Henrietta Cosentino
League of Women Voters Plymouth
323.868.3296

Mary Lampert
Pilgrim Watch
781.934.0389
Diane Turco 508.776.3132
Cape Downwinders

Mark DeCristoforo
MA Seafood Collaborative
973.610.1612

The Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection PUBLIC HEARING

THURSDAY AUGUST 24

Plymouth Town Hall

Great Hall 6:00 PM

To register, Click here for MassDEP form


Rally PLYMOUTH Town Hall Green 5:00 PM

The Next Step Is Up To YOU

COME TO THE HEARING

Stand Up! Speak Out !t Save Our Bay!

WCAI reports State Hearing Will Evaluate Plans at Public Meeting

 listen here


ANOTHER ACTION TO SAVE OUR BAY


WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD EXTENDED TO AUGUST 30


SEND EMAIL TO MassDEP IN SUPPORT OF TENTATIVE DETERMINATION


This past April, Holtec applied to the state Department of Environmental Protection for a modified Surface Water Discharge Permit as part of their plan to illegally dump over a million gallons of Pilgrim's radiological and chemical industrial wastewater into Cape Cod Bay. Dumping is the cheapest and speediest method to get rid of the contaminated water.


On July 24, the MassDEP announced their tentative determination to deny the state permit which begins the process to enforce MA state laws that prohibit Holtec's illegal plan. We applaud the MassDEP for their stand to uphold state laws that protect our Ocean Sanctuaries. With resounding public opinion and our elected officials against the dumping plan, including Governor Healey, we need to CONTINUE to strongly express our opposition.


As part of the process, MassDEP must open a public comment period. This is our opportunity to speak up and affirm support to finalize denial of the permit.

Written comments will be accepted until 5:00 PM August 30, 2023.

MassDEP encourages written comments to be submitted by email to massdep.npdes@mass.gov; subject line: Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station.


If not possible, please send by mail to:

Cathy Coniaris, MassDEP, 100 Cambridge St., Boston, MA 02114.

Full public notice here>>>

Sample:


Cathy Coniaris

Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection

100 Cambridge Street

Boston, MA 02114

massdep.npdes@mass.gov


Subject: Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station


Dear Ms. Coniaris:


I am writing to support the tentative determination by the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection (MassDEP) to deny Holtec’s application for a modified Surface Water Discharge Permit that would allow Holtec to discharge radioactive and chemically contaminated industrial wastewater into Cape Cod Bay.


MassDEP’s tentative determination that the requested discharge is prohibited by the

Massachusetts Ocean Sanctuaries Act is entirely correct. That act prohibits the “dumping or discharge or commercial, municipal, domestic or industrial waste” into an Ocean Sanctuary. Cape Cod, Plymouth, Kingston, and Duxbury Bays are all protected ocean sanctuaries under the act.


The MassDEP final determination must be to deny Holtec's application. Thank you for enforcing the law to protect our ocean sanctuaries.


Sincerely,


[name, address]

additional comment sample
addtional information
Full text here for MassDEP document
Full Provincetown Independent article here

OUR EFFORT TO PROTECT CAPE COD BAY and

OUR COMMUNITIES IS NOT OVER YET!


Holtec still plans to dump!


HOLTEC'S MENDACITY: Holtec claims that this MassDEP action is stalling the decommissioning. Actually, the company made a statement at the May 2023 Nuclear Decommissioning Citizens Advisory Panel that the work at Pilgrim is delayed for 4 years due to the drop in the stock market which impacts the Decommissioning Trust Fund. The tentative MassDEP action is a side bar excuse. Holtec has no other plan in place than dumping. Otherwise, this state action would not impact their time sequence to decommission as Holtec could have prepared for it.


Holtec Senior Compliance Manager David Noyes comments made it clear that money $$$$ is the driver here:


"The Decommissioning Trust Fund [DTF] did not grow at a rate compared to the costs of performing decommissioning due to the increased costs of labor and high inflationary costs. And as a result of that, in order to be able to continue to regrow the DTF and ensure we have the proper amount of margin [i.e.profit] to be able to complete the job, we are putting a 4-year hold on this key portion of the demolition activities."

click here for the NDCAP MEETING May 2023

See statement time at 1:36


Now, in response to the July 24 MassDEP announcement, Holtec International Government Affairs and Communications Director Patrick O'Brien plays the blame game: "We are disappointed by the state's denial of our permit modification for discharge of treated water from Pilgrim Station well within state limits. We will continue with the EPA modification process and will look to evaluate all options related to ultimate disposition of the water used in plant operations for the last 50 years. This process has already delayed the completion of the project for an additional four years, impacted the workforce on site and furher changes when the site can be returned to be an economic driver for the Plymouth Community."


Holtec has slowed down decommissioning work at Indian Point in NY and Oyster Creek in NJ. The April 5, 2023 Ashbury Park Press from NJ reports,

"Holtec officials explained the economic condition that led the company's decision to decide to slow down the process in a March 31 report on its trust funds to the Nuclear Regulatory Agency. The company cited "poor market performance and higher than usual inflation during 2022" as reported by Holtec spokesperson Patrick O'Brien. Full story here


Holtec has a history of "ignoring state authority", according to the New Mexico lawsuit [see below]. Also, Holtec plans to pursue a modified National Polliutant Discharge Elimination System permit via the federal Environmental Protection Agency.


The deal is not sealed until Holtec removes dumping into Cape Cod Bay as part of their business plan.

Until then, we must remain vigilant!

HOLTEC IS IN THE HOT SEAT FOR MISLEADING FINANCIAL STATEMENTS IN NEW JERSEY, MISUSE OF FUNDS IN MICHIGAN, ILLEGAL FACILITY IN NEW MEXICO, AND NEW YORKERS FIGHT HOLTEC'S PLAN TO DUMP INTO THE HUDSON RIVER


NEW YORK:

Citizens in New York continue to fight Holtec's plan to dump Indian Point's radioactive wastewater into the Hudson River, drinking water for over 100,000.

Read more here>>>


NEW JERSEY:

Former Holtec CEO Kevin O'Rouke files whistleblower lawsuit against Holtec for "false and misleadig statements".


"The financial projections could not possibly be completed accurately in the timeframe demanded by Defendant Singh, the document included numerous false and misleading statements, and legally the document could not contain “make believe” or unsupported financial projections."

See full complaint filed here>>>


NEW MEXICO:

The illegal Centralized Interim Storage Facility Holtec plans to build in New Mexico is rejected by the state government. The NM AGO filed suit. When Holtec came to Plymouth, Holtec PR Pat O'Brien presented to the NDCAP, "If all goes as planned, the waste will be leaving Plymouth by 2024." Misleading Plymouth area folks about removing the high level waste? It's not going anywhere.

New Mexico Lawsuit here>>>


MICHIGAN:

At Palisades, Holtec raided the Decommissioning Trust Fund of $44 million in the first six months of taking ownership - by their own admission no decommissioning work done at Palisades. Owners only need report DTF status once a year by March 31st of previous year ending December 31st. Holtec may have raided much more since then, knowing they only have to fess up once a year.

An email was sent to the NRC Office of Inspector General and Office of Investigations with the attached complainet by Terry J. Lodge, Esq. for Beyond Nuclear and Don't Waste Michigan

See letter of complaint/Request for investigation here>>>

Holtec plans for nuclear future in Plymouth?

Can nuclear energy help meet US climate goals?

Why China won't buy Japanese seafood if Fukushima dumps.

EPA letter to Holtec

AGO/Holtec Settlement Agreement

Dr. Ian Fairlie on Tritium

Plymouth Board of Health

Holtec CEO Singh letter to Senator Markey

The Bomb Next Door by Dr. Thomas Bass/The American Scholar

Boston Globe-In the shadow of the Pilgrim nuclear plant, EPA warning reverberates

Provincetown Independent-Legislation to stop radioactive water release fails

Provincetown Independent-Shape of Bay means poisons would linger

APCC Legal letter to the state

Save Our Bay MA

Cape Downwinders

Pilgrim Watch

MA Seafood Collaborative

Herring Pond Wampanoag

Sierra Club of Massachusetts

MA Lobstermen's Association

United American Indians of New England

Realtor Association of Southeastern Massachusetts

Greater Boston Physicians for Social Responsibility

UUMASS Action

Indivisible Outer Cape

Six Pond Association, Plymouth

League of Women Voters/Plymouth Area

League of Women Voters of the Cape Cod Area

Environment Massachusetts

Community Action Works

Clean Water Action

Sierra Club of Massachusetts

MA Peace Action

Facebook  Instagram