|
Plastic Waste Trade Watch
November 2023
| |
Plastic Waste Trade Watch is a monthly review of information on the international trade in plastic waste. It is produced by Basel Action Network's (BAN) Plastic Waste Transparency Project, which undertakes campaigns, networking, research, and statistical analysis of the trade in plastic waste. The project also maintains the Plastic Waste Transparency Hub on the BAN website, which serves as an overall clearinghouse for News, Data, Campaigns, and Resources.
To join or sign up new members to the Plastic Waste Trade Watch, click here.
| |
Nairobi, Kenya. The plenary at the third meeting of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee (INC) to craft a legally binding global agreement on plastic pollution. Delegates from governments and observers from NGOs, industry groups, and other stakeholders made little progress during the week, with a group of “like-minded” plastic-producing countries stalling and not allowing any progress on the text or any intercessional work to take place before the next meeting, scheduled in April 2024. (Photo credit: Fenceline Watch) | |
|
Latest export data shows EU is flooding Asia and Turkey with plastic waste
Key Message: OECD countries promoting the “circular economy of plastics” myth are the largest plastic waste exporters, proving it to be a false concept as they cannot manage their own plastic waste.
EU continues to increase plastic waste exports to Asia. Total EU exports to non-OECD countries rose to 58.9 million kg/month in August 2023 from 28 million kg/month in May 2022. Exports to non-OECD countries:
- Germany: 18.0 million kg/month (September 2023)
- Netherlands: 17.5 million kg/month (August 2023)
- Spain: 9.4 million kg/month (July 2023)
- Belgium: 8.3 million kg/month (August 2023)
- Italy: 3.8 million kg/month (July 2023)
EU continues to flood Turkey with plastic waste. EU exported 24 million kg/month in August 2023 to Turkey. This is equal to 148 trucks of plastic waste per day.
Japan continues to flood Asia with plastic waste. Japan exported 49.1 million kg/month in September 2023 to non-OECD countries. This is equal to 308 shipping containers of plastic waste per day.
Australia continues high plastic waste exports to Asia. Australia exported 5.8 million kg/month in September 2023 to non-OECD countries.
Check here for these annual summaries and the latest monthly data.
| |
Check here for annual summaries and the latest monthly data. | |
|
“Too many of the delegates from around the world are still suffering from the false narrative sold by the plastics industry for decades: ‘Don’t worry, we just have to do more recycling and everything will be alright.’ But we now know that plastic recycling is harmful to people and the planet, and plastic must not be considered as a material eligible for inclusion in the circular economy. Plastics contain toxic chemical additives that should not under any circumstances be given a new and unpredictable life in recycled material. Further, the use, washing, and processing of plastics release microplastic contaminants into our environment and indeed into our bodies with the likelihood of frightening health impacts including neurological disease and cognitive decline. The new treaty on plastic must not in any respect promote the false narrative that plastic is a benign material and its recycling is good for the environment. If perpetuated, this myth will threaten our very existence.”
-- Jim Puckett, Basel Action Network’s Executive Director and Founder, on the recent third meeting of the INC in Nairobi toward a Global Plastics Treaty.
“Plastics act as a Trojan horse, absorbing chemicals in contact with them, with the potential for these compounds to be later released into the environment.”
-- Dr. Eric Carmona Martinez in an interview with Environmental Health News, co-author of a new study that found that recycled plastics contain more chemicals than original plastics.
| |
Despite some countries’ opinion that the Global Treaty on Plastic Pollution should not address trade during the recent INC-3 negotiations, trade provisions are essential for the success of the treaty and its implementation, as plastic is largely traded internationally. Without these provisions, the instrument would be weak, full of loopholes, and lead to fragmentation. Trade provisions can help ensure that treaty obligations are not inadvertently violated and undermined. (Graphic Source: #BreakFreeFromPlastic) | |
|
EU further cracks down on the export of plastic wastes
On November 16, the European Union’s trialogue negotiations (European Parliament, Council, and Commission) finally culminated with a provisional agreement to update the Waste Shipment Regulation (WSR), a process that began three years earlier. The EU had already gone beyond the Basel Convention to ban the export of mixed and dirty plastics to non-OECD countries, controlled by the Basel Convention as Y48 plastics. Last week, the EU expanded that ban to include all plastic wastes, including the non-hazardous category B3011, the movement of which the Basel Convention does not normally control, let alone ban. This additional plastic waste export ban will enter into force within 2.5 years. Five years after it entered into force, it will allow one narrow exception for non-OECD countries that can meet stringent waste management standards, which is unlikely to be possible for most non-OECD countries.
Further, because of numerous reports of highly polluting recycling operations in Turkey (an OECD country receiving 35% of EU plastic wastes), the EU will make it mandatory for all exports of plastic scrap to OECD countries to be subject to the prior-informed-consent (PIC) control procedure, which requires full transparency over the destination facility with no export allowed unless the receiving government authorizes the shipment. Additionally, non-recyclable contamination beyond 2% of the total load for those shipments is not permitted. The OECD exports will be scrutinized by the European Commission within two years and will be also subject to an export ban if found to not be treated in an environmentally sound manner. Further, OECD shipments must not adversely impact the management of domestic waste and cannot be transshipped to third countries.
In sum, the EU will be managing plastic waste far more strictly than any other waste stream, aiming to control its trade regardless of whether or not it is going to developing countries or whether it is hazardous. With respect to exports to non-OECD countries, a de facto ban is now in place, ending more than 30 years of the EU exporting tens of millions of tonnes of plastic waste to countries such as China, Malaysia, and Vietnam.
The narrow exception on the non-OECD country ban allows countries to apply to receive plastic wastes after five years if they can demonstrate that they have a comprehensive waste management system in place that covers their entire territory and can effectively ensure separate collection of plastics in municipal solid waste. They must also have a legal framework in place for waste which includes a prohibition of open burning and of uncontrolled landfilling of waste, a prohibition of incineration and of landfilling of separately collected plastic waste, and strict provisions on enforcement, inspection, and penalties designed to ensure the implementation of the provisions in points above. Finally, the imports of plastic from the EU can only be allowed if it can be demonstrated that the imports do not have any adverse effects on the management of plastic waste generated in the country.
Within the European Union, shipments can only be allowed to go to permitted facilities. In several instances, the EU has deviated from the Basel Convention for Basel-controlled plastic waste (Y48), such as PVC, and allowed such wastes to be traded without prior informed consent within Europe. Such deviations are not in fact legal under the terms of the Basel Convention's Article 11, which allows agreements between countries to have separate agreements as long as they are as environmentally sound. The EU agreement with respect to intra-EU trade unfortunately allows an illegal loophole.
While these gains are difficult to describe as “no exception bans,” they do ramp up control significantly to all countries of the world, making Europe the region with the most responsive and responsible export controls globally. In most cases, they are de facto bans and, if enforced, are going to seriously change the waste market. Ground-truthing and “citizen enforcement” by NGOs will still be vital, but finally there will be the necessary scrutiny by the European Commission and EU member states to counter the ugly reality of exports for plastic recycling: contaminated streams and very partial and dirty recycling.
“Many of us living in non-OECD countries face relentless illegal dumping, open burning, and microplastic pollution in the vicinity of plastic recycling facilities,” says Pui Yi, BAN’s Malaysia-based Plastic Waste Trade Campaigner. “We are reassured that the EU has heard our pleas and is acknowledging the horrific impacts caused by the over-consumption of plastic and the export of its waste. Time is ripe for other high-income countries to also take responsibility – the US, the United Kingdom, and Japan, among others. We look forward to a world where countries focus on reducing plastic production and waste, instead of sending waste abroad. We stand in solidarity with OECD recipients of EU plastic waste, where evidence of pollution and harm caused by imported plastic waste has been clear.”
INC-3 makes little progress toward Plastics Treaty
The third meeting (INC-3) of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee to craft a legally binding treaty on ending plastic pollution, held for from November 13 – 19 in Nairobi, Kenya, resulted in a compilation of member states’ preferences but little agreement on how (or even if) to address the problem. Delegates from 161 countries spent almost the entire week opining on the "Zero Draft,” which was prepared following INC-2 by the Chair and based on submissions from delegates and observers. The zero draft contained promising provisions with options from higher to lower ambition over a wide variety of areas like trade controls, the elimination of chemicals and polymers of concern, dumped fishing gear, and microplastic pollution.
While the zero draft was a great leap forward in terms of framing the various articles that would be needed to address the plastic crisis, the delegates could not make any progress beyond it. Instead of honing down the options, Member States expanded them, sometimes turning three options per provision into as many as eighteen. Nevertheless, several countries and regions, in particular, countries in Africa, the South Pacific, Latin America, and Europe deserve recognition. They stood steadfast in their strong call for key elements to properly address the crisis upstream by preventing more plastic products and toxic additives from being produced and utilized and thus tackling the crisis at its source. They refused to pretend further that we will be able to recycle our way out of our massive overconsumption of plastic.
However, the “low, to no ambition” countries that pushed for no action or the weakest of options prevailed, not allowing advancement of the text or even allowing the Parties to conduct any intercessional work to prepare for the next meeting (INC-4), scheduled for April 2024 in Ottawa, Canada. It is becoming far clearer that these countries, which include Russia, Saudi Arabia, Iran and India, believe that controlling plastic pollution is a much greater existential threat to their fossil fuel industry’s profits than plastic pollution is to life itself on Earth. In fact, a CIEL analysis published during the talks found that the number of fossil fuel and chemical industry lobbyists outnumbered the delegates from 70 countries combined.
By the end of INC-3, we are no closer to achieving any necessary action that might allow us to claim even a partially successful treaty. With only two more projected INCs to go, the high-ambition countries will have to strongly reject the bad-faith non-negotiation tactics of these few countries, as they clearly aim only to block progress toward solving one of the most serious environmental threats of our age.
| | The BAN delegation at INC-3 in Nairobi, Kenya. From left to right, Jim Puckett (Founder and Executive Director), Pui Yi Wong (Plastic Waste Trade Campaigner), Salomé Stähli (Plastic Waste Trade Campaigner) and Yuyun Iswamati Drwiega (BAN Board member and Co-founder and Senior Advisor of Nexus3 Foundation). | Jim Puckett intervenes on behalf of BAN at INC-3. | |
|
EU-Mercosur deal will encourage plastics trade
A Greenpeace analysis of the trade agreement currently being negotiated between the EU and the four South American nations known as Mercosur (Brazil, Argentina, Paraguay, and Uruguay) reveals that it will eliminate tariffs on EU exports of throwaway plastic products. Many of the products in this proposal are currently banned in the EU, like single-use plastic cutlery and food containers made of expanded polystyrene, and encouraging their export to other countries while not allowing them within their borders only seeks to capitalize on their inevitable environmental harm. The deal would also gradually eliminate tariffs on plastic scrap exports of PET, PVC, and other polymers over ten years, though the recent ban announced on exports of non-hazardous plastic waste to non-OECD countries within the updated Waste Shipment Regulation may make this tariff elimination a moot point. However, within that ban, there is a provision that allows non-OECD countries to submit a request to the European Commission indicating their willingness to import EU plastic waste if they fulfill strict waste management standards, after five years of the ban going into effect, which for the Mercosur countries would then be tariffed at lower and lower rates.
New York sues PepsiCo over plastic waste
New York state has filed a lawsuit against PepsiCo and its Frito-Lay subsidiaries that the excessive quantities of packaging from its soda and snack food products are creating a public nuisance by polluting the Buffalo River. As some of this huge amount inevitably ends up in the river when they are discarded, the company is damaging the environment, according to the lawsuit. While the company has made pledges to reduce its plastic use, the lawsuit further alleges that the opposite is occurring and the company is misleading the public about its efforts. In a 2022 survey, out of nearly 2,000 pieces of plastic found in the river with a brand label, 17.1% were produced by PepsiCo, with the next brand most prominent brand (McDonald’s) distantly behind. The lawsuit seeks financial penalties and restitution from the company and wants to force PepsiCo to both warn its customers of the health and environmental risks of its packaging and to develop a plan to keep the trash out of the Buffalo River.
| |
|
Court ruling undermines Canadian single-use plastic ban
With the second phase of Canada’s single-use plastic ban to enter into force next month, a Federal Court judge has ruled the government’s classification of all plastic items as toxic to be “unreasonable and unconstitutional.” This distinction was key to the ban on plastic items like straws and shopping bags, as it allowed the federal government to regulate the substances under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act. The case was brought by the Responsible Plastic Use Coalition, an industry group comprised of chemical and packaging companies like Dow and LyondellBasell, which argued that not enough scientific evidence had been provided to justify the regulations. The federal government is planning to appeal the decision.
| |
Basel Implementation News | |
Contamination Levels
The Basel Convention's 2019 Plastic Waste Amendments utilize the term "almost free from contamination" as one criterion for whether the plastic waste shipment will be uncontrolled. This term has not been given an international quantitative value, leaving the Parties to define it on a national basis. Enclosed are the known levels adopted by certain countries to date. If readers know of other country interpretations, please let us know.
| |
|
-- Airborne hydrophilic microplastics in cloud water at high altitudes and their role in cloud formation – Report by Yize Wang, Hiroshi Okochi, Yuto Tani, Hiroshi Hayami, Yukiya Minami, Naoya Katsumi, Masaki Takeuchi, Atsuyuki Sorimachi, Yusuke Fujii, Mizuo Kajino, Kouji Adachi, Yasuhiro Ishihara, Yoko Iwamoto & Yasuhiro Niida
| |
-- Moving from symptom management to upstream plastics prevention: The fallacy of plastic cleanup technology – Report by Melanie Bergmann, Hans Peter H. Arp, Bethanie Carney Almroth, Win Cowger, Marcus Eriksen, Tridibesh Dey, Sedat Gündoğdu, Rebecca R. Helm, Anja Krieger, Kristian Syberg, Mine B. Tekman, Richard C. Thompson, Patricia Villarrubia-Gómez, Anish Kumar Warrier, & Trisia Farrelly | |
The Atlas of Plastic Waste | |
The Atlas of Plastic Waste is a collaboration between the Basel Action Network (BAN) and graduate students Matthew Gordon (Yale University) and Anna Papp (Columbia University). The project aims to harness human discoveries and inputs from satellite and computer technology to identify sites around the world where plastic waste ends up in the terrestrial environment. The goal is to raise awareness worldwide of the unsustainable characteristics of plastic and the large degree it has become an unwanted geographic feature of our collective landscape and Earth's biosphere.
We are soliciting submissions from each of you for the locations of plastic waste dumps to begin the creation of a global database of these sites. If you know of a major dump site (at least the equivalent volume of waste as a large city bus), please submit the information HERE.
We will use satellite data to view the user-submitted dump locations this data will, in turn, refine the satellite’s algorithm to find more sites independently/automatically. The Atlas will ultimately contain data based on your submissions to our entry portal, as well as verified new locations discovered by satellite.
Help us create and build this Atlas by inputting known sites in your part of the world and likewise tell your friends to join in from their corners of the world. Together we can make this Atlas a comprehensive global snapshot and help the public and governments better understand the severity of the plastic malignancy on the Earth today.
| |
Plastic Waste Transparency Project | | | | |