History of CTE as it relates to Tackle Football
As we navigate the complex landscape of youth football, the looming specter of Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE) casts an ever-growing shadow over the sport. For over two decades, I have echoed the concerns of the medical community regarding the unsettling correlation between repeated head impacts in tackle football and the insidious onset of CTE. The gravity of this condition gained widespread recognition in the early 2000s when Dr. Benet Omalu, a neuropathologist, unearthed the first case in an NFL player, Mike Weber of the Pittsburgh Steelers, during a postmortem examination. However, CTE's dark presence had already manifested in boxers many years prior.
Mike Weber's tragic demise ignited a profound sense of interest and concern, prompting intense scrutiny of the National Football League (NFL) and its policies. The subsequent multimillion-dollar settlement for NFL players and a surge in research intensified the investigation into CTE. The Center for Disease Control (CDC) has contributed valuable insights, exemplified by a study published in Sports Health. It exposes a stark reality –
youth tackle football athletes aged 6 to 14 endure 15 times more head impacts than their flag football counterparts during practices or games, with a staggering 23 times more high-magnitude head impacts. These impacts exponentially elevate the risk of concussions and other severe head injuries, particularly for our vulnerable youth.[1]
Amidst this backdrop, a potential paradigm shift is underway, fueled by new legislation in California. Intriguingly, Flag Football already boasts more participants in the 6-12 age group in America than tackle football. [2]Over a million children engage in youth sports flag football leagues, dwarfing the 724,000 in tackle football in 2022 (Sports and Fitness Industry Association). The momentum toward a ban on tackle football for children under 12 in California is gaining traction, driven by advocates determined to shield kids from the insidious specter of brain damage. This legislation, if passed, would position California as the pioneering state to prohibit tackle football for youths under 12, marking a watershed moment despite previous setbacks in similar attempts in California, New York, and Illinois.
Opposition to CA’s Proposed Tackle Football Legislation
Yet, a chorus of opposition, primarily from coaches, argues that such a ban would rob youths of a vital source of physical activity. The rationale behind advocating for change is unequivocal. A wealth of research, articulated by Chris Nowinski, CEO of the Concussion Legacy Foundation, attests that tackle football induces brain damage, with the risk escalating proportionally to the duration of play. Chronic blows to the head give rise to Traumatic Encephalopathy, resulting in the irreversible death of nerve cells in the developing brains of our youth. Should this legislation pass, California stands poised to become the pioneer in prohibiting tackle football for youths under 12, marking a watershed moment despite previous setbacks in similar attempts in California, New York, and Illinois.
| 
