrew Carnegie Free Library/Captain Thomas Espy GAR Post, Carnegie, PA

15th: Sarah Kay Bierle, San Diego Civil War Round Table

16th: Doug Crenshaw, "The Battle of Glendale," Powhatan CWRT 

February 2020
13th: Doug Crenshaw, "The Battle of Glendale," Richmond CWRT

13th:   Dwight Hughes, “Unlike Anything That Ever Floated: The USS  Monitor  and the Battle of Hampton Roads,” Civil War Roundtable of North Florida, Gainesville, FL

15th: Chris Kolakowski, "Civil War to World War," Louisville CWRT 

24th: Jon-Erik Gilot, "Hardships & Dangers Will Bind Men as Brothers": Mobilizing the Ohio National Guard during the Summer of 1864, Ohio Valley Civil War Roundtable, Wheeling, WV