|
LEARN & GROW
INVESTOR QUESTION OF THE MONTH
Q: Can I emulate Amber’s impact by investing in mutual funds or ETFs sold in the public market?
A: Public markets can play a role in an impact portfolio, but their impact is less direct than that of private investments, for three reasons. First, buying shares on an exchange mostly moves ownership from one investor to another. Unless the company is issuing new shares, your money doesn't reach the business, and your purchase rarely changes how the company operates.
Second, impact in public markets comes mainly from shareholder engagement: proxy voting, shareholder resolutions, and dialogue with management.
Third, the most widely used ESG ratings measure something different from impact. They assess how environmental and social issues could affect a company's financial performance, not the company's effect on people and the planet.
Private investments can close these gaps. When you invest with Amber, your capital buys farmland that Amber leases to organic farmers, providing them land access without debt. The link between your investment and what happens on the ground is direct and traceable. Public investments offer liquidity that private investments typically don't, so many investors use both: public holdings for liquidity and engagement, and private holdings for direct, measurable impact.
|